Republicans Search for a Scapegoat After Midterm Collapse, With Senate Majority Leader John Thune in the Crosshairs
Key Takeaways
- •Conservative writer Nick Catoggio argues in his 'Boiling Frogs' newsletter at The Dispatch that the Republican Party needs someone to blame for its midterm loss but will not fault President Trump.
- •Catoggio says Vice President J.D. Vance and House Speaker Mike Johnson cannot serve as blame targets because Republicans are heavily invested in Vance and Johnson operates under the president's control.
- •The central accusation against Senate Majority Leader John Thune is that he failed to advance the SAVE America Act, a Trump-backed bill requiring proof of citizenship to register to vote.
- •Thune has not accepted responsibility, asking on Fox News what the party could have done differently, a remark his critics seized on according to a Yahoo News report.
- •Catoggio contends the defeat resulted from Senate Republicans offering no governing vision distinct from Trump's, leading voters to punish the party for the president's actions.

Conservative writer Nick Catoggio says the Republican Party is confronting an uncomfortable dilemma after its historic collapse in last week's midterm elections: the party desperately needs someone to blame, yet its ranks are filled with "dead-end Trump apologist[s]" who cannot bring themselves to assign responsibility where, in his view, it belongs. Catoggio made the argument in his "Boiling Frogs" newsletter at The Dispatch, the commentary site co-founded by Jonah Goldberg and Steve Hayes.
"You can't blame the man responsible. Your political identity, if not your entire personality, rests on the belief that saving the country somehow required handing over the Republican Party to a corrupt authoritarian game-show host," said Catoggio. "To fault Donald Trump for embarrassing the American electorate into painting the map blue would be tantamount to admitting you're an imbecile."
Nor can the party turn on Vice President J.D. Vance, he argued, because nobody pays attention to vice presidents — and because Republicans are almost as invested in Vance as they are in Trump. House Speaker Mike Johnson is likewise untouchable, Catoggio said, because "Johnson is less an actual human being than a sock puppet with the president's arm up his backside. Blaming him for GOP failures is like having a beef with Jim Henson and blaming Kermit the Frog."
"To find a useful scapegoat for the GOP's drubbing, you need to find a figure within the party who's in a position of power yet isn't ideologically aligned with the Trumpist project. There aren't many of those left. In fact, there's only one," said Catoggio — and the knives are already out for him.
The central accusation, he noted, is that Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota failed to pass the SAVE America Act, the Trump bill that would have required millions of Americans to produce proof of citizenship in order to register or reregister to vote. The charge lands on Thune because the majority leader effectively controls the Senate's agenda — deciding which bills reach the floor and which stall — so the fate of any White House legislative priority rests with him. As Catoggio observed, it did not matter that Trump's "own voters could have been hit disproportionately hard by the procedural burden" of such a requirement.
Thune, for his part, has not accepted blame. Instead, he went to Fox News to ask, "what could we have done differently?" — a question his critics seized on, according to a report carried by Yahoo News. Whether Thune or his Senate Republican colleagues offer a fuller accounting of the defeat — and whether they publicly push back on the blame argument or let it stand — remains unresolved as the party digests the result.
Catoggio called that a startling posture for a leader whose party had just absorbed "the worst electoral beating since Watergate." "There's nothing Thune could have done over the past two years to better serve his party or his country except stand around looking constipated while the president cannibalized legislative power, reducing Congress from a co-equal branch of government to a squalid Russian Duma?" he said.
In Catoggio's telling, Thune handed Trump nearly everything he wanted.
"On John Thune's watch, Trump launched a major war without congressional authorization, nominated laughably unfit cretins to lead the government's essential agencies, monetized the presidency for himself and every crony attached to him, and turned federal law enforcement into a vindictive joke. The Senate majority leader and his members did nothing about any of it and in some cases actively enabled him, like when it confirmed Pete Hegseth, Todd Blanche, and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to Cabinet positions," he said. "… By doing next to nothing to stop the president from governing America like a lower-IQ Viktor Orbán, Thune ensured that blame for an electoral drubbing would fall squarely on Trump himself …"
But doing next to nothing, he added, also guaranteed that voters saw no difference between Trump and his party's candidates for the House and Senate. That is why the blame fight matters beyond a single stalled bill: in Catoggio's framing, the dispute is really over whether a strategy of near-total alignment with the president left the party's candidates with no distinct case to make to the electorate.
"When I say that Republicans lost this election because of Thune, that's what I mean. He and his members offered no vision of right-wing government distinct from Trump's, so Americans quite reasonably punished them for the president's sins," said Catoggio. "… That's the way John Thune and his members wanted it. Blame them for the result."