NewsCryptoEnterprise Blockchain Is Ready for Its Second Chance

Enterprise Blockchain Is Ready for Its Second Chance

Author: Cointelegraph·

Key Takeaways

  • •The first wave of enterprise blockchain projects between 2017 and 2023 collapsed largely because blockchains lacked native privacy, forcing companies into slow and expensive permissioned workarounds.
  • •Roughly 18 enterprise blockchain ventures failed despite high-profile backers such as Deutsche Bank, HSBC and IBM, and the surviving firms reverted to conventional software-as-a-service models.
  • •Ethereum transaction costs have fallen from periodic spikes of $30-50 in 2020 to under a penny today, with capacity ramping toward billions of transactions per day.
  • •Stablecoin transaction volume reached almost $1.8 trillion in June according to Visa's onchain analytics, providing regulated onchain liquidity for enterprise commerce.
  • •Microsoft's Xbox smart-contract deployment cut monthly royalty statement access from 45 days to four minutes while handling more than 2 million transactions per day.
Enterprise Blockchain Is Ready for Its Second Chance

Opinion by Paul Brody, founder and chief executive of Nightfall Networks.

Do you remember Pets.com? The online pet-supplies retailer raised $110 million from Amazon and other investors to build a business where people ordered pet toys and dog food over the internet. The company then crashed and burned, and everyone learned what seemed like an important lesson: you cannot profitably ship a 50-pound bag of dog food to a customer’s door.

As online retail entrepreneur Ed Baum asked in a 2001 postmortem: “Did Pets.com’s business plan assume the invention of transporters to magically move bags of pet food without shipping costs?”

Whatever you do, please do not share that verdict with the people at Chewy — they might not realize their business model does not work. Chewy reported $12.6 billion in sales and $223 million in net income in its latest fiscal year.

The real lesson of Pets.com was never that shipping dog food was a bad idea. It was that the idea arrived before the logistics, customer habits and unit economics required to make it work. As it was with chew toys and dog food, so it may be with enterprise blockchains. Collectively, the crypto industry probably incinerated just as much money pursuing that vision between 2017 and 2023 — maybe more. But the dozens of companies that went after enterprise blockchain were not delusional; they were simply too early.

Why businesses need enterprise blockchains

The appeal of enterprise blockchain solutions is not hard to understand, at least superficially. Nearly all enterprise systems today tend to fail at the boundaries between companies, and there are two failure modes. Mode one — the original failure mode — is collaboration information that is constantly out of sync. In this world, enterprise IT systems are islands, communicating asynchronously with one another through digital text messages and emailed spreadsheets. It is cheap and easy to set up, provided you do not mind always having slightly wrong information.

Related: Privacy is missing ingredient for business blockchain adoption: EY exec

Failure mode two is the costly, real-time proprietary integration. Powerful industry leaders politely request their key suppliers and partners to join their closed but always-on networks. These integrations are very expensive, but they work well — leaving everyone with a kind of business version of Stockholm syndrome, in which you come to appreciate the thoroughness and efficiency of the digital chokehold you are in.

Blockchains offered a better path forward: shared information and business logic across an open ecosystem, promising all the real-time visibility and efficiency of a proprietary system without the lock-in.

Sometime around 2017, this started to look like a very obvious good idea. Investment poured in, consortia launched, press releases were drafted and released — and then pretty much everything crashed and burned. TradeLens, We.Trade, Contour, B3i, ASX Chess, Everledger: all came and went in just a few years.

Though there is much nuance to the details of each of these stories, they largely share one thing in common: they had to do unnatural things to make up for the lack of privacy available natively in blockchains.

Companies need privacy, not transparency

No company wants its competitors to see what it is doing in detail. In most cases, that meant building a private, permissioned chain and then doing lots of non-blockchain-like things to it and in it to try to keep information private. The results were uniformly slow and expensive, and they failed to gain traction.

It is hard to overstate the bloodbath of companies and startups that tried and failed to make enterprise blockchain work. A quick web and history search turned up 18 different examples, some of them well known. Many had big-name backers, from major banks like Deutsche Bank and HSBC to technology companies such as IBM. Pedigreed parents and big brands made no difference — privacy did not work, and the results were dismal.

The few survivors that remain have “de-chained” themselves — giving up the blockchain theater and reverting to a classic software-as-a-service (SaaS) model. Many companies that piloted these permissioned enterprise systems as users came away from the experience with a clear lesson: we tried blockchain, it did not work.

That is unfortunate, because everything is different now.

Blockchains today have scalability, privacy and liquidity

Blockchains have scale. In 2020, Ethereum handled 1 million transactions a day, and costs per transaction periodically spiked to $30-50 when demand was high. Today, most transactions are completed for under a penny, and capacity is ramping toward billions of transactions a day. Nobody talks about the “trilemma” anymore. Ethereum is decentralized, and it is scaled.

Related: Ethereum’s Glamsterdam upgrade launches on Sepolia testnet

Privacy is different now, too. While privacy is still not the default setting, a huge range of privacy tools and systems is now available, from privacy pools to zero-knowledge roll-ups — systems that can prove transactions are valid without exposing their contents — and full privacy chains. On top of that, Ethereum is building a range of tools that will add basic elements of privacy at multiple levels in the network. How quickly those tools move from roadmap to production, with upgrades such as Glamsterdam already testing on the Sepolia testnet, will be one practical signal of whether the privacy gap that sank the first wave keeps closing. The result: it is now possible to run business operations at scale with a high degree of privacy.

Finally, there is the money — and it is all moving onchain. Regulators around the globe have blessed stablecoins — blockchain tokens pegged to fiat currencies such as the US dollar — and the result is a tsunami of liquidity, with transaction volume reaching almost $1.8 trillion in June, according to Visa’s onchain analytics.

Combining the operational benefits of blockchains with the financial ones gives enterprises something they have never really had before: a single ecosystem where you can not only buy, sell and move assets, but also get paid for them.

The return on investment from every single component of this equation is big, and combined they can yield colossal advantages. McKinsey partners have even found that digital supply chain tools could make inventory reductions of 35-75% possible through better planning.

More conservatively, from my experience in the field, simply switching away from the existing cascades of spreadsheets and electronic data interchange (EDI) messages can allow firms to run most supply chains with about 20% less inventory at the same service level. That is worth billions in working capital in most industries. Much of that upside comes from replacing aging plumbing: EDI, a decades-old messaging standard, still carries much of the world’s cross-company purchase orders and invoices today.

It gets better from there. Smart contracts reduce the time required to handle many business contract rules from days to minutes and cut the costs of administration in half. Microsoft began moving its Xbox video game network onto smart contracts for handling royalties and cut the time to access monthly royalty statements from 45 days to four minutes — all while handling more than 2 million transactions a day.

And once you have inventories, contracts, purchase orders and invoices onchain, you can go after working capital directly as well. When you can prove your purchase order originates from a top-quality buyer, you can access credit for less. And when you have full visibility into inventory and delivery status, you can factor receivables immediately and efficiently.

The possibilities and the returns are big. The use cases are obvious. It is time to try again — and whether new deployments lean on public-network privacy tools rather than the permissioned workarounds of the first wave will show whether the Pets.com lesson has finally stuck.

Magazine: What Democrats’ US midterm sweep means for the CLARITY Act

About the author: Paul Brody is the founder and CEO of Nightfall Networks, a blockchain technology company focused on building robust privacy systems for enterprise users. He is the former Global Blockchain Leader at EY and the former Chairman of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance.

Source: Cointelegraph