White Evangelical Turnout Fell Sharply in 2026 Midterms, Weakening a Core Pillar of the GOP Base
Key Takeaways
- •Turnout among white evangelicals, long a core part of the Republican base, fell significantly below 2024 levels in the recent midterm elections.
- •Voting in 343 evangelical hub counties across 15 Senate-race states reached only 66 percent of 2024 turnout, while surrounding counties in those states recorded 78 percent.
- •The evangelical hub counties, located almost entirely in the Southeast from Texas to Virginia, are 52 percent white evangelical, compared with 13 percent of the U.S. population overall.
- •American Communities Project founder Dante Chinni said Republicans would have gained hundreds of thousands more votes had these areas voted at rates similar to their neighbors.
- •Some individual evangelical voters, including a longtime Kentucky couple who typically back the GOP, withheld support this year because they believed President Trump was too focused on enriching himself.

One of the most powerful engines driving the Republican Party for nearly half a century quietly ran out of steam this month, and the silence has shaken the GOP to its foundation, the Washington Post reports. Turnout among white evangelicals — long a key pillar of the party's base — fell significantly below 2024 levels in the midterms, and the areas where they live voted much less Republican.
It is difficult to quantify the contribution of the late Jerry Falwell Sr., founder of Liberty University and co-founder of the Moral Majority — the organization he helped start in 1979 to mobilize evangelical voters — whose coalition of conservative firebrands dominated national political debate in the 1980s and beyond.
Born in Lynchburg, Virginia, in 1933, Falwell Sr. was very much a product of the Jim Crow-era Deep South. In the 1950s and 1960s he was a rabid segregationist who railed against Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., insisting that “The true Negro does not want integration…. He realizes his potential is far better among his own race.”
Critics argue that Falwell's racism has long been part of the Christian Right and helped drive the Republican Party's Southern Strategy, which pushed segregationist Dixiecrats into the arms of the post-Lincoln Republican Party. They say it also helps explain why, in 2020, far-right white evangelicals “found President Donald Trump so appealing”.
But in a striking turn, the Post reports that even racism could not stir white evangelicals to pull the lever for Republicans this year. “Turnout rates among White evangelicals — a key part of the GOP base — were significantly lower during the recent midterms than in 2024, and people in those areas voted much less Republican,” the newspaper said, citing a new analysis.
Pollsters and political scientists are still digesting exit polls to understand the factors behind the historic Republican rout this month. Researchers at the American Communities Project scrutinized 15 states with U.S. Senate races that contain large numbers of what ACP calls “evangelical hub counties” — places, according to the Post, with “high concentrations of self-described evangelicals,” particularly white evangelicals. The ACP work covers those 15 Senate-race states and measures this November against a single benchmark — the 2024 presidential election — so it captures one cycle in one set of states, leaving the durability of the slide an open question as exit-poll analysis continues.
Those white “evangelical hub” counties sit almost entirely in the Southeast, stretching from Texas to Virginia. White evangelicals make up 52 percent of the population in those counties, compared with 13 percent of the country overall, according to the PRRI 2023 Census of American Religion, a national survey of U.S. religious demographics.
This November, however, the energy that kept those hubs sailing for decades dwindled to fumes. “The 343 counties’ vote was 66 percent of what it was in the 2024 presidential election,” the Post reports. “The turnout for surrounding counties in those states, ACP found, was 78 percent of the 2024 election.” The spread between those two figures — 12 points against the same 2024 baseline — is the measure of how much further participation fell inside the hubs than around them.
Enthusiasm in the heavily white evangelical areas “was lower than enthusiasm in other locales,” Dante Chinni, founder of the American Communities Project, told the Post. Had those areas voted at rates similar to their neighbors, he added, Republicans would have generated hundreds of thousands more votes. In statewide contests like the Senate races the ACP examined, those missed votes count directly against the party's totals.
The decline showed among individual voters, too. Paul Binford and his wife are Kentucky evangelicals who vote regularly and typically back the GOP. This year, though, they concluded Trump was too busy “enriching himself” to be an effective president.
“[W]e thought he might not sell us out, but he was [the] worst offender of all,” said Binford, 69.