US Consumer May Be Hitting a Wall: A Look at Eight Indicators
Key Takeaways
- •Consumer spending, which accounts for roughly two-thirds of US GDP, is showing early signs of fatigue according to San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly and the Oct. 14 Beige Book.
- •September's retail sales control group rose just 0.1% against a 0.3% forecast, and the personal savings rate fell to 3.8%, its lowest level since October 2022.
- •Bank of America cardholder data showed annual growth in per-household spending slowing to 5.8%, with trading down at its highest level since 2021, while Citi recorded a 6% year-over-year drop in luxury card purchases in September.
- •McDonald's posted a 0.2% decline in US comparable sales in Q3, its first since early 2025, and NY Fed survey data put the expected probability of missing a debt payment at 13.8%, the highest since December 2025.
- •This week's earnings from Walmart, Target and Home Depot, together with official October retail sales expected to show a 0.4% monthly gain in the control group, will offer the clearest check on household demand.

The old adage in markets — never underestimate the spending power of the US consumer — has been a remarkably reliable one. Time after time, American households have dug into their pockets and kept the economy churning. That reliance is structural: consumer spending accounts for roughly two-thirds of US gross domestic product, which is why even tentative signs of fatigue draw outsized scrutiny.
But never say never.
San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly remarked recently that she is "just starting to hear the consumer may be running out of gas."
That comment may not constitute a red flag on its own. In the Oct. 14 Beige Book, the San Francisco Fed reported: "Retail sales softened slightly. Contacts continued to describe economic conditions as bifurcated or K-shaped, with one contact observing that mounting financial pressures on lower-income families have spread to impact middle-income households."
The K-shaped pattern is nothing new; in that same Beige Book, more than half of the districts said spending was being driven by high-income households. Still, with the election hinging on affordability, gasoline prices staying elevated and inflation biting, this would be the period in which cracks begin to show.
The week ahead offers the best check. Earnings are due from Walmart, Target, Home Depot and others, alongside official October retail sales, with economists expecting the closely watched "control group" to rise 0.4% month-over-month. Because those chains sell across categories ranging from groceries and general merchandise to home improvement, their results provide a company-level, category-by-category complement to the government data landing the same week. It could be the week Wall Street recognizes that, while it has been watching AI and the Anthropic IPO, the foundations of the US economy have been eroding.
For those who do not want to wait a few more days, the early signs are as follows:
- September retail sales control group rose +0.1%, versus +0.3% expected.
- The September personal income report put the savings rate at 3.8%, the lowest since October 2022.
- Bank of America cardholder data showed spending per household up 5.8% year-over-year in nominal terms, down from 6.2%, with lower-income households leading at 5.9%. Trading down is at its highest level since 2021.
- Redbook same-store sales were up 10.4% year-over-year in the week of Oct. 31.
- McDonald's Q3 report showed US comparable sales fell 0.2%, the first decline since early 2025; industry-wide fast-food traffic fell 2.6%, and the CFO was not forecasting a better fourth quarter. Management did report encouraging underlying traffic trends in October.
- NY Fed expectations data for October showed the expected probability of missing a debt payment at 13.8%, the highest since December 2025, while 45.3% of respondents see higher unemployment in a year, the most since April 2020.
- Citi luxury card data showed luxury card purchases down 6% year-over-year in September, following 4% declines in both July and August.
- The CNBC/NRF Retail Monitor released Nov. 11 showed October retail spending gained 0.2% month-over-month and 3.6% year-over-year, with the core measure up 0.3% on the month — the weakest monthly gain since November 2025. CNBC's own headline described it as showing "signs of strain."
The signals draw on different vantage points — official statistics, bank card aggregates, survey-based expectations and company reports — which is why reading them together offers a fuller picture of household demand than any single release.
For now, there are no clear signs of a cliff in the data, but this week's numbers warrant attention at least as close as that being paid to Anthropic's IPO.
Source: Investinglive