NewsMacroTrump DOJ's Noncitizen Voter Lists Included Birth Dates in the Future and Other Errors, Officials Say

Trump DOJ's Noncitizen Voter Lists Included Birth Dates in the Future and Other Errors, Officials Say

Author: Alternetยท

Key Takeaways

  • โ€ขA DOJ list flagged 81 suspected noncitizen voters in Santa Cruz County, but the county's senior election official said more than half were not registered there and some listed birth dates fell in the future, including 2044.
  • โ€ขPresident Trump claimed before the midterms that 250,000 noncitizens were registered in four states, a figure administration officials later characterized as a "ceiling" estimate rather than a verified count.
  • โ€ขUniversity of California data experts found that 42 percent of the names on a federal list of 20,000 "likely" noncitizen registrants in California did not appear on the state's current voter roll, and naturalized citizens were included.
  • โ€ขDOJ attorneys admitted in court hearings that the lists were flawed, and the department dropped its lawsuit against California, canceling proceedings Judge David Carter had planned to assess the lists' accuracy.
  • โ€ขIt remains unresolved whether federal officials violated the Privacy Act by using California voter roll data without required public notice, and congressional hearings under a Democratic majority are the main identified avenue for further oversight.
Trump DOJ's Noncitizen Voter Lists Included Birth Dates in the Future and Other Errors, Officials Say

A report published on Friday detailed the unusual measures the Trump administration took as it sought to substantiate its claims about noncitizen voting โ€” including, according to election officials who spoke with NPR, identifying suspected voters with birth dates that have not yet occurred.

In California's Santa Cruz County, senior election official Tricia Webber said her office received a list in the run-up to the midterm elections of 81 people the Department of Justice had flagged as suspected noncitizens registered to vote in the county. The United States has no federal voter registration database: rolls are maintained by state and local election offices, which put county officials in a position to check the DOJ's flags against their own records. According to Webber, the list contained multiple problems: "more than half are not registered in Santa Cruz County," "some names do not match any person currently registered or previously registered," and some dates of birth "were wildly inaccurate with some dates appearing well into the future like 2044."

Webber's experience was far from unique, per NPR's reporting. Ahead of the midterms, President Donald Trump claimed that 250,000 noncitizens were registered to vote in four states, including California. Once state officials began pushing back on the assertion, administration officials acknowledged that the figure represented what they considered the "ceiling" of potential noncitizen voters rather than a verified count.

In mid-October, federal officials sent California a list of what they said were 20,000 "likely" noncitizens registered to vote in the state. After a federal judge allowed data experts from the University of California to analyze the list in the final days before the midterms, their review found that 42 percent of the names did not appear on California's current voter roll and that naturalized citizens were included on the list. Several California counties also pointed out that the lists were riddled with duplicates and obvious inaccuracies, including the 2044 birth dates.

Even DOJ attorneys have admitted in court hearings, under questioning from judges, that the lists are flawed. According to NPR, U.S. District Judge David Carter, a Clinton nominee who was presiding over the federal government's lawsuit against California, had planned to hold proceedings to assess the accuracy of the DOJ's lists. Those proceedings will no longer take place, however, as the DOJ has dropped its lawsuit.

Questions also remain about the legal basis for the effort. Enacted in 1974, the Privacy Act governs how federal agencies collect, maintain, and disclose individuals' records, including public-notice requirements before data is put to new uses. According to Loyola Law School professor Justin Levitt, it is unresolved whether federal officials violated the Privacy Act by using California voter roll data to create the lists without following required public notice procedures.

David Becker, executive director of the Center for Election Innovation and Research, said lawmakers could hold hearings to determine how the Trump administration produced its list once a Democratic majority assumes control of Congress. With the DOJ having dropped its lawsuit and the court review Judge Carter had planned now canceled, such hearings are the oversight avenue so far identified for publicly examining how the lists came together. "I think we're going to have some very serious scrutiny of the Department of Homeland Security and their methodology as they assisted the administration in its failed effort to try to demonstrate there was widespread noncitizen voting in this country," Becker said.