NewsMacroToilet Paper Returns as a Political Problem for Trump as Canadian Retaliatory Tariffs Take Effect

Toilet Paper Returns as a Political Problem for Trump as Canadian Retaliatory Tariffs Take Effect

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •Canada will impose retaliatory tariffs on nearly 900 American products starting September 8, including a 25% duty on U.S. toilet paper and facial tissue and 50% on paper towels, napkins, and raw wood pulp.
  • •The U.S. invoked Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, a largely dormant Depression-era law, to place a 50% tariff on roughly $20 billion of Canadian goods after trade talks broke down.
  • •Canada was the largest foreign supplier of toilet paper to the U.S. in 2024 at $328 million, and U.S. mills buy about 2 million tons of Canadian NBSK pulp annually, meaning tariffs raise costs on both finished goods and inputs.
  • •Procter & Gamble reports a roughly $0.25-per-share earnings headwind from tariffs and is raising prices, while Federal Reserve research shows full pass-through of tariff costs to consumers.
  • •Ahead of the midterms, only 39% of Americans approve of Trump's job performance and 30% approve of his inflation handling, with 31% citing inflation and prices as their top concern.
Toilet Paper Returns as a Political Problem for Trump as Canadian Retaliatory Tariffs Take Effect

Six years after pandemic-era panic buying emptied supermarket shelves, toilet paper is once again a kitchen table issue for President Donald Trump—this time because of tariffs.

After trade talks between the U.S. and Canada broke down in late August 2026, Washington imposed a 50% tariff on roughly $20 billion (C$27.6 billion) of Canadian goods under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930—a Depression-era law that allows the president to retaliate against countries seen as discriminating against U.S. commerce. It is a provision that had sat largely dormant for decades, and its use here marks one of the most aggressive unilateral tariff actions of Trump's second term. In response, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney vowed to match the United States "dollar for dollar" and unveiled retaliatory tariffs on close to 900 American products, set to take effect September 8. Chief among them: toilet paper and other paper products.

"Canada will match those tariffs dollar for dollar," Carney said two weeks ago. "Because we were attacked. Like, you're at war when you get attacked."

What the Tariffs Cover

Paper goods are among the hardest hit. Canada's retaliation imposes a 25% duty on U.S. toilet paper and facial tissue, and a 50% duty on paper towels, napkins, and raw wood pulp. The measures extend beyond paper: Canada is also charging 50% on American dairy products (except cheese, which gets 25%) and 25% on American fish and seafood, including frozen lobster—a move that drew criticism from Maine Senator Susan Collins.

The Canadian measures respond to U.S. tariffs, including a 25% tariff on Canadian cars and auto parts, which Trump is now threatening to double to 50% if no deal is reached by January 1, 2027. To soften the blow at home, Ottawa announced a C$7.5 billion relief package for small and medium Canadian businesses hurt by the standoff.

A Covid-Era Toilet Paper Shortage

The episode echoes March 12, 2020, when U.S. toilet paper sales surged 734% compared with the same day the year before, making it the top-selling grocery item that day. By the time the panic subsided, roughly 70% of the world's grocery stores had run out of toilet paper at some point. Shelves that normally held Charmin and Cottonelle sat bare for weeks as retailers imposed purchase limits, and bamboo-paper startups saw Amazon sales jump more than 5,000% month over month as shoppers hunted for anything they could find. Researchers who studied the episode afterward found no actual break in production—mills kept running. Hoarding, not a supply failure, created nearly all of it.

Eight months later, due to a confluence of the COVID-19 pandemic and his administration's handling of the virus, Trump lost the presidency to Joe Biden. Toilet paper did not decide that election, but it became a small symbol of an economy that felt like it was slipping out of a president's control just as voters decided whether to give him another term.

Americans make up just 4% of the world's population but use more than 20% of the world's tissue supply, burning through an average of 141 rolls a year—the highest rate globally, just ahead of Germany's 134. Six years after the pandemic, Trump is again confronting affordability and kitchen table prices as the midterm campaign season kicks into high gear.

The Supply Chain Dimension

In 2024, Canada supplied $328 million worth of toilet paper to the United States, more than any other country, and retailers like Costco source much of their private-label paper stock from Canadian mills. The supply chain complicates the dispute further: American factories rely on northern bleached softwood kraft pulp, or NBSK, harvested from Canadian forests, which makes up roughly 30% of a standard American toilet paper roll and close to half of U.S. paper towel production. U.S. mills buy about 2 million tons of Canadian NBSK a year. That means tariffs flowing in both directions touch the same product from different ends: Canadian duties raise the cost of finished paper crossing north, while U.S. mills face higher input costs on the Canadian pulp they depend on.

Procter & Gamble, which makes Charmin, said tariffs are creating a roughly $0.25-per-share earnings headwind and is raising prices on a portion of its product lineup. Americans are paying 96% of the cost of Trump's tariffs, and Federal Reserve research showed the tariffs are now seeing "full pass-through" to consumer prices.

The American Forest & Paper Association, which did not respond to Fortune's requests for comment, argues that any shortages would be localized rather than national. The group is nonetheless urging consumers not to stock up ahead of the September 8 deadline.

A Political Problem Ahead of the Midterms

All of this poses a problem for Trump: ahead of the midterms, his economic standing has slipped further than the White House would like. Just 39% of Americans approve of his job performance, and only 30% approve of his handling of inflation, with a 31% plurality naming inflation and prices as their top concern—17 points ahead of the next issue, jobs and the economy. Even Marc Short, who served in Trump's first administrations, said it is hard to argue that the tariffs are not contributing to the affordability problem. Goldman Sachs research found that the cost of living is voters' top issue at a higher share than heading into the 2024 election.

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.