NewsStocksTesla (TSLA) Shares Jump 5% as Q3 Deliveries Beat Estimates, but Jim Cramer Says the SpaceX Stake Matters More

Tesla (TSLA) Shares Jump 5% as Q3 Deliveries Beat Estimates, but Jim Cramer Says the SpaceX Stake Matters More

Author: Blockonomi·

Key Takeaways

  • •Tesla delivered 486,532 vehicles in the third quarter, beating the analyst consensus of 461,974 units by roughly 5% even though deliveries declined about 2% year over year.
  • •Energy storage deployments totaled 13.7 GWh, falling approximately 14% short of the 15.9 GWh consensus estimate.
  • •Production of 464,391 vehicles came in about 22,000 units below deliveries, indicating an inventory drawdown that could have positive implications for cash flow.
  • •CNBC's Jim Cramer argued Tesla's core investment case centers on its SpaceX stake, which was created by converting a $2 billion xAI investment into a direct minority ownership position.
  • •Tesla's complete third-quarter financial results are scheduled for October 21, when investors will look for revenue, margin, free cash flow, and Optimus production timeline details.
Tesla (TSLA) Shares Jump 5% as Q3 Deliveries Beat Estimates, but Jim Cramer Says the SpaceX Stake Matters More

Tesla shares rose 5% during Friday's trading session after the electric vehicle maker reported third-quarter delivery figures that surpassed Wall Street forecasts. Yet according to CNBC's Jim Cramer, the stock's core investment case has little to do with vehicle volumes — and everything to do with Tesla's stake in SpaceX.

The company announced deliveries totaling 486,532 vehicles for the third quarter, a roughly 5% outperformance versus the company-compiled analyst consensus of 461,974 units. Results were particularly strong for the Model 3 sedan and Model Y crossover, which combined for 478,237 deliveries, ahead of both Tesla's internal consensus and FactSet's projection of 435,000 vehicles.

Delivery and production figures are released ahead of Tesla's full financial results, giving market participants the first quantitative read on the quarter. That made the headline beat notable against a softer backdrop: year-over-year comparisons showed total deliveries declined approximately 2% from the third quarter of the previous year. Nevertheless, the upside surprise relative to expectations provided sufficient momentum to drive shares higher.

Energy Storage Falls Short

The quarterly update was not without disappointments. Tesla's energy storage division failed to meet analyst targets, with deployments totaling 13.7 GWh for the quarter — a shortfall of approximately 14% against the consensus estimate of 15.9 GWh.

What Analysts Are Watching

Colin Rusch of Oppenheimer suggested the delivery outperformance could translate into improved operating cash generation and healthier gross margin profiles. He also identified Full Self-Driving technology as a possible catalyst for future unit demand. William Blair's Jed Dorsheimer highlighted the same positive delivery surprise while acknowledging the disappointing performance in the energy storage segment.

Tesla manufactured 464,391 vehicles throughout the quarter, a production total that fell approximately 22,000 units short of deliveries. The gap indicates the company reduced on-hand inventory, a development that could carry positive implications for cash flow generation. Oppenheimer noted it will monitor capital expenditure levels and balance sheet health in the upcoming earnings release.

Tesla's third-quarter financial results are scheduled for release on October 21. Market participants will be seeking clarity on the production timeline for the Optimus humanoid robot, as well as the company's free cash flow position. Because the delivery report covers unit volumes only, the October 21 release is where revenue, margin, and cash flow figures will fill in the financial picture behind the quarter's demand signal.

Cramer's Take Has Nothing to Do With Deliveries

During his broadcast, Jim Cramer presented an alternative investment rationale for Tesla shares, arguing that the primary growth opportunity lies outside the automotive division. He emphasized SpaceX as the critical factor.

Earlier this year, Tesla converted its $2 billion xAI investment into a direct minority ownership position in SpaceX. The transaction provides Tesla equity with indirect exposure to SpaceX's financial performance — exposure to a company that remains privately held rather than listed on a public exchange.

Cramer drew attention to the space company's growing computational infrastructure, which generates revenue through capacity leasing to third-party clients. He projected that SpaceX could experience significant earnings acceleration in future periods, and argued this development would strengthen Tesla's balance sheet and drive appreciation in the stock price over the long term.

Cramer also commented on the delivery results themselves, attributing the better-than-expected numbers partly to increasing gasoline prices, which he said are accelerating consumer interest in electric vehicles. As conventional fuel expenses rise, electric vehicles present a more economical alternative for cost-sensitive consumers — a macroeconomic trend Cramer believes contributed to Tesla's ability to exceed delivery projections.

Despite Friday's advance, Tesla shares remain down more than 15% year-to-date through 202. The Wall Street consensus rating on the stock currently stands at Overweight.