Terence Tao on Game Theory, Black-Scholes and the Limits of Economic Models
Key Takeaways
- •Terence Tao said AI has pushed mathematics from an era of 'proof scarcity' into one of 'proof abundance,' raising questions about whether video talks may become more valuable than research papers.
- •Tao endorsed game theory as a productive lens for pure mathematics, explaining that framing intimidating epsilon-delta statements as strategic games activates useful modes of thinking.
- •He said he uses economic concepts such as cost functions and loss minimization in his work and applies Ricardo's law of comparative advantage to decide how to spend his time.
- •Tao called the Black-Scholes model an 'algebraic miracle' for enabling option pricing from risk alone, but cautioned it becomes dangerous to use without Gaussian fluctuations, referencing the events of 2009.
- •In an accompanying note, Cowen described the episode as 'self-recommending,' said he deliberately downplayed AI because Tao has spoken on the topic frequently, and pointed to Tao's new book Six Math Essentials.

Economist Tyler Cowen has published a new episode of Conversations with Tyler featuring Terence Tao, widely regarded as one of the foremost mathematicians working today. The audio, video, and full transcript of the discussion are available on the episode page.
A Wide-Ranging Conversation
According to the episode summary, Cowen opens by asking Tao what it feels like to contemplate Euler's identity, quantum mechanics, the Riemann hypothesis, and Gödel's incompleteness theorem. From there, the conversation moves through why mathematical history tends to be stripped out of classrooms; whether abstract mathematics is a lottery ticket or a unified whole; string theory's beauty versus its lack of confirmation; why real analysis arrived so late; why zero took until the 7th century to be invented; game theory; the Black-Scholes model; Bostrom's simulation argument; Newcomb's paradox; mathematics education and the case for teaching more statistics.
A recurring theme is Tao's view that AI has pushed mathematics from an era of "proof scarcity" into one of "proof abundance," what that shift means for the research paper, and why video talks may become more valuable than papers themselves. The discussion also covers lighter ground, including Tao's favorite Hong Kong action movies, his unconventional path through an Australian university at age 13, his most unusual work habit, and his verdict on the Collatz conjecture.
On Mathematical Economics and Game Theory
Asked whether mathematical economics over the last two decades interests him as mathematics, or is simply a field doing work he considers low level, Tao said he has always been fascinated by economics, singling out game theory, the mathematical study of strategic decision-making.
"I love game theory, and actually often there are pure math problems where it's actually good to think in game theory terms. In analysis, you have all these complicated statements, like for every ε, there exists a δ, blah, blah, blah. It looks very intimidating, but if you phrase it as a game, your opponent is giving you an ε, you need to counter that ε with a δ of your own. If you view it as a game, then actually you can talk about strategies and who's ahead, who's behind. It actually activates really good modes of thinking."
Tao said he has used economic thinking in his own work, pointing to concepts such as cost functions and minimizing loss, and noted that he applies Ricardo's law of comparative advantage — the principle that gains come from specializing according to relative strengths — to his own life.
"There are so many things I can do. What do I choose to spend my time on? It's actually a very useful principle: comparative advantage."
He also described economics as "a very good arena to understand the difference between models and reality." In physics, Tao observed, "we're spoiled" because great physicists have produced highly accurate, well-tested models of the real world — classical mechanics and quantum mechanics — whose consequences can be explored while still predicting reality. Economics, by contrast, is "a much more mixed situation" in which models sometimes predict the real world very well and sometimes do not.
"In addition to doing the math, you also have to do the modeling, and you have to understand the limits of when a model starts breaking down and what you need to do to adjust it. I find that fascinating. It's somewhere between the hard sciences and the social sciences. There's enough hard models that you can do math, but there's also enough real-world messiness that you have to also grapple with the subjectivity. As an outsider, I find it a really fascinating subject."
'An Algebraic Miracle,' With Limits
The Black-Scholes model, a foundational framework for pricing options, is one of the best-known points of contact between mathematics and finance. Cowen asked whether Tao was shocked by the model's special property that probability does not matter, and whether he found it beautiful. Tao answered yes.
"There is a special feature of Gaussian fluctuations that you can price options just by knowing risk. There is one algebraic miracle that makes this work. Normally, predicting future costs of anything is just an intractable problem, and there just happens to be this miracle. If you have Gaussian fluctuations, then it is beautiful."
Gaussian fluctuations — bell-curve-shaped patterns of variation — are the statistical ideal that makes the model's clean pricing result possible.
Tao cautioned, however, that the result doubles as a lesson in knowing when financial models break down.
"This is actually a really good example of when you need to know when the models work and when they don't work. If you don't have Gaussian fluctuations, then actually Black-Scholes is somewhat dangerous to use, especially if you compound it into derivatives over and over again. Again, that's an old story. You know what happened in 2009."
The caveat amounts to a compact statement of what practitioners in quantitative finance call model risk: the possibility that a model's simplifying assumptions stop matching the behavior of the system it is meant to describe.
Cowen's Note on the Episode
In an accompanying note, Cowen described the episode as "self-recommending, and of interest throughout." He noted that the conversation includes some discussion of AI, but said he chose not to emphasize the topic because Tao "has spoken so much on that topic lately." Cowen also pointed to Tao's new book, Six Math Essentials.
The post first appeared on Marginal Revolution.