NewsMacroRetired Coast Guard Officers: Trump's Boat Strikes Are Unlawful, Failing, and 'More Troubling' Than Admitted

Retired Coast Guard Officers: Trump's Boat Strikes Are Unlawful, Failing, and 'More Troubling' Than Admitted

Author: Rawstory·

Key Takeaways

  • •Retired Coast Guard officers Stephen Chamberlin, Leanne Lusk, and Brian McNamara published an essay in Just Security arguing the year-long strike campaign against suspected drug smugglers is unlawful and ineffective.
  • •The authors contend the strikes stretch domestic and international law by treating suspected traffickers as military targets rather than criminals subject to law enforcement.
  • •Reporting cited in the essay indicates cocaine's price, purity, and availability in the U.S. have largely returned to pre-operation levels despite strikes killing hundreds of alleged traffickers.
  • •The United Kingdom, Canada, and the Netherlands have all curtailed intelligence sharing with the U.S. over the killings, weakening joint counter-narcotics efforts.
  • •Reports that two defenseless survivors of a strike were killed while adrift at sea represent a violation of the maritime principle to preserve life at sea, according to the authors.
Retired Coast Guard Officers: Trump's Boat Strikes Are Unlawful, Failing, and 'More Troubling' Than Admitted

One year into President Trump's campaign of military strikes against suspected drug-smuggling boats, a group of retired Coast Guard officers says the operation is not only legally dubious — it is "more troubling" than the administration acknowledges, and it is not even working.

In an essay published in Just Security, retired Coast Guard officers Stephen Chamberlin, Leanne Lusk, and Brian McNamara argue that the strikes represent something far more troubling than officials portray: an unlawful expansion of military force into what has always been a law enforcement mission.

The authors contend that suspected traffickers are, at worst, criminals — not combatants — and that treating them as military targets stretches both domestic and international law past recognition. The Posse Comitatus Act, a Reconstruction-era statute dating to 1878, generally bars the Pentagon from conducting civilian law enforcement, which is precisely why Congress has long relied on the Coast Guard — a military service that operates under the Department of Homeland Security and, uniquely, retains law enforcement authority — rather than the military, to handle maritime drug interdiction. That division of labor matters because it is what allows suspects to be captured, prosecuted in U.S. courts, and their networks mapped, rather than simply killed at sea.

Drawing on decades of combined experience running Coast Guard search-and-rescue and law enforcement operations, the authors argue that the new approach destroys the very evidence needed to dismantle trafficking networks.

"Dead suspects cannot be questioned. Destroyed vessels cannot be searched," they wrote.

Despite a year of strikes that have killed hundreds of alleged traffickers, the authors cite reporting showing that cocaine's price, purity, and availability in the U.S. have largely returned to pre-operation levels, suggesting the campaign has produced little lasting impact. The strikes have also cost the U.S. cooperation from allies: the United Kingdom, Canada, and the Netherlands have all curtailed intelligence sharing over the killings. That cooperation has historically been central to counter-narcotics work in the Caribbean and Eastern Pacific transit zone, where partner nations contribute ships, aircraft, and intelligence to a joint U.S.-led interdiction effort; the allied pullback therefore removes capabilities the United States cannot easily replace on its own.

Most damning, according to the authors, are reports that two survivors of one strike were killed while defenseless and adrift at sea — a direct violation of the maritime principle to "preserve life at sea whenever possible," which has guided American sea services for generations.

The authors argue the United States already possessed an effective, lawful model for fighting traffickers through Coast Guard-led interdiction, and that abandoning it in favor of military strikes is not a show of strength but a dangerous departure from the principles that once set America apart. The essay's audience includes lawmakers and courts who may yet be asked to weigh in: whether Congress authorized this use of force, and how the strikes square with domestic and international law, remain live questions as the campaign enters its second year.