NewsMacroProfessors report 55-hour weeks as pay stagnates and states tighten tenure oversight

Professors report 55-hour weeks as pay stagnates and states tighten tenure oversight

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Kansas Board of Regents adopted a policy requiring written work plans, mandatory annual reviews, and comprehensive peer reviews every five years for tenured faculty, with dismissal or reassignment possible after two consecutive unsatisfactory reviews.
  • •A Utah legislative audit of 666 tenured-faculty performance reviews found only eight concluded that teaching needed improvement, including 40 cases in which professors received satisfactory ratings despite evidence of poor teaching.
  • •The share of faculty holding full-time tenured or tenure-track appointments fell from about 53% in 1987 to 32% in fall 2023, according to the American Association of University Professors, while departments such as Wichita State's history and engineering programs lost roughly half their faculty.
  • •Faculty report demanding workloads—including 55-hour weeks and 12-hour days at some community colleges—while average full-time pay rose 2.3% between fall 2024 and fall 2025, below the 2.7% inflation rate, leaving real salaries 9.5% below fall 2019 levels.
  • •Democratic victories in the November midterm elections in Texas and Wisconsin may ease political pressure on universities, but existing accountability measures remain in force, and rebuilding public confidence and lost research capacity is expected to take years.
Professors report 55-hour weeks as pay stagnates and states tighten tenure oversight

Public universities helped make American higher education a destination for students and researchers worldwide. Now lawmakers and governing boards from Kansas to Utah are demanding evidence that the professors who teach at those institutions work hard enough.

Faculty members who spoke with Fortune say that premise misunderstands their jobs. They describe 55-hour workweeks, departments that have lost as much as half their faculty, and raises that have failed to keep pace with inflation.

“We are losing ground,” said Renita Coleman, a journalism professor at the University of Texas at Austin.

As scrutiny of higher education intensifies, state legislators, governing boards and university administrators are questioning how professors spend their time and whether they provide enough value in exchange for their salaries and job protections. Some policymakers have sought to limit tenure, while others are requiring detailed accounts of faculty responsibilities.

Critics view tenure as protection for underperformers. Faculty say that misreads the job

Public confidence in American higher education has declined sharply over the past decade. According to Gallup, 38% of Americans expressed a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in higher education in 2026, down from 57% in 2015. The share expressing very little or no confidence increased from 10% to 25%.

The decline in trust comes amid concerns about rising college costs, the value of degrees and political conflicts on campuses. Those frustrations have fueled skepticism of tenure, which grants professors permanent faculty status after they meet a university’s standards for teaching, research and service.

Tenure was designed to protect academic freedom. But the American Council of Trustees and Alumni acknowledged in July that the public increasingly views it as “a mere promise of job security, even for incompetent or unproductive professors.”

Against that backdrop, lawmakers and governing boards in states including Wisconsin, Utah, Ohio and Kansas have moved to increase faculty accountability. Their measures include minimum teaching loads, more rigorous post-tenure reviews and other requirements intended to ensure professors perform their share of the work.

For Coleman, the assumption that professors slow down after earning tenure is far removed from reality.

“If they would only follow us around for a while, they would see this is ridiculous,” she said. “The pressure, the way they think, as soon as we get tenure, you’re going to stop working.”

Earning tenure can take half a dozen years, Coleman said, and by then the pace of the job has become habitual. The idea of slowing down can feel almost unfamiliar.

“By the time we get tenure, we’re so ingrained in this, we can’t stop,” she said.

George Dehner, a history professor and department chair at Wichita State University, said the scrutiny often begins with a basic misunderstanding of what professors do.

“If you think the faculty are scamming you and don’t really work hard…this idea that faculty are working four or six hours a week teaching classes is a deep misunderstanding of what faculty do,” Dehner said. He added that he and his colleagues “easily” work 55-hour weeks, even though their contracts stipulate 40-hour weeks during the nine-month academic year.

Kansas requires written work plans and five-year reviews for tenured faculty

Many universities have long used a rough 40-40-20 model for faculty time: 40% teaching, 40% research and 20% service to the institution and the broader community.

In January, the Kansas Board of Regents, which governs the state’s six public universities, formalized those expectations. Under its new policy, faculty at the three research universities—the University of Kansas, Kansas State and Wichita State—must devote 40% to 55% of their workload to teaching, 35% to 45% to research and 5% to 20% to public service. At the three regional universities, teaching accounts for 60% to 75% of the workload.

Every faculty member now needs a written work plan, and annual reviews are mandatory. Faculty who fall short of workload expectations are placed on an improvement plan. Tenured faculty who receive two consecutive unsatisfactory annual reviews face dismissal, reassignment or an additional one-year improvement plan.

Tenured faculty will also undergo a comprehensive peer review every five years, rather than every seven years.

Dehner described the policy as a concession to lawmakers who had pushed to give the regents greater authority to revoke tenure. Rather than protecting faculty, he said, the new requirements reflect the same suspicion that professors are not doing enough.

“It is absolutely not welcome,” Dehner said. “It comes from a space where there’s a deep suspicion that faculty don’t do anything… that’s a bad-faith place to start. This belief that faculty are lazy and are scamming them [is] compounded by the fact that they have no idea what higher education people do.”

Gamal Weheba, an engineering professor at Wichita State, also sees the policy as an effort to appease legislators rather than a meaningful measure of productivity. Academic work, he said, cannot be measured by the hours spent in a classroom or office.

“It’s not just an idea of having a time card that I clock in and clock out before I talk to students,” Weheba said. “That can never happen.”

The Kansas Board of Regents did not respond to Fortune’s request for comment. At a January meeting, Regent Matt Crocker said the new policies strengthen accountability for state higher-education spending, according to the University Daily Kansan.

“The question I seem to get all the time, especially being here in Topeka, is making sure I’m being a good steward for the state’s funding for higher education, and I think the program and policies help answer that question,” Crocker said.

More work, fewer tenured professors to share it

Faculty members’ biggest frustration with the new mandates is that they are being asked to do more without additional colleagues to share the workload.

When Coleman began teaching at UT Austin in 2005, her department had roughly 25 full-time tenured faculty members. It now has about 18, a decline of roughly 28%.

The same pattern appears in Kansas. Dehner said Wichita State’s history department had about 17 faculty members when he joined in 2004, compared with roughly nine today. Weheba said the engineering department’s faculty count has fallen from about 14 to eight.

Nationally, about 32% of faculty members held full-time tenured or tenure-track appointments in fall 2023, down from about 53% in 1987, according to data from the American Association of University Professors (AAUP). By the same measure, roughly two-thirds of the professoriate now sits outside the tenure system—in the contingent, part-time and non-tenure-track appointments the AAUP tracks alongside tenure.

The decline matters because tenured faculty perform duties well beyond teaching. They serve on university committees, advise students, help colleagues pursue research funding and sit on search committees for new university leaders. Those searches can be particularly time-consuming amid the revolving door of college presidents.

Professors also face challenges that were far less prominent when many of them began their careers, including student mental-health crises, the rapid adoption of artificial intelligence, cuts to research funding and political and social unrest on campus.

“There are more burdens than ever being placed on faculty shoulders, which is putting incredible strain on them individually, but also strain on the overall ecosystem in higher ed,” said Geoff Watson, CEO of NCFDD, which provides faculty-development resources.

“When you put all of that together, more is being asked of faculty, and actually they’re being provided less support than they ever have been,” he added.

None of that means professors should be exempt from accountability, or that all faculty members are complaining, Coleman said. Universities have long had mechanisms for addressing faculty members who do not meet expectations, including removing some from their positions.

A legislative audit released in Utah in October suggests those mechanisms do not always work. Auditors reviewed materials from 666 performance reviews of tenured faculty, and only eight concluded that a professor’s teaching needed improvement.

The auditors identified 40 cases in which professors received “satisfactory” ratings despite evidence of poor teaching. Utah Legislative Auditor General Kade Minchey told Fortune that his office had also received allegations of harassment and of professors failing to show up for class.

The report attributed much of the problem to leadership. Department chairs, who are often responsible for holding faculty accountable, generally rotate through the position while taking on administrative duties in addition to their own teaching, research and service. That leaves them with little time or incentive to confront colleagues.

“When chairs are faculty first and supervisors second, they may neglect the harder, time-intensive leadership responsibilities that drive accountability,” the report stated.

The Utah audit called on universities to strengthen the supervisory role of department leaders and redefine the responsibilities of chairs. It also asked the Legislature to consider whether the minimum due process required to remove a tenured professor is excessive.

Minchey emphasized that the findings were not “an attack on tenure,” but rather “a problem of leadership, and it’s a problem of structure.”

Faculty workload pressures are not limited to red states

Much of the drive for greater faculty accountability has come from Republican-led legislatures, and the Nov. 3 midterm elections reshuffled that political landscape. In Texas, Democrat Gina Hinojosa unseated Gov. Greg Abbott, according to KSAT. In Wisconsin, which enacted a minimum teaching load, Democrats flipped both legislative chambers, according to Wisconsin Public Radio.

Those results give some faculty members reason for optimism, but neither changes existing policy, and meaningful changes are unlikely to happen overnight. The near-term checkpoints for the accountability push are already set: Kansas’s written work plans and mandatory annual reviews are in force, and Utah’s audit has placed the question of tenure-removal due process before its Legislature. The workload strain, meanwhile, is not confined to Republican-led states.

In Massachusetts, free community college has helped drive enrollment up more than 43% since 2022, adding roughly 27,000 students, according to the state. The program has expanded access for students while adding pressure on the professors who teach them.

Darren Stocker, a criminal-justice professor at Cape Cod Community College, typically teaches five classes per semester. Each can have as many as 32 students, and he often makes room for more.

The result is workdays that last at least 12 hours, “from sun up to sundown, seven days a week,” he said. His responsibilities include grading assignments, meeting with students, preparing lectures and handling other duties.

Pay adds to the pressure. Stocker said housing costs on Cape Cod have made it increasingly difficult for educators to live near campus.

“It’s very difficult to really live in the area in which you work,” Stocker said. “That’s the reality of it.”

Average pay for full-time faculty increased 2.3% between fall 2024 and fall 2025, but inflation rose 2.7% over the same period, according to the AAUP’s annual report on faculty pay. Adjusted for inflation, faculty salaries remain 9.5% below their fall 2019 levels.

Policy changes could ease some of the pressure. But rebuilding public confidence in higher education, along with the research capacity the sector has lost, will take considerably longer.

“There is no more pressing issue for higher education than getting very serious about how we rebuild what’s been lost and hopefully build upon it from there,” Watson said. “But it’s not a short-fuse fix that is going to have to take years to kind of come back.”

Stocker, for his part, is not looking for a way out.

“I absolutely love my job. I don’t think there’s anything I would ever want to do more than what I do now, and that’s teaching in the classroom,” Stocker said. “I live to see the success of my students.”

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.