Win McCormack Says Trump’s Rigidity Led to Political Calamity
Key Takeaways
- •Win McCormack, editor-in-chief of The New Republic, argues that President Trump's political decline was rooted in inflexible beliefs formed under a stern father and later reinforced by mentor Roy Cohn.
- •McCormack says Trump's refusal to accept advice from figures he viewed as less prominent, including former chief of staff John Kelly, resulted in a second-term Cabinet unwilling to challenge his inclinations.
- •McCormack points to Trump's tariff position and an attack on Iran that he says killed Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei as examples of proceeding without informed counsel.
- •McCormack links the midterm election results to the consequences of ignoring better-informed advice, and suggests Trump may spend his remaining term focused on construction projects.
- •McCormack predicts that deportation efforts could intensify after Stephen Miller's elevation to chief of staff, while asserting that Trump's broader agenda will ultimately fail.

New Republic Editor-in-Chief Win McCormack argues that President Donald Trump’s political power was bound to collapse, attributing the decline to beliefs and habits he says were formed early in Trump’s life and reinforced by his unwillingness to learn. Because it comes from the magazine’s own editor-in-chief rather than an outside contributor, the argument carries the publication’s editorial weight as well as its platform.
In an analysis published by The New Republic, the century-old opinion magazine McCormack oversees, and carried by Alternet, a progressive news site, McCormack said Trump entered business and politics with “misguided and inflexible beliefs and habits, instilled in him first by a stern and un-loving father.”
McCormack cited Trump’s niece, Mary L. Trump, a psychologist who has authored books about the family, who has described him as having been raised by a “cold, ruthless, mercenary father and a largely absent and sickly mother.” He said the absence of affection in Trump’s household was a defining feature of his upbringing, later reinforced by Roy Cohn, described by McCormack as “ruthless and unprincipled.” Cohn was the former chief counsel to Sen. Joseph McCarthy.
“The essence of Cohn’s tutelage of Donald: No matter what, no matter how wrong you might be or turn out to be about a given matter or issue, you must never bend, never give up your adherence to a position, no matter how misguided it might turn out to be,” McCormack said.
McCormack argued that Trump followed that principle, developing a level of self-absorption that meant he did “not brook advice from other people as to what he should or should not do in a given circumstance.” He said Trump resented advice from people he considered less powerful or less prominent, including retired Marine Gen. John Kelly, who served as White House chief of staff during Trump’s first term, when their recommendations conflicted with his own instincts.
As a result, McCormack said, Trump’s second-term Cabinet was filled with “pliant, mediocre individuals who would never dare challenge his inclinations, no matter how wayward or bizarre they might be.”
McCormack used tariffs as an example, saying that if Trump believes businesses exporting goods pay them rather than U.S. consumers purchasing those goods, he will maintain that position despite efforts by others to correct him. The question of who ultimately absorbs tariff costs has been a recurring point of dispute in U.S. trade policy debates.
He made a similar argument about Iran. After what McCormack described as Trump’s successful kidnapping of Venezuela’s president, he said Trump believed he could subdue the “vastly larger nation of Iran, with its estimated population of 93.4 million and approximately 610,000 military personnel, including its notoriously brutal Revolutionary Guard.”
Instead, according to McCormack’s account, Trump’s attack killed Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, along with several more moderate Iranian leaders whom U.S. analysts believed might have been willing to negotiate with the United States over Trump’s stated concerns about nuclear weapons.
McCormack said that moving ahead without heeding better-informed advice leads to calamity and suggested that the midterm election results demonstrated the consequences. Midterm elections fall at the midpoint of a president’s term and set the composition of Congress for the years that remain in it.
Asked how a president could recover from such damage, McCormack said Trump might focus on construction projects during the remainder of his second term, while warning that this would not rule out “some forms of mischief.”
“His top priority, clearly — and one doomed to failure — is and has been trying to turn the United States back into an overwhelmingly white country,” McCormack said. He pointed to Trump’s attacks on affirmative-action programs and efforts to deport noncitizen residents of color, adding that those efforts could intensify after Stephen Miller’s elevation to chief of staff, a role now held by one of Trump’s longest-serving advisers.
“Beyond that, I think he aspires to reduce every aspect of excellence in the country to a level of mediocrity, which is to say, down to his very own level,” McCormack added. “And at this, I confidently predict, he will woefully fail, as he has failed so often at his major endeavors throughout his miserable life.”