NewsMacroMissouri Supreme Court Presses GOP Lawyers Over Bid to Keep Redistricting Referendum Off Ballot

Missouri Supreme Court Presses GOP Lawyers Over Bid to Keep Redistricting Referendum Off Ballot

Author: Rawstory·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Missouri Supreme Court must decide by September 8 whether the Proposition A referendum on the new congressional map appears on the November 3 ballot.
  • •Secretary of State Denny Hoskins rejected the referendum petition on August 4, arguing neither the Missouri nor the U.S. Constitution permits a statewide vote on congressional redistricting.
  • •Judges questioned why Hoskins did not include the text of the attorney general's legal opinion in his official certification rejecting the petition.
  • •The new map was designed to flip the 5th District red, pitting Republican state Sen. Rick Brattin against Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver.
  • •The sponsoring PAC, People Not Politicians, collected more than 300,000 signatures, and any ruling is expected to face immediate appeal given ballot-printing deadlines.
Missouri Supreme Court Presses GOP Lawyers Over Bid to Keep Redistricting Referendum Off Ballot

Missouri's Supreme Court grilled attorneys defending Secretary of State Denny Hoskins on Wednesday, repeatedly pressing them to explain why voters should not get a say on the state's new gerrymandered congressional map this November.

The case, reported by the Missouri Independent, marks the final legal showdown before Election Day over a redistricting plan Republicans pushed through during a 2025 special session. At stake is not just whether the referendum, known as Proposition A, lands on the ballot — the ruling will also determine which district lines Missourians actually vote under on November 3, with real consequences for control of Congress in a chamber where seat margins are narrow enough that a single district's outcome can matter.

Hoskins declared the referendum petition insufficient on August 4, arguing that neither the Missouri nor the U.S. Constitution allows a statewide vote on congressional redistricting, backed by an opinion from Attorney General Catherine Hanaway. A Cole County judge sided with Hoskins, prompting the sponsoring PAC, People Not Politicians, which gathered more than 300,000 signatures, to appeal. The dispute is part of a broader national pattern in which state courts and election officials have become the decisive battlegrounds over redistricting and ballot access, since the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2019 that partisan gerrymandering claims fall outside federal court jurisdiction, leaving such fights to the states.

Judges zeroed in on a potentially fatal flaw: Hoskins never actually included the text of Hanaway's legal opinion in his official certification rejecting the petition.

"What authority do you have that the secretary can incorporate anything they want and staple it to their certification?" Judge Zel Fischer asked.

Attorneys defending the decision argued that even if a referendum is technically legal, the primary has already happened and candidates have built their campaigns around the new map, so voters should stick with it in November.

"Anytime an election is looming, [a court] has to consider the impact of its decision on the electorate," attorney John Gore argued.

The stakes are concrete: the new map, rushed into law at the urging of President Donald Trump last year, was drawn specifically to flip the 5th District red, pitting Republican state Sen. Rick Brattin against longtime Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, who has cleared 55 percent of the vote in all but two elections since 2004.

Chief Justice Brent Powell pushed back on the delay argument, noting the court already ruled in May that the new map would not take effect if the referendum qualified — meaning Hoskins could have resolved the matter months ago instead of waiting until August.

Attorney Chuck Hatfield, representing the petition's backers, said the court does not need to overthink it: "If you put the consequences and the controversy aside, this analysis is really very simple."

The court must rule by September 8 on whether Proposition A appears on the ballot. Whatever the justices decide is likely to be appealed immediately, given the fast-approaching ballot-printing deadlines for the November 3 election, making further litigation before Election Day a realistic possibility.

Missouri Republicans separately tried to push a measure to curtail the ability of voters to put initiatives on the ballot in the first place. That measure was resoundingly defeated last month, a result consistent with Missouri's recent ballot-measure history, in which voters have used the initiative process to override legislative positions on issues including minimum wage, Medicaid expansion and abortion rights.

Source: Raw Story