NewsMacroReport: Lutnick pushed to soften pasta tariff enforcement amid inflation concerns

Report: Lutnick pushed to soften pasta tariff enforcement amid inflation concerns

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •A Commerce Department investigation determined in September that leading Italian pasta makers had underpriced products sold in the U.S., violating trade rules.
  • •According to four anonymous sources cited by Politico, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and other officials discouraged staff from pursuing the most aggressive tariffs and ordered recalculations of rates deemed too high.
  • •In March, the Commerce Department finalized Italian pasta tariffs ranging from 2.65 percent to 7 percent, far below the 91.74 percent rate initially proposed.
  • •Career Commerce officials and trade experts are concerned that duty rates are being set by political considerations rather than hard data and legal criteria.
  • •The softened enforcement reflects administration concern that inflation and affordability could hurt Republicans in the midterm elections less than two months away.
Report: Lutnick pushed to soften pasta tariff enforcement amid inflation concerns

U.S. President Donald Trump continues to double down on his steep tariffs, escalating a trade war with Canada and other U.S. allies. But with the midterms a little over two months away, Republicans fear that soaring prices will cost them control of Congress. According to Politico, concerns over the price of pasta imported from Italy triggered a "panic" from Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who moved into damage-control mode by "leaning on agency staff not to drive up tariffs on grocery items and other goods ahead of the midterm elections."

The case at issue is the kind of antidumping investigation the Commerce Department has long conducted: when foreign producers are found to sell goods in the U.S. below fair value, the department calculates duty rates intended to offset the underpricing. Italy is one of the world's largest pasta exporters, and Italian brands hold a significant share of the U.S. pasta market, which is why duty rates on Italian producers can translate directly into shelf-price pressure.

Politico reporters Ari Hawkins and Oliver Ward wrote, "Agency leaders first stepped in late last year, after a Commerce Department investigation determined in September that leading Italian pasta makers had been underpricing the products they sold in the U.S., in violation of trade rules. The proposed punishment — sky-high tariffs on the pantry staple — drew headlines at a time when the administration was trying to convince Americans its trade agenda was not driving up prices."

A Commerce Department insider, interviewed on condition of anonymity, described Lutnick's reaction to reports of rising pasta prices.

The source told Politico, "Lutnick was very upset that the work was making it on the news, from the perspective that he was responsible for inflation. Then he became a micromanager. He micromanaged every decision that came out to try to water down enforcement and compliance."

Hawkins and Ward reported that, according to four Politico sources — all interviewed on condition of anonymity — Lutnick and other Commerce Department officials "have discouraged staff from pursuing the most aggressive possible tariffs in the pasta case and other similar investigations into trade violations."

"In some cases," the reporters wrote, "senior officials instructed staff to recalculate rates that were deemed too high, two of the people said. The result has been much lower duties on violators in recent months compared to the past. Those decisions are worrying career Commerce officials as well as other trade and legal experts, who say the rates for any new duties should be based on hard data and legal criteria. And it illustrates how concerns about inflation and affordability approaching the midterm elections have begun to override Trump's desire to crack down on foreign companies that cheat domestic industry."

Lutnick, Hawkins and Ward noted, "signaled to staff across meetings and private correspondence in the fall of 2025 that the administration would no longer prioritize the most aggressive forms of enforcement, according to the four people."

"In a meeting in March," Hawkins and Ward reported, "senior Commerce officials told private-sector lawyers about the new approach, stressing that the administration would no longer back the most aggressive form of enforcement, two of the people said. That same month, the Commerce Department finalized the tariffs on the Italian pasta companies at a maximum rate of 7 percent for Garofalo and a minimum of 2.65 percent for La Molisana, while 11 other Italian companies were hit with a 5.21 percent duty — far lower than the 91.74 percent rate initially proposed."