New Jersey Seeks Supreme Court Review in Kalshi Prediction Market Dispute
Key Takeaways
- •New Jersey filed its Supreme Court petition on September 2 in KalshiEX v. Flaherty.
- •The Third Circuit ruled in April that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission has exclusive authority over Kalshi’s sports event contracts.
- •The Ninth Circuit later ruled against Kalshi in a Nevada case and said the contracts are sports bets subject to state law.
- •At least four states — Nevada, Massachusetts, Michigan, and Washington — have obtained court orders limiting Kalshi’s operations.
- •Kalshi was last valued at $22 billion, and the Supreme Court has not yet decided whether to hear the case.

New Jersey has formally asked the US Supreme Court to step into a growing legal dispute over whether states can regulate sports prediction markets operated by Kalshi.
New Jersey asked the Supreme Court to shut down prediction markets in the state, teeing up a potential landmark case where the justices could decide if the highly popular but controversial industry can survive in its current form. pic.twitter.com/lAMqWM1EYT — CNN Politics (@CNNPolitics) September 2, 2026
The state filed its petition on September 2, asking the court to overturn an April ruling by the Third US Circuit Court of Appeals. That court sided with Kalshi and held that the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission has exclusive authority over the company’s sports event contracts.
New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said the companies have no right to offer sports bets without complying with state law. She also said dozens of states across the political spectrum have opposed Kalshi’s position.
A Direct Split Between Courts
The timing of New Jersey’s petition is significant. On August 28, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Kalshi in a separate case involving Nevada. The court said Kalshi’s sports contracts are sports bets, not federally regulated swaps, and concluded that Nevada could enforce its own gaming laws.
That ruling directly conflicts with the Third Circuit’s earlier decision. When two federal appeals courts reach opposite conclusions on the same legal question, the Supreme Court is far more likely to review the case. The split also matters because it leaves states, companies, and regulators operating under different legal rules depending on geography, a situation that is difficult to reconcile in a market that is expanding across state lines.
At least four states — Nevada, Massachusetts, Michigan, and Washington — have already obtained court orders restricting Kalshi’s operations.
What Is at Stake
Kalshi argues that its products are event contracts regulated by the CFTC under the Commodity Exchange Act. The CFTC under the Trump administration has supported that view, suing states that have tried to enforce their own gambling laws against the platform.
New Jersey counters that Congress never intended to give a federal agency control over the sports betting industry when it passed the Dodd-Frank Act after the 2008 financial crisis. The state says the law is not clear enough to strip states of authority over a multi-billion-dollar industry.
Kalshi was last valued at $22 billion and has been expanding rapidly in the prediction markets space.
The case is formally known as KalshiEX v. Flaherty. The Supreme Court has not yet agreed to hear it.
If the court does take the case, the ruling could affect not only Kalshi but the broader prediction markets industry, which is facing lawsuits and restrictions in multiple states. The court’s next steps are to docket the petition, potentially request a response from Kalshi, and decide whether to grant review. Until then, the conflicting appellate rulings keep the underlying question unresolved for operators and state regulators alike.
No hearing date has been set.
The post Two Courts, Two Rulings: The Kalshi Legal Fight That Could Change Sports Betting Forever appeared first on CoinCentral .