NewsMacroGen Z believes AI is making their colleagues dumb and lazy—but may see it as the key to their own promotion, Wharton survey finds

Gen Z believes AI is making their colleagues dumb and lazy—but may see it as the key to their own promotion, Wharton survey finds

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •A Wharton-led survey of nearly 2,500 U.S. adults aged 18 to 28 found 79% believe AI makes people lazier and 62% worry it makes them less smart.
  • •Pew Research Center data shows 66% of Americans aged 18 to 29 have used an AI chatbot, up from 55% in 2024, while 37% expect AI's impact on them over the next 20 years to be negative.
  • •Research from Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University associated heavy reliance on AI tools with diminished critical thinking among more than 300 knowledge workers.
  • •The report's authors recommend that employers embrace ambivalence toward AI rather than ban it, noting that frequent users expressed fewer concerns about its effects on intelligence and motivation.
  • •North Carolina State professor Mark Beasley warned that a critical thinking gap, rather than an AI skills gap, could leave organizations without adequately trained workers for mid- and upper-level roles.
Gen Z believes AI is making their colleagues dumb and lazy—but may see it as the key to their own promotion, Wharton survey finds

Gen Z believes artificial intelligence is making their colleagues dumb and lazy—but that hasn't stopped young workers from ramping up their use of the technology, or from seeing it as a potential key to their own promotion.

The tension sits against a growing body of research on AI's cognitive effects. Last year, researchers from Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University released evidence on how—and how hard—people think when using AI, finding that among more than 300 knowledge workers, leaning too much on AI tools like ChatGPT was associated with diminished critical thinking skills.

The study, mirrored by results from MIT-led research, suggested that even using AI for low-stakes tasks such as proofreading “can lead to significant negative outcomes in high-stakes contexts,” like writing legal documents, the study authors wrote.

For the young generation of digital natives navigating AI anxiety—both around keeping up with peers who use the technology and around AI displacing them from jobs—the fear that it makes people dumber is dominant. But that hasn't stopped them from using AI, even when they're explicitly told not to.

A Wharton-led survey published earlier this year in Harvard Business Review, conducted in partnership with Gallup and the Walton Family Foundation, found young people are ramping up their AI use even as their concerns about it causing lazy thinking persist. The survey of nearly 2,500 U.S. adults between the ages of 18 and 28, completed in October 2025, found 79% of respondents believed AI makes people lazier, and 62% said they had concerns it makes people less smart.

“What we find is deep ambivalence on how Gen Z is thinking [about] using AI,” Benjamin Lira Luttges, a postdoctoral scholar at Wharton who led research for the report, told Fortune.

Despite these fears, Gen Zers have increased their AI usage. Pew Research Center data published in June found 66% of people ages 18 to 29 have ever used an AI chatbot, such as ChatGPT, up from 55% in 2024. However, 37% of those young adults said they believed the impact of AI on them over the next 20 years would be negative—the most pessimistic attitude of any age group surveyed.

The paradox of Gen Z's willingness to use AI at the office, even amid persistent worries about the technology's impact on critical thinking, lays bare the young generation's complicated feelings toward AI, according to the report's authors. Gen Z's fraught relationship with the technology runs deep: nearly one-fifth of the generation is worried about AI displacing them at work, yet they lead the workplace in AI adoption.

Though they require some decoding, Gen Z's tangled attitudes toward AI can be critical in designing a path forward for how the technology, more broadly, is best integrated into the workplace, Lira Luttges suggested.

“Young people lead the adoption of new technologies, and a lot of things that are often seen as fringe, as not mainstream, are adopted by young people and eventually become part of the mainstream,” he said. “So in a sense … looking at Gen Z is a way of looking towards the future of work.”

What are Gen Z's fraught feelings toward AI?

Lira Luttges speculates that the biggest mental factor informing Gen Z's attitudes toward AI is simply a bias toward immediate gratification, a disposition more prominent in younger, developing minds.

“There's a legitimate tradeoff between benefits and costs that you get from using AI,” he said. “Our brains are wired to prefer smaller, immediate rewards versus long-term, delayed rewards.”

As Gen Z grapples with finding or keeping jobs, as well as scaling career ladders, job performance bolstered by an AI boost may hold more appeal than the less tangible threat of losing critical thinking skills. Similarly, even if an employer does not want an employee using AI for certain tasks, those workers—particularly if young—might consider getting their tasks done efficiently as more important, especially if the risk of getting caught is low, Lira Luttges noted.

Anyone—not just Gen Z—could also fall victim to the better-than-average effect, a statistically impossible phenomenon in which most people generally believe they are above average at a certain task. Gen Z survey respondents, for example, may see themselves as AI power users, Lira Luttges said. Sure, AI could atrophy critical thought capabilities and make other people lazy—but not those filling out the survey.

How will Gen Z shape the future of work?

To maximize how AI is used in the workplace, employers should not ban AI, but rather embrace ambivalence toward it, the report authors argued. According to the survey, respondents who reported using AI more frequently worried less about its impact on intelligence and motivation, indicating AI anxiety may resolve over time.

But resolving AI anxiety doesn't address the question of AI use impacting critical thought. Some future-of-work experts, including Mark Beasley, professor and director at North Carolina State University's Poole College of Management, believe a critical thinking gap, not an AI skills gap, will pose a serious threat to organizational pipelines and business operations. Beasley told Fortune the threat AI poses to entry-level jobs could mean insufficient training and experience for middle- and eventually upper-tier positions in the near future.

“The biggest risk organizations face is just being stagnant,” he said.

How employers act on that warning—whether through outright bans or the intentional implementation the report authors advocate—is one thread to watch as adoption among early-career workers continues to climb.

But as long as workplaces are intentional about how they implement AI, Lira Luttges said, the technology won't have a significant impact on critical thinking.

“For every task, there are two kinds of efforts,” Lira Luttges said. “There is effort that is germane to the task, that is intrinsic to the thing that you're doing, and that kind of effort is the effort that you put in, and gets translated into learning. But there's a lot of effort that is just there, that's just like friction, that doesn't really teach you anything.”

“You should outsource the crap, not the craft,” he added.

A version of this story was published on Fortune.com on Jan. 30, 2026. This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.