NewsMacroFlorida Towns Eye New Fees and State Aid to Plug Budget Holes After Property Tax Cut Vote

Florida Towns Eye New Fees and State Aid to Plug Budget Holes After Property Tax Cut Vote

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •Florida's Amendment 3 increases the homestead exemption for non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, reducing tax bills for eligible homeowners.
  • •Florida TaxWatch estimates the tax cut could cost local governments $4.9 billion in revenue in its first fiscal year and $45.8 billion over five years.
  • •Sanford anticipates an approximately $15 million revenue loss over the next two years, an estimated 18% budget gap, prompting discussions of cuts to travel, public arts spending, and early retirement incentives.
  • •Sanford commissioners are weighing a fire assessment fee on homeowners and businesses, which is tied to a specific service and therefore falls outside the homestead exemption expanded by Amendment 3.
  • •Oakland expects to lose about $820,000 in property tax revenue in fiscal 2028 and will hold a December vote that could enable new fire protection and stormwater assessments.
Florida Towns Eye New Fees and State Aid to Plug Budget Holes After Property Tax Cut Vote

Just two weeks after Florida voters approved sweeping property tax cuts in the midterm election, officials in one Florida city are already planning how to make up for the lost revenue—including through a potential new fee on property owners to help pay for firefighters.

The measure, Amendment 3, raises the homestead exemption for non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, meaning the property tax bill for eligible homeowners will go down. According to an estimate from Florida TaxWatch, a nonpartisan, nonprofit government watchdog group, the cut could reduce local government revenue by $4.9 billion in its first fiscal year and by $45.8 billion over five years.

Sanford, a city northeast of Orlando, expects to lose approximately $15 million in property tax revenue over the next two years—an estimated 18% hole in its budget, according to local news station FOX 35 Orlando.

The projection has pushed the city to consider major changes. Last Monday, Sanford commissioners discussed eliminating travel to meetings with the Florida League of Cities, cutting public arts spending, and even offering early retirement incentives similar to those used during the Great Recession, the station reported.

The adjustments in Sanford come as Americans voiced widespread frustration over the cost of living in a midterm election that helped Democrats regain both chambers of Congress. Florida was not the only state where voters passed property tax measures: in North Carolina, voters approved a constitutional amendment requiring lawmakers to limit increases in property taxes collected by local governments. But while voters sought relief from rising prices, they have now left local governments to work out how to keep delivering essential services.

More fees

One idea floated by Sanford commissioners to cover the shortfall is a fire assessment fee charged directly to local property owners, including homeowners and businesses, to pay for fire services. Unlike ad valorem property taxes, which the homestead exemption reduces, such assessments are tied to a specific service rather than a property's assessed value, so they fall outside the exemption that Amendment 3 expands. Still, Commissioner Patrick Austin acknowledged that such a fee would likely be deeply unpopular.

"The voters have said we want less fees, and if we come back and go, 'We want to do this fire fee,' we are going to be really, really hated," he said.

In Oakland, another Central Florida town, officials are preparing a December vote that could pave the way for new fire protection and stormwater assessments. The town expects to lose about $820,000 in property tax revenue in fiscal 2028.

Because of the changes brought on by Amendment 3, former Republican state Sen. Jeff Brandes predicted Florida could eventually raise its statewide sales tax—currently 6%—to compensate local governments for lost property tax revenue. In a post on X, he compared the measure to California's Proposition 13, which sharply limited property taxes in 1978 and increased local governments' dependence on state funding.

"When your city needs a state check to balance its budget, your legislators become your city commissioners," wrote Brandes, who is now the president and founder of the Florida Policy Project. "The bailout comes with a leash."

Oakland's December vote and Sanford's ongoing budget deliberations will provide the first concrete tests of how Florida municipalities absorb the cuts—whether through service reductions, new assessments, or appeals to the state for help.

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.