David French: Republicans' Survival Hinges on Anti-Trump Faction Prevailing in MAGA Civil War
Key Takeaways
- •David French argued in a New York Times column that both the Republican Party and American democracy depend on the GOP's internal civil war ending with the anti-Trump faction prevailing.
- •French rejected the MAGA narrative blaming Bush-era neoconservatives for the midterm wipeout, pointing out that Trump's approval rating was trending downward well before the Iran war.
- •He attributed the collapse in Hispanic voter support largely to the administration's immigration crackdown, a signature issue of the MAGA movement.
- •French urged Republicans to adopt constitutional conservatism, citing George Will's formulation, arguing it would let the party roll back Trump's policies on tariffs, Iran, civil liberties, and Russia.
- •Former Trump communications director Anthony Scaramucci said in a September interview that Republicans had become cowards who failed to seek Trump's removal or convict him in his second impeachment.

President Donald Trump's MAGA movement has long been fueled by internal disputes over issues such as foreign policy, and talk of a civil war dividing the Republican coalition has circulated for years. Yet as one conservative columnist recently argued, the future of both the Republican Party and American democracy depends on that civil war ending — and on the anti-Trump faction prevailing.
The argument came from New York Times columnist David French in a column published Sunday, landing amid a post-midterm reckoning in which rival wings of the GOP are advancing competing explanations for the wipeout — and competing prescriptions for recovery.
"If you spend any time watching right-wing media or following right-wing accounts online, you'll know that MAGA has settled on one message to explain the midterm wipeout: It's the neocons' fault," French wrote. "The establishment holdovers from the dreaded George W. Bush years coaxed or coerced the president into the ruinous Iran war, and without the Iran war, everything would have been just fine."
Under that reading, he observed, the movement's prescribed remedy is escalation. "So what's the solution? Double down on MAGA and 'America first' until the last molecules of the old Republican Party have been swept away," French wrote. "This is the reasoning that gives us Miller as the White House chief of staff."
French dismissed that explanation outright. "This narrative isn't just wrong; it's idiotic," he wrote. Trump's approval rating, he noted, was trending downward well before the Iran war, and the collapse in support from Hispanic voters was almost certainly "a result, in large part, of the administration's brutal immigration crackdown, perhaps the signature issue of the MAGA movement."
Rather than doubling down, French contended, the Republican Party should return to traditional conservative principles. "If Trumpism isn't conservatism, then what is conservatism?" he asked, citing a definition from George Will, whom he called "the dean of conservative columnists": "The object of conservatism is to preserve the founding principles and institutions of the United States, including its ethos and its Constitution."
"I can think of few better paths back to popularity for Republicans than to adopt Will's formulation," French continued. "In fact, constitutional conservatism can be among the most effective ways to combat the least popular aspects of Trumpism."
He argued that such a return would allow Republicans to roll back Trump's ineffective policies on tariffs, Iran, civil liberties and Russia. "Conservatives don't have to change themselves to oppose Trump and reach the millions of Americans who've rejected the Republican Party," French wrote. "They simply have to, at long last, be themselves again."
French's column arrived months after a former Trump White House official offered a blunt assessment of the party. In a September interview with AlterNet, former Trump communications director Anthony Scaramucci — who served just 11 days in the role in 2017 — blasted the current state of the Republican Party.
"I would say to you that they've become cowards," Scaramucci told AlterNet. "They've become self-aggrandizing. We started this interview by me saying that they only care about themselves and their own personal power, and they've become cowards. If they were not cowards, they would've sought Donald Trump's removal. If they were not cowards, they would've convicted Donald Trump in his second impeachment after the ridiculous, and I want to emphasize the ridiculous, Matthew, the ridiculous insurrection and the fomenting of that insurrection. If they were not cowards... But they're cowards."
Taken together, the two assessments frame the central question of the GOP's intraparty war: whether the movement follows the escalation French derides, or takes up the constitutional conservatism he argues is the party's surest route back to the voters it has lost.
This article originally appeared on Alternet.