Burnham Demands Honesty While Ignoring Britain's Fiscal Reality
Key Takeaways
- •Andy Burnham made his first appearance as Prime Minister at Prime Minister's Questions this week, facing Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch.
- •UK public debt stands close to 100 per cent of GDP, a level not sustained since the early 1960s, with debt interest among the largest public spending items.
- •The author accuses Burnham of pressing his Chancellor to bend fiscal rules to allow more borrowing, echoing risks seen in the 2022 mini-budget gilt sell-off.
- •The column argues that commitments such as the state pension triple lock, public sector pension liabilities, and rising NHS spending cannot be afforded as the population ages.
- •The writer warns that when forced to address fiscal reality, the government's response may be large tax hikes.

Andy Burnham declared this week that "change begins with honesty." My ears pricked up. Was our new Prime Minister about to deliver some hard truths? Of course he wasn't. The honesty Burnham had in mind was very much "his truth" rather than "the truth." We were told that all the country's problems were down to Thatcher and Brexit. In Burnham's mind the former haunts us while the latter shattered our future.
Recollections – like opinions – may vary, but watching his first outing at PMQs yesterday it was hard not to notice a contradiction. In tone and approach, Burnham likes to come across as a reasonable guy, more interested in "problem solving than point scoring." As Kemi Badenoch discovered, this makes him hard to land a blow on. Every time she went in with her blade he simply danced out of the way and offered a courtly bow. How infuriating! Here is a man so deeply ideological that his sole purpose in taking power was to "end 40 years of neoliberalism" and he won't even argue about it.
But no amount of charm can hide the fact that he isn't being honest. He can talk about hope, optimism and good growth as much as he likes, but it makes him look as if he hasn't noticed the interest rate hike warnings, the size of our debt or the cost of servicing it. Britain's public debt stock now sits close to 100 per cent of GDP, a level not sustained since the early 1960s, and debt interest payments already rank among the largest single items of public spending. He pays lip service to fiscal credibility, then tells his Chancellor to bend the fiscal rules to accommodate more borrowing – a stance made more awkward by the memory of the 2022 mini-budget, when unfunded tax cuts triggered a gilt sell-off and forced an intervention from the Bank of England.
The bond market can see what Burnham refuses to acknowledge
He is more interested in reorganising local government and hosting devolution summits in Number Ten North than he is in confronting core economic truths.
We cannot afford our current commitments – whether that's the triple lock on the state pension, unfunded public sector pension liabilities or the current trajectory of NHS spending – pressures that deepen as the population ages – and we certainly can't afford to fund his ideological crusade for more "public control" of water, energy, transport and housing.
He continued to tell MPs yesterday that his plan for growth was "credible," but the bond market can see what he refuses to acknowledge: that credibility requires more than rhetoric and ambition. It requires discipline, details and – most of all – honesty.
My real worry is that when he's finally forced to level with the public, his only answer will be large tax hikes, and that way ruination lies.