Arthur Hayes Supports Coinbase in US Stock Perpetuals Dispute
Key Takeaways
- •Coinbase and five other companies filed a court brief opposing a temporary halt to stock perpetual futures trading.
- •The CMAA argues that the contracts are security-based swaps and should face tighter restrictions on retail participation.
- •The SEC is reviewing the exchanges’ listing rules while the CFTC and SEC jurisdictional boundary remains contested.
- •Judge Valerie Caproni denied the CMAA’s restraining-order request, allowing the products to keep trading for now.
- •Kalshi’s stock perpetuals recorded about $375 million in reported 24-hour notional volume shortly after launch, according to the CMAA.

Arthur Hayes, co-founder of BitMEX, said he was “flattered” by Coinbase’s support for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in a US legal dispute over stock perpetual futures.
“When we launched the perpetual swap at BitMEX in 2016, Washington’s reaction was less than warm,” Hayes told Cointelegraph. “Ten years later, Coinbase is in federal court defending the right to offer them on US stocks. I’m flattered. Imitation is the sincerest form of regulation.”
Coinbase and five other companies submitted a brief on Monday opposing the Capital Markets Alliance Association’s request to block trading in perpetual futures tied to individual stocks. The court accepted the brief on Tuesday. The case has become a test of how US regulators treat a product format that rose to prominence in crypto trading, and of which agency gets to police it.
The Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA), which brought the lawsuit, argues that the contracts should be treated as security-based swaps, which face tighter restrictions on retail trading.
Hayes was CEO of BitMEX when the crypto derivatives exchange launched its Bitcoin perpetual swap. The product allowed traders to take leveraged positions on Bitcoin without a fixed expiration date and helped make perpetual swaps a staple of crypto trading. The stock versions now before the court carry that same no-expiry design — the very feature the lawsuit targets.
SEC weighs in on stock perpetuals
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reportedly submitted a proposed court brief on Monday opposing the CMAA’s request to temporarily halt trading in the contracts. The SEC’s entry into a dispute over contracts approved by the CFTC underscores how contested the boundary between the two agencies’ jurisdictions remains.
The agency said it was reviewing the exchanges’ rules for listing the contracts. The brief left open whether the SEC would set those rules aside and whether the contracts qualify as security futures or security-based swaps. That classification question sits at the heart of the case, since the CMAA’s push to treat the products as security-based swaps is aimed at subjecting retail trading to tighter restrictions.
In a Tuesday court filing, the CMAA said the CFTC had approved the contracts without adequately explaining its decision or addressing unresolved regulatory questions.
The group also cited about $375 million in reported 24-hour notional trading volume for Kalshi’s stock perpetuals shortly after their launch. It claimed that the products were already diverting business from traditional stock markets.
Stock perpetuals’ lack of expiry is at issue
Stock perpetuals allow traders to speculate on individual share prices without owning the underlying stocks. Unlike traditional futures, the contracts have no fixed expiration date.
On Nov. 3, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the group’s request for a temporary restraining order because it had not yet shown likely irreparable harm. She found that the alliance was likely to succeed on its claim that the CFTC had exceeded its authority. The denial leaves the products trading for now, while her finding keeps the core jurisdictional challenge alive — with the SEC’s review of the exchanges’ listing rules and the unresolved classification question still open as the case advances.
Wojciech Kaszycki, strategy adviser to BTCS SA, said the absence of a fixed expiration or delivery date could complicate the case for treating perpetual contracts as futures. Kaszycki told Cointelegraph that the case involved the issue of “sale for future delivery.”
However, he warned that a ruling against the CFTC could push trading activity toward offshore and decentralized platforms.
“The product doesn’t die; it just changes address,” he said.