NewsMacroAbolishing Inheritance Tax Would Reduce Wealth Inequality, Argues Max Young

Abolishing Inheritance Tax Would Reduce Wealth Inequality, Argues Max Young

Author: City AM Markets·

Key Takeaways

  • •A 2021 OECD report found inheritances represent a larger share of net wealth for lower-wealth households, with the second-poorest fifth benefiting more than the richest fifth across the 12 countries studied.
  • •HMRC data shows British estates worth between £2m and £7.5m face effective Inheritance Tax rates exceeding 25 per cent, with the burden falling for wealthier estates.
  • •Ten OECD countries, including Sweden, Canada, and Australia, have scrapped inheritance taxes, and Sweden abolished its levy in 2004 after middle-earning families' effective rate rose to 5.4 per cent.
  • •A Charles Stanley survey found 20 per cent of business owners used an inheritance to start their firm, while a 2018 US study linked receiving any inheritance to an almost 13 per cent higher likelihood of owning a business.
  • •UK policy is expanding the tax rather than scrapping it, as unspent pension pots will join estates from April 2027 and the Office for Budget Responsibility expects more than 10 per cent of estates to pay Inheritance Tax within three years due to a threshold frozen since 2009.
Abolishing Inheritance Tax Would Reduce Wealth Inequality, Argues Max Young

Abolishing Inheritance Tax would help reduce wealth inequality by acting as a crucial equalising measure and a vital source of start-up funding that disproportionately benefits lower-wealth households and middle-class families, according to Max Young, news editor at Guido Fawkes, writing for City AM.

The Chancellor did not abolish Inheritance Tax (IHT) at the Budget, nor did he lower it. But Young argues that the Chancellor should know for next time that such a policy would not only provide “growth in every postcode” — it would actually reduce inequality in Britain.

Inheritances weigh heaviest for poorer households

A landmark 2021 report by the OECD found that “While lower-wealth households receive smaller inheritances and gifts, these are typically large as a share of net wealth.” It added that “even a small inheritance can be substantial relative to pre-inheritance wealth.”

Across the 12 countries examined by the organisation, the second-poorest fifth of households benefited more from their inheritance than the richest fifth. In Spain, 95.6 per cent of the net wealth of the second fifth derived from bequests.

In short, the poorer the recipient, the more important the money passed down by parents becomes — and in many cases it is the only cash injection a person ever receives. Wealthier heirs, by contrast, tend to own assets before their parents die, which means inheritances act as an equalising force.

The supporting evidence

A 2016 study by the Institute for Fiscal Studies noted that inheritances in Britain “act to make the distribution of non-pension wealth less unequal.”

In Denmark, research into tax records found that bequests cut the share of wealth held by the top one per cent by around six percentage points. In an analysis covering the whole Swedish population’s tax records, inheritances were found to reduce the Gini coefficient — the standard formula for measuring relative wealth inequality — by five to ten per cent.

Sweden went on to abolish its inheritance tax after the levy was shown to have an outsized effect on middle-earning families, who paid an effective rate of 5.4 per cent in 2004, up from 2.9 per cent in 1992. The left-wing Social Democratic government scrapped the tax with the support of two-thirds of Swedes.

In Britain, Inheritance Tax also falls hardest on the middle class. HMRC data shows that families with estates worth between £2m and £7.5m face an IHT bill of more than 25 per cent — a share that drops for wealthier estates.

The ten countries that have scrapped inheritance tax

Ten OECD countries have scrapped inheritance taxes: Mexico (1961), Canada (1972), Australia (1979), Israel (1980), New Zealand (1992), Sweden and Slovakia (2004), Austria (2008), and the Czech Republic and Norway (2014). Young suggests there is a hint for Healey somewhere in that list.

Bequests as start-up funding

Bequests are also a crucial source of start-up funding. A recent survey by Charles Stanley found that 20 per cent of business owners used an inheritance to start their firm — just one point behind bank funding — while 15 per cent used inherited cash to fund a later expansion of their business.

A 2018 study examining US data from 1992 to 2010 found that receiving any inheritance increases the chances of owning and running a business by almost 13 per cent. The size of the bequest mattered comparatively little: each extra $1m bequeathed added only one per cent to that probability.

Who benefits most? Banks like to lend against a house or significant savings. Those who have neither rely especially on what their parents leave behind.

Where UK policy stands

Instead of winding down the tax, the British government is expanding it. Unspent pension pots will join the estate from April 2027, too, as City AM has reported. The Office for Budget Responsibility predicts that more than 10 per cent of British estates will pay Inheritance Tax in three years, thanks to the allowance threshold having been frozen since 2009 — it should be more than £540,000 today.

Inheritance tax is one of the levies most hated by the British public because, in Young’s view, it punishes aspiration and inhibits the basic human desire to provide for one’s children and leave a legacy. He also argues it is helping to keep the poor in relative poverty — and that any progressive campaigner worth their salt should campaign for its abolition.

Max Young is news editor at Guido Fawkes. This article originally appeared in City AM.