NewsCryptoGate Says Disputed Bitcoin Remains Held as ZachXBT Challenges Indian Fraud Case Evidence

Gate Says Disputed Bitcoin Remains Held as ZachXBT Challenges Indian Fraud Case Evidence

Author: CryptoMeter io·

Key Takeaways

  • •On-chain investigator ZachXBT published an analysis on November 17 alleging that investigators mislabeled Merlin Chain bridge addresses as wallets tied to a fraudulent investment platform, a reconstruction Gate disputes.
  • •The affected user says he deposited 15 BTC in July 2025 and subsequently lost access to his account, which held approximately $3 million when the freeze was imposed.
  • •Gate states the disputed Bitcoin remains in its custody, that no assets have been transferred to authorities, and that local lawyers are assisting the user's defense.
  • •The Andhra Pradesh Crime Investigation Department says its broader probe concerns a roughly $1.5 million investment scheme, with 15 Bitcoin transactions traced to four Gate accounts and a court ordering the identified crypto converted to USDT for return to the complainant.
  • •A timeline discrepancy remains open, as the user dates his account restriction to July 2025 while Gate says it received the police freeze request in September 2025.
Gate Says Disputed Bitcoin Remains Held as ZachXBT Challenges Indian Fraud Case Evidence

A frozen Bitcoin balance belonging to a Gate user is under renewed scrutiny after on-chain investigator ZachXBT publicly challenged the evidence underpinning an Indian fraud investigation. According to the user, he deposited 15 BTC in July 2025 and subsequently lost access to his account. Gate says the disputed assets remain in its custody and that nothing has been transferred to authorities. For exchange customers, the case is a reminder that frozen balances can stay locked for months while competing reconstructions of on-chain evidence are contested publicly.

ZachXBT reported that the account held approximately $3 million at the time the freeze began, noting that this figure reflects the value when the restriction was imposed rather than its worth today. In an analysis published on November 17, he alleged that investigators mistakenly linked the investor to a cryptocurrency investment scam. Gate, however, disputes his reconstruction of the transaction trail supplied by police.

Disputed Bitcoin Trail

ZachXBT asserts that authorities mislabeled addresses belonging to the Merlin Chain bridge — infrastructure that moves assets between blockchain networks — as wallets tied to a fraudulent investment platform. In his view, the payments in question represented withdrawals of the investor's own Bitcoin rather than proceeds of the alleged fraud. The dispute turns on address attribution: whether the flagged addresses reflect the investor's own bridging activity or activity tied to the alleged platform.

His analysis states that the investor deposited 50 BTC into Merlin in March 2024, before the alleged theft took place. ZachXBT matched three subsequent bridge withdrawals with Bitcoin payments to the investor, and separately traced a 15 BTC deposit to older holdings originating from Binance and OKX withdrawals.

Police Pursue Fraud Recovery

The Andhra Pradesh Crime Investigation Department says the broader investigation concerns an investment scheme involving approximately $1.5 million. Investigators say they traced 15 Bitcoin transactions to four Gate accounts — a transaction count that differs from the individual user's claim of a 15 BTC deposit into his own account. The disagreement illustrates how tracing that crosses bridges and multiple exchanges can produce reconstructions contested by independent analysts.

Police say a court ordered the identified cryptocurrency converted into USDT and returned to the complainant. Nevertheless, ZachXBT disputes the connection between the affected investor and the scam. His findings challenge the tracing evidence, though they do not establish that a court has cleared the user.

Gate Retains the Assets

Gate says it requested additional evidence after receiving a police freeze request in September 2025. The user, meanwhile, dates his account restriction to July, leaving the two timelines unresolved. The exchange says local lawyers are helping the user pursue a defense while it seeks permission to share further evidence. Both the July-versus-September timeline gap and investigators' response to ZachXBT's analysis remain open, leaving the disputed balance in Gate's custody for the time being.

Source: CryptoMeter io