Banks Move to Block AI Agents Over Security and Competition Concerns
Key Takeaways
- •HSBC, Barclays, Lloyds, NatWest and Nationwide have blocked or restricted third-party AI agents from accessing customer accounts, citing fears of rogue agents and unclear liability rather than any known breaches.
- •The restrictions differ from the UK's open banking regime in place since 2018, which mandates customer-initiated data sharing with accredited third parties rather than autonomous agent transactions.
- •A Bank of England and FCA survey found that while 80% of responding firms had deployed AI agents, only 2% used agents with broad autonomy, citing data security, third-party dependencies and hallucination risks.
- •The US Office of the Comptroller of the Currency issued a supervisory framework on Nov. 4 covering banks' use of agentic AI systems, assessing risk by autonomy level and human oversight without imposing new binding requirements.
- •Apollo chief economist Torsten Slok warned that agents moving household cash en masse to higher-yield alternatives could strip banks of low-cost funding and create a problem for the entire financial system.

Lenders in the United Kingdom have drawn a line on how much access artificial intelligence should have to their customers' money. HSBC, Barclays, Lloyds, NatWest and Nationwide have all moved to block or restrict third-party AI agents — software that can act with minimal human oversight — from accessing customer accounts, especially where such systems can make transactions without the customer's involvement.
There is no evidence yet of AI agents actually gaining access to UK bank accounts, but the country's large lenders are worried about what happens if an automated system mismanages customers' money — and about who would ultimately be on the hook. The restrictions, reported by The Telegraph, reflect fears of rogue agents.
The restrictions mark a line distinct from the UK's open banking regime, in place since 2018, under which the country's largest banks must let customers share account data with accredited third parties — a framework built around customer-initiated access and payments, not transactions an agent decides to make on its own.
The banks may have other, unspoken concerns as well — namely, what agentic finance could do to their business models.
Edgars Nemše, chief executive of GenLayer Foundation, an AI-focused blockchain infrastructure project, says routine banking tasks like paying bills, moving money and finding better rates could all be handed to agents. The uncomfortable corollary for banks is that agents would be able to seamlessly find customers a better deal elsewhere the moment it is published on the web.
"For plain accounts, that removes the switching costs and makes the space even more competitive," Nemše told Magazine.
The risk of agentic bank runs
That scenario could threaten more than just customer loyalty. In September, Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo, warned about a possible "agentic bank run".
If swarms of agents start moving household cash en masse from low-yield checking accounts to alternatives offering higher returns, banks would be drained of the low-cost funding they rely on to make loans — and the speed and scale of such a shift "would be a problem for the entire financial system."
JPMorgan Chase chief executive Jamie Dimon has also warned against allowing external agents unrestricted access to bank accounts. "You don't want rogue agents," he said on an October earnings call.
Regardless of short-term moves to hold back the tide, AI agents look more and more likely to revolutionize banking within a few years. Neeraj Makin, group head of strategy analytics at Emirates NBD, predicts agents will usher in a new era in which around-the-clock banking and near-instant payments are the norm by 2036.
"Forget about waiting for a payment for 24 hours or inter-country payments taking three days… all of that will be in seconds, atomic," he says, with AI agents taking over most financial decisions.
Banks risk losing the everyday customer interface
Ferdinand Dabitz, chief executive of Augustus, an AI-native banking and payments company, sees a similar shift in how customers interact with financial institutions. "Every consumer will have 10s and every business will have 100s of agents talking to their bank," Dabitz says.
A human interface will still remain important, he says — for managing those agents and providing a layer of trust, "especially in commercial banking."
Emirates NBD's developer experience team argued in July that financial institutions should build their own frameworks for agentic AI, rather than allowing individual teams to develop agents without common controls. Its Leap framework is designed to govern how agents authenticate with core banking systems, access sensitive data and carry out actions, with audit trails, monitoring and human oversight built in.
Major concerns remain, however, about the reliability of agents making significant financial decisions on their own. A recent Bank of England and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) survey found that while 80% of responding firms had deployed AI agents, just 2% used agents with broad autonomy, identifying data security, third-party dependencies and risks such as hallucinations among their biggest concerns.
From paying bills to making financial decisions
The shift is unlikely to happen overnight — "it will come in steps," Nemše says. "Today I use an agent to review my own and my company's finances every month and queue the payments, and I approve them. The next step is the natural one: once you trust it, you let it spend small amounts without asking."
Routine bills, subscriptions and the agent's own running costs would be among the first tasks to become autonomous, he says.
Dabitz says corporate treasury management could be an area delegated to agents, though banks will need to be involved in developing these early applications.
Who pays when an agent gets it wrong?
While consumers may enjoy the upside of automating their finances, the question of who is on the hook when an agent makes a mistake remains open.
Nemše says banks need to offer "delegated access as a normal feature" to avoid customers sharing logins with agents. Customers could set permissions and spending limits, and agents could make low-value transactions independently while requiring approval for larger amounts.
Existing dispute processes, however, may struggle if agents begin making thousands of transactions on behalf of each customer. "Even a small share going wrong is a lot of disputes," Nemše says. "The processes for handling them were built for people making a few payments a week. That part still has to be built."
Regulators move to define the rules
In the United States, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) — the regulator that charters and supervises US national banks — issued a supervisory framework on Nov. 4 covering banks' use of what it calls "super intelligence," including agentic systems.
The framework is intended to help bank examiners assess how institutions use the technology and does not introduce new binding requirements for banks. Scrutiny should reflect the potential consequences of an agent's actions, its level of autonomy and the degree of human oversight.
An AI system helping a bank employee draft a report, for example, would present a different risk from one authorized to move customer funds without approval — and the banks that get that balance right are likely to come out on top.
In the UK, by contrast, the restrictions remain self-imposed: the Bank of England and FCA have so far gauged AI adoption through surveys rather than set rules on agentic access, and whether British authorities follow the OCC with formal guidance of their own remains to be seen.