NewsMacroTrump's Personalized Diplomacy Hits Its Limits at Unprecedented Three-Way Summit With Xi and Putin

Trump's Personalized Diplomacy Hits Its Limits at Unprecedented Three-Way Summit With Xi and Putin

Author: Bworldonline·

Key Takeaways

  • •Trump, Xi, and Putin held an unprecedented three-way summit in Shenzhen that yielded a symbolic peace declaration rejecting nuclear war but no substantive agreements.
  • •The three leaders agreed to a nuclear risk reduction dialogue without setting a time frame and announced no plans for the bilateral or trilateral arms control talks Trump has long sought.
  • •The summit, which lasted less than 90 minutes, produced no movement on Iran, Ukraine, Taiwan, trade, or artificial intelligence.
  • •European allies meeting in Berlin voiced indignation at being excluded from the talks, with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz dismissing the summit as a photo op.
  • •The mid-December G20 summit in Florida, where Trump is expected to meet Xi again though Putin has not been formally invited, is now the nearest test of whether the Shenzhen encounter produces concrete follow-up.
Trump's Personalized Diplomacy Hits Its Limits at Unprecedented Three-Way Summit With Xi and Putin

WASHINGTON — US President Donald Trump has long relished the pomp and ceremony of international summitry, but his signature brand of personalized diplomacy has often produced little of substance. Analysts said his meeting on Thursday with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin starkly exposed the limits of that approach.

Mr. Trump entered the unprecedented three-way summit, held in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen, seeking to reassert himself on the world stage after being politically weakened at home. His Republican Party lost control of Congress in this month's midterm elections, and he remains locked in a tense stalemate with Iran in a war that polls show is deeply unpopular and has driven down his approval ratings.

The three leaders did agree to a symbolic "peace declaration" reaffirming that nuclear war should never be fought. But they announced no plans for the arms control talks Mr. Trump has long sought, and showed no signs of movement on issues such as Iran, Ukraine and Taiwan, or toward narrowing gaps over trade and artificial intelligence.

Instead, the leaders appeared content to gloss over their major differences. Mr. Xi was able to burnish his diplomatic credentials by hosting a big-power gathering, while Mr. Putin — whose country is a comparative economic lightweight — appeared on par with the world's two most powerful leaders without making major concessions.

Some analysts said the outcome of the Shenzhen summit may actually diminish Mr. Trump's stature on the world stage as he enters the lame-duck phase of his presidency, while bolstering two of Washington's main adversaries.

"Trump has always loved the pageantry and the sense that he's sitting down with the most important people in the world, and he got that moment," said Christopher Preble, a senior fellow at the Stimson Center think tank in Washington. "But as in other summits, it's hard to see any substantive progress made on any major issue."

A Familiar Pattern

For Mr. Trump, the summit fit the pattern of many of his leader-to-leader encounters since returning to office last year, including earlier meetings with Mr. Xi and Mr. Putin that did not yield breakthroughs, as well as his inconclusive first-term summits with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un.

Responding to queries from Reuters, White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly said: "After four years of weakness under Joe Biden, President Trump effectively restored American strength – and his events in Asia showcased the great respect and deference that world leaders bestow upon our country under this president's bold leadership."

"President Trump will meet with anyone in order to advance our country's interests," she added.

Mr. Trump has framed his willingness to engage directly with autocratic leaders such as Mr. Xi, Mr. Putin and Mr. Kim as decisive, high-profile efforts to deliver results in ways his predecessors avoided. Democratic lawmakers and other critics have countered that he has failed to lay the groundwork such summits require, lacks clear objectives, appears to cozy up to authoritarian leaders and often pressures traditional US allies.

After the meeting, Mr. Trump told NBC News that, "on a scale of zero to 10, I think it was a 12," offering the kind of upbeat assessment he frequently delivers after such events.

A former reality TV star who relishes political showmanship, Mr. Trump has signaled that his definition of diplomatic success places as much emphasis on the spectacle surrounding him as on any agreements reached at the negotiating table. Asked ahead of the meeting what he hoped to accomplish, he suggested in a Fox News interview that he had already secured a victory simply through the way he was received in China on Wednesday, when Mr. Xi greeted him directly at the airport with an elaborate military welcome — an unprecedented gesture.

Yalta Comparisons Fall Short

The three-way meeting drew comparisons, particularly in Russia, with the 1945 Yalta Conference between the United States, Britain and the Soviet Union, which formalized spheres of influence, set the stage for the post-World War Two order and became shorthand for great-power deals imposed on smaller countries. For Ukraine, which is engaged in a four-year-old war with invading Russian forces, such a comparison was particularly worrisome.

But Thursday's summit, which lasted less than 90 minutes, was no second Yalta — a conference that ran for more than a week and involved detailed discussions and far-reaching decisions.

European allies, who met in Berlin on Thursday to demonstrate their support for Ukraine, were indignant that Mr. Trump embraced Mr. Putin as a "friend" and that Europe was absent from the Shenzhen discussions. Speaking to reporters in Berlin, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said: "The meeting in Shenzhen was apparently first and foremost a photo op."

Mindful of how much weight Mr. Trump places on personal rapport as he crafts foreign policy decisions, many world leaders — from Europe to Asia and Latin America — have used flattery to seek an edge.

The Shenzhen meeting has also raised questions about what Mr. Trump has planned when he hosts the Group of 20 summit in mid-December at his golf resort in Florida, where he is expected to meet Mr. Xi again and could potentially see Mr. Putin, analysts say — though the Russian leader has not been formally invited. That mid-December gathering now stands as the nearest checkpoint for whether the Shenzhen encounter produces concrete follow-up.

Reflecting the challenges Mr. Trump could face in Washington once the balance of congressional power shifts in January, US Senator Charles Schumer of New York, who leads Democrats in the Senate, called Mr. Trump's meeting with Mr. Xi and Mr. Putin "a historic embarrassment that people will remember long into the future."

"Trump keeps acting like he struck the diplomatic deal of the century, but he didn't secure any meaningful commitments from China or Russia that will last even a millisecond," Mr. Schumer said.

Seeking a Nuclear Deal

Still, some analysts argued that the Shenzhen summit — by bringing adversaries together — could prove a plus for international stability. Daryl Kimball, executive director of the US-based Arms Control Association, said it was "positive" that the countries with the three largest nuclear arsenals issued a statement that "reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought." The three sides also agreed to hold a nuclear risk reduction dialogue, though they gave no time frame, leaving open when — or whether — such talks would convene.

"We need much more than rhetoric," Mr. Kimball added.

As he flew back to Washington, Mr. Trump told Reuters by phone that a three-way deal to limit nuclear arms was "a very hard thing" for him to achieve. China has resisted such an agreement, given that its arsenal is much smaller than those of the other two powers.

With two years left in office and still in command of the broad foreign policy powers of the US presidency, analysts say Mr. Trump may continue this brand of personal diplomacy, in part because he values unpredictability in his foreign affairs.

"Ultimately the proof of all of this is what is the resolution in Iran, what is resolution in Ukraine, if any," said Josh Lipsky, vice president of international economics at the Atlantic Council think tank. "That's how this will be judged over history."

— Reuters