Former Federal Prosecutor Joyce Vance Calls DOJ Conduct in Trump Golf Course Case 'Utterly Intolerable'
Key Takeaways
- •The Trump administration cut down more than 400 trees at East Potomac Park, prompting Judge Ana Reyes to stop extending the Justice Department the benefit of the doubt.
- •Former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance said Justice Department attorneys, who represent the United States rather than the president personally, should leave the case or resign when their client undermines them.
- •President Trump publicly inserted himself into the litigation through a post on Truth Social, a factor Vance cited in the judge losing patience with the government.
- •Plaintiffs are seeking an injunction against a park closure set to begin Nov. 15, alleging it is a prelude to new plans that would alter the golf course's structure, landscaping, and local public use.
- •Vance argued the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on the merits because of strong evidence the government is not playing by the rules, with the dispute forming part of a broader pattern that includes the Kennedy Center and a large arch project.

The legal battle over East Potomac Park and its golf course has produced one problem after another for the Justice Department and President Donald Trump's administration. After the administration cut down more than 400 trees at the site, the presiding judge stopped extending the department's lawyers the benefit of the doubt, and the hearings that followed have been rough for the government's attorneys.
On MS NOW, host Alicia Menendez posed a question she described as stemming more from curiosity than empathy. "How difficult is it for these attorneys right now to have the president of the United States fundamentally undermining them at every turn?" she asked.
Legal analyst and former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance replied that handling a simple golf course case in court should not be that difficult — yet this one has become exactly that.
"The first time that your client does that to you, you fire the client, or if you're a Justice Department attorney, you take yourself off of the case or you resign because it's utterly intolerable," Vance said. "That's what we're seeing play out in court. It's why Judge [Ana] Reyes is so angry. She's adopted the rule, you know, fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me." The tension she describes is structural: Justice Department attorneys represent the United States rather than the president personally, which is why she framed the choice facing them as stepping off the case or resigning.
According to Vance, it is clear the judge will not let the department mislead her again. The trial began with Judge Reyes "bending over backward to give the Justice Department the presumption of regularity, to assume that when they spoke to her, what they said was truthful and representations were made in good faith."
The government's conduct quickly proved that was not the case, and Trump then inserted himself into the matter by posting about it on Truth Social. "And she clearly now had enough," Vance said.
The golf course dispute is one of several projects Trump has carried out across the District, including the Kennedy Center and his giant arch project. Vance said it is all part of a pattern.
"You know, she's been pushing them in court this morning on whether a final decision has been made about whether to implement the new plans for the parks," Vance explained. "The plaintiffs are alleging that this proposed [park] shutdown, that they seek an injunction against, which is set to begin on Sunday, that that's just a prelude to implementing these new plans to alter the way the golf course is structured and laid out and the way the landscaping is done, all of which impacts local use of that property."
At its core, Vance said, the hearing is really about whether the Justice Department has "been deceitful" about the projects it has pursued over the past year. In her view, the plaintiffs hold ample evidence that the Nov. 15 closure will likely result in the course being torn apart and in Trump implementing his plans with or without permission.
"They have a likelihood of success on the merits because of the strength of their evidence that the government is not playing by the rules," Vance said. With the plaintiffs seeking an injunction against the Nov. 15 closure, the immediate questions are whether Reyes grants it and whether a final decision on the new park plans is acknowledged in court — the issue she pressed lawyers on during the hearing.
Source: Alternet