Clarity Act Defeat a 'Failure of American Leadership,' Says Trump's Former Crypto Adviser
Key Takeaways
- •The Clarity Act, which would have divided crypto market oversight between the SEC and CFTC, failed a key Senate procedural vote in September after ethics concerns over the Trump family's crypto ventures overshadowed largely resolved policy differences.
- •Witt said Trump had agreed to two ethics provisions, including one that would have barred federal officials from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, required divestment or a blind trust, and allowed state attorneys general to enforce violations.
- •With prospects for comprehensive legislation low, Witt expects U.S. crypto market structure to be shaped primarily through SEC and CFTC rulemaking, though parts of the Clarity Act could still pass within larger legislative packages, such as granting the CFTC spot market authority.
- •Witt framed the issue as American competitiveness, noting SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig are committed to moving markets on-chain while the EU's MiCA framework took full effect at the end of 2024.
- •Despite Democrats winning both chambers in the midterms and reportedly planning their own market structure bill, Witt said he is "not bearish" on crypto, viewing opposition as increasingly generational rather than partisan, and is weighing offers from crypto firms, venture capital firms, and defense companies after departing in October.

The U.S. Senate's failure to pass the Clarity Act was "a failure of American leadership," according to Patrick Witt, President Donald Trump's former top crypto adviser, who said the bill ran out of time ahead of the midterm elections.
"It was extremely disappointing," Witt said in an on-stage interview at Solana's Breakpoint conference in London. "I was knee deep in Clarity. I lived it for a year plus negotiating that bill," he noted, adding that the measure, which would have established a framework for regulating crypto markets and divided oversight between the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, "would have been incredibly impactful."
Witt served as executive director of the President's Council of Advisers for Digital Assets until last month and led the White House push for the legislation, which failed a key procedural vote in the Senate in September.
"We ultimately lost against the clock," he said, adding, "The policy was good. We resolved pretty much all of the policy differences." But with the midterm elections approaching, "the political issue of ethics really consumed everything else," he said.
Democrats had raised concerns over the Trump family's crypto ventures. Witt acknowledged that the president's involvement in crypto was "arguably the issue," but said Trump had agreed to two ethics provisions. The second would have barred federal officials, including the president, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, forced the president to divest certain digital assets or place them in a blind trust, and let state attorneys general enforce violations. "There's no precedent for those kinds of things in American law," he said.
Witt noted that the GENIUS stablecoin bill, which went on to be signed into law in July, also lost an initial procedural vote in 2025 but recovered because it came early in Trump's term. With Clarity, "we knew that we were going to get one shot at it, and unfortunately we just came up short," he said.
Regulators take the lead
Looking ahead, Witt said the odds of passing a comprehensive replacement are low. "I would expect that market structure in the United States is going to be less written on Capitol Hill and more written in the Federal Register, which is where the agencies do their rulemakings and issue their guidance," he said. Federal rulemaking typically involves publishing proposed rules and soliciting public comment before they are finalized.
Parts of the Clarity Act could still pass in larger legislative packages, and lawmakers could grant targeted powers, such as giving the Commodity Futures Trading Commission authority over spot crypto markets, he added.
Witt said regulators already have "ample authority," and that the administration had to "hold them back a little bit" while the bill played out. The SEC and CFTC have since moved ahead with their own crypto rules, though House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill (R-AR) has said those efforts fall short of what the legislation would have achieved.
SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig "are committed to moving markets on chain," Witt said, framing the issue as one of American competitiveness. "Capital is going to go where it's treated best," he said. Other jurisdictions have already formalized their own regimes — the European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) framework took full effect at the end of 2024.
'Not bearish'
Despite Democrats winning control of both chambers of Congress in this month's midterms, Witt said he is "not bearish on the industry overall," since the regulators and the president remain in place. Democrats are reportedly planning to push their own, broader market structure bill, which would still need to clear Senate procedural votes and win the president's signature to become law.
He said opposition to crypto is increasingly generational rather than purely partisan. While some Democrats, such as Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), are "going to be 100% opposed to anything that seemingly is favorable to crypto," younger lawmakers on both sides see it as "part of the fabric of financial infrastructure," he said, pointing to Sens. Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD) and Ruben Gallego (D-AZ).
Witt left the administration in October, The Hill reported. He said he has held talks with crypto firms, venture capital firms and defense companies, and hopes to announce his next move in the coming weeks.