NewsMacroTrump's 'wildly unusual' attacks threaten judge's safety amid D.C. golf course takeover fight, CNN legal analyst says

Trump's 'wildly unusual' attacks threaten judge's safety amid D.C. golf course takeover fight, CNN legal analyst says

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Judge Ana Reyes issued an order halting the Trump administration's renovation of East Potomac Golf Links, citing insufficient legal justification for the project.
  • •Challengers argued the administration failed to complete necessary approvals, an environmental review, and steps required under the Administrative Procedure Act.
  • •The administration claimed the renovation was needed for safety, but Reyes dismissed that argument as pretextual, noting thousands of people recently participated in a marathon at the course.
  • •CNN legal analyst Elie Honig said Trump's attacks on Reyes, though constitutionally protected, are highly unusual and contribute to a dangerous threat environment for federal judges.
  • •Reyes and her family members have received death threats in connection with the case, while Honig argued the judge has been patient and fair to the administration.
Trump's 'wildly unusual' attacks threaten judge's safety amid D.C. golf course takeover fight, CNN legal analyst says

President Donald Trump has engaged in "wildly unusual" conduct as he attempts to take over a Washington, D.C., golf course, according to CNN legal analyst Elie Honig — behavior that has left the judge presiding over the case fearing for her safety.

Honig appeared on CNN's The Situation Room on Monday morning, where host Wolf Blitzer asked him to respond to a series of recent stories — most prominently Trump's push to take over and heavily renovate East Potomac Golf Links, a move that has drawn public outcry and mounting legal scrutiny.

Over the weekend, Judge Ana Reyes, who is handling the case, issued a new order blocking the administration from continuing work on the course, citing the lack of legal justification for the renovation. The order leaves the renovation on hold for now as the litigation continues.

"So this ruling went against the Trump administration and its plans to close and renovate that golf course," Honig explained. "Now, the challengers argued that the administration had not gone through the necessary approvals. They had not gone through an environmental review. They had not gone through something called the Administrative Procedure Act, and therefore this needed to be put on hold. Now, the Trump administration countered. They said this is necessary to protect safety because the condition of the golf course is so dangerous that it's a real threat to life and limb."

The Administrative Procedure Act, which the challengers invoked, is the federal statute that lays out the steps agencies are required to follow before taking major actions and gives courts the basis to review — and halt — actions taken without the necessary process.

Reyes rejected that argument, dismissing the administration's safety claim as "pretextual" — which Honig said was "just a polite way of saying it's false." The judge also questioned how the course could be so dangerous when "thousands" of people took part in a marathon held there in recent weeks.

Blitzer pressed further on Trump's escalating verbal attacks against Reyes, including recent posts calling her a "crazed lunatic," and asked Honig how atypical such attacks are. Honig stressed that while Trump's insults are legal — and not anything new for him — they are nevertheless extremely "dangerous."

"It's very unusual, but it's something that Donald Trump has done time and again," he said. "You know, Wolf, the attorney general of the United States, Todd Blanche, just a few days ago, went on radio and was talking about the heightened threat environment around federal judges and other federal officials. This type of language — does the president have a constitutional right to say these things about a judge? Sure. Is it wildly unusual for him to do so? Absolutely. And does this contribute to the threat environment? Of course it does. Judge Reyes has said that she and her family members have received death threats because of this."

Honig added that the criticism of Reyes was "completely wrong," arguing that the judge "has given the administration every benefit of the doubt," held off on issuing certain rulings to give the administration a chance to try to fix things, and "has been eminently patient with the administration here."

"So does Trump have a right to say these things? Sure," Honig concluded. "Are they wrong and dangerous? Absolutely."