NewsMacroThomas Markle, Estranged Father of Duchess Meghan, Ruled Competent to Face Child Sexual Abuse Trial

Thomas Markle, Estranged Father of Duchess Meghan, Ruled Competent to Face Child Sexual Abuse Trial

Author: Bworldonline·

Key Takeaways

  • •US Magistrate Judge Lindsay Griffin ruled the 82-year-old mentally fit for trial after a court-appointed psychiatrist found that, despite a probable major neurocognitive disorder, he could understand the case and help in his defense.
  • •Markle was charged on November 5 with one felony count of possessing child sexual abuse images and was arrested the following day at a Lakeland, Florida assisted-living facility.
  • •Evidence cited in an FBI affidavit, including photos of Markle with a naked underage girl, was seized from two Los Angeles storage units he had rented since 2008.
  • •His home confinement was revoked and he was returned to jail without bond after he cut off his electronic ankle tag with a knife.
  • •Markle now faces parallel criminal proceedings in the United States and the Philippines, where complaints were filed in Cebu province, while he denies the allegations as untrue.
Thomas Markle, Estranged Father of Duchess Meghan, Ruled Competent to Face Child Sexual Abuse Trial

TAMPA, Florida — A US judge in Florida ruled on Thursday that Thomas Markle, the estranged father of Britain's Duchess of Sussex, Meghan Markle, is mentally competent to answer a federal court charge accusing him of being a child sexual predator.

Accepting the findings of a court-appointed forensic psychiatrist, US Magistrate Judge Lindsay Griffin determined that the 82-year-old, who is the father-in-law of Prince Harry, was mentally fit to understand the proceedings against him and to properly assist in his own defense, court records showed.

Neither prosecutors nor the defense disputed the psychiatrist's evaluation, which was set out in a 15-page report and based in large part on the doctor's in-person interview with Mr. Markle in prison last week.

Charges and Arrest

Mr. Markle was charged on November 5 in a criminal complaint — the charging document that initiates a federal criminal case — with a single felony count of possessing child sexual abuse images. He was arrested the following day, November 6, at an assisted-living center in Florida.

According to an FBI affidavit filed with the complaint, the material in question — including two explicit photographs of Mr. Markle posed with a naked underage girl, along with other images showing him with children in various stages of undress — was found in two Los Angeles storage units.

Commenting on the case at the time of the arrest, FBI Director Kash Patel said Mr. Markle had "targeted innocent children and sought to steal their innocence through his criminal actions."

Competency Ruling

Thursday's ruling capped a competency proceeding set in motion by the judge after Mr. Markle's first court hearing on the day of his arrest. In ordering a psychiatric examination of the defendant, Ms. Griffin wrote that she found "reasonable cause" to believe Mr. Markle was suffering from some mental deficiency, citing in part his advanced age and his "lack of recall" during that first court appearance.

Dr. Aime Gerodimos, who conducted the evaluation, wrote in her report that Mr. Markle appeared to suffer from a "major neurocognitive disorder," possibly the result of mild vascular disease. She also found that he was likely "exaggerating deficits" when asked to recall specifics of the allegations against him.

The psychiatrist concluded, however, that Mr. Markle "does have sufficient present ability to understand the nature and consequences of the proceedings against him and to assist properly in his defense" — the legal standard a criminal defendant must meet to be deemed competent. Under US federal law, a defendant found incompetent cannot stand trial while the incapacity persists, making the competency finding a prerequisite for the case to proceed.

Case Originated in the Philippines

Mr. Markle was first taken into custody at the assisted-living facility where he was residing in Lakeland, Florida, near Tampa. Ms. Griffin initially ordered him placed under home confinement on the condition that he wear an electronic monitoring device. Days later, however, the judge revoked the arrangement and ordered him back to jail without bond after Mr. Markle cut off his electronic ankle tag with a knife.

It remains unclear when Mr. Markle will be transferred to federal custody in California, where the case against him was lodged. On Thursday, the judge set a preliminary hearing in the case for December 1 in Tampa — the next scheduled step now that the competency question has been resolved.

According to the FBI affidavit, federal agents acting on a search warrant earlier this month seized a large cache of slides, film negatives and books from two storage lockers Mr. Markle had rented in Los Angeles since 2008. One of the photos showed a naked girl in a room that appears to be part of a motel chain in the Philippines, where Mr. Markle previously resided and where authorities initiated an investigation of him last month, the affidavit said.

Philippine police said on Wednesday that criminal complaints had been filed against Mr. Markle in the country's Cebu province, where he lived. The complaints accuse him of violating local laws against the online sexual abuse and exploitation of children, police said. With filings pending in both countries, Mr. Markle now faces criminal proceedings under two separate legal systems.

Family Estrangement

Mr. Markle has denied the allegations, telling the Daily Mail that the claims were untrue and describing them as "sick lies."

Meghan Markle, an American actor, has been estranged from her father since the run-up to her 2018 marriage to Harry, King Charles' younger son. The duchess has said she first became aware of the allegations against her father around that time and was "deeply distressed" over the matter, which led her to cut off contact between him and her two children, Archie, 7, and Lilibet, 5.

— Reuters

Source: Bworldonline