Supreme Court's 5-4 Ballroom Ruling Weakens Watchdog Groups' Ability to Sue Federal Government, Says Legal Scholar Noah Feldman
Key Takeaways
- •The Supreme Court dismissed the National Trust for Historic Preservation's challenge to the White House ballroom project in a 5-4 ruling issued August 31.
- •The five GOP-appointed justices formed the majority, while Chief Justice Roberts and the three Democrat-appointed justices dissented.
- •The unsigned opinion found the National Trust likely lacked standing to challenge the construction, which is replacing the East Wing.
- •Noah Feldman argues the ruling narrows standing more than any recent decision, exceeding even Justice Scalia's stance in the 1992 Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife case.
- •The decision came on the emergency docket without full oral argument or briefing, which Feldman says weakens judicial limits on presidential authority.

In a 5-4 decision issued on Monday, August 31, the U.S. Supreme Court dismissed a lawsuit brought by the National Trust for Historic Preservation challenging President Donald Trump's ability to move forward with construction of a White House ballroom. According to SCOTUSBlog, the majority held that "the plaintiff likely lacks a legal right, known as standing, to challenge the project at all." Harvard University legal scholar Noah Feldman argues that the implications of the ruling extend far beyond the ballroom itself, because standing doctrine often determines whether outside groups can get into federal court in the first place.
Chief Justice John Roberts joined the Court's three Democrat-appointed justices — Sonia Sotomayor, Ketanji Brown Jackson and Elena Kagan — in dissent. The majority consisted of the five GOP-appointed justices: Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas, Amy Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh and Neil Gorsuch.
Writing in an op-ed for Bloomberg News, Feldman explained: "Over a dissent by Chief Justice John Roberts, who was joined by the Court's three liberals, the Court's five conservatives said that the National Trust for Historic Preservation lacked standing to challenge the ballroom being built where the East Wing of the White House used to be. The unsigned opinion raises an obvious question — if the National Trust for Historic Preservation can't challenge the destruction of a historic building, who can? — and a less obvious one: How is the White House like a crocodile?"
The Harvard legal scholar continued: "I'm not being facetious — Roberts actually does raise that second question. And the consequences of the first go beyond the narrow issue of who has the legal authority to challenge Trump's architectural imperialism. More than any other Supreme Court decision in recent memory, this one narrows the grounds for federal lawsuits by watchdog groups. It's so extreme, it goes much further to deny standing than even the late Justice Antonin Scalia did."
Feldman noted that Scalia denied standing in the 1992 case Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, which "involved a challenge to an EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) regulation."
"The vote that surprises me most in this case is that of Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who clerked for Scalia and ordinarily takes pains to make sure the Court interprets his views correctly," Feldman commented.
According to Feldman, the Court's ballroom ruling is "distressing" because it makes it "harder to sue the federal government in an emergency docket case that did not benefit from full oral argument or briefing." That procedural point matters because emergency-docket rulings can shape access to judicial review even when the Court has not used its more fully developed merits process.
"Trump's desire to act like an emperor, marring the Washington cityscape with disproportionately large triumphal arches and ballrooms, is offensive both aesthetically and symbolically; these are not monuments to democracy," Feldman wrote. "The Court's ballroom decision is disappointing for deeper reasons: It weakens the capacity of the judiciary to keep the president within the limits of his legal authority. In so doing, it undermines the rule of law itself."