Philippine Supreme Court Upholds P83-Million Tax Refund for San Miguel Brewery
Key Takeaways
- •The Philippine Supreme Court's First Division, in a ruling promulgated on Oct. 28, denied the Commissioner of Internal Revenue's petition for review and affirmed San Miguel Brewery's entitlement to a refund or tax credit of P83,018,504.21.
- •The case stemmed from excess excise taxes collected on San Mig Light in 2013 under the Sin Tax Reform Law, which set 2013 rates of P15 per liter for fermented liquors priced at P50.60 or less per liter and P20 per liter for those above the threshold.
- •BIR Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 prescribed a uniform excise rate of P20.57 per liter for bottled and canned San Mig Light, exceeding both statutory rates of P15 and P20 per liter.
- •San Miguel Brewery paid the BIR-prescribed rate to secure the release of its products from its breweries before seeking a refund of the excess payments.
- •The Supreme Court held that the Bureau of Internal Revenue cannot, through an administrative issuance, impose excise rates above those prescribed by Congress, and the tax court's award stands whether paid in cash or applied as a credit.

The Philippine Supreme Court has affirmed a P83.02-million tax refund or tax credit for San Miguel Brewery, Inc., upholding a Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision concerning excess excise taxes collected on San Mig Light products in 2013.
In a ruling promulgated on Oct. 28, the High Tribunal's First Division denied the petition for review filed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, sustaining the tax court's finding that the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) had levied excise tax rates beyond those authorized by law. The decision was penned by Associate Justice Ramon Paul L. Hernando and upheld the brewer's entitlement to a refund or tax credit certificate amounting to P83,018,504.21.
The dispute arose from the implementation of Republic Act No. 10351, the Sin Tax Reform Law — a 2012 measure that overhauled excise levies on alcohol and tobacco products — which introduced revised excise tax rates on fermented liquors effective Jan. 1, 2013. Under the statute, fermented liquors with a net retail price of P50.60 or less per liter were taxed at P15 in 2013, while products priced above that threshold were taxed at P20 per liter.
Despite these statutory rates, BIR Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 prescribed a uniform excise tax rate of P20.57 per liter for bottled and canned San Mig Light, a figure that exceeded both statutory rates of P15 and P20 per liter. San Miguel Brewery paid the prescribed amount to secure the release of its products from its breweries, then sought a refund of the excess payments.
The company argued that the BIR circular imposed excise taxes exceeding the rates authorized under the amended National Internal Revenue Code. The Supreme Court sided with the tax court, holding that the BIR cannot, through an administrative issuance, impose excise rates above those prescribed by Congress. The ruling draws a clear line for taxpayers and regulators alike: revenue agencies implement tax laws through issuances, but those issuances must stay within the rates lawmakers have set. With the review petition denied, the tax court's award of the P83.02-million refund or tax credit certificate to the brewer stands, whether paid out in cash or applied as a credit. — Erika Mae P. Sinaking