NewsCryptoSupreme Court Declines Custodia Bank's Appeal for Direct Fed Payment Access

Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank's Appeal for Direct Fed Payment Access

Author: Cointelegraph·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank's appeal, leaving standing the ruling that Federal Reserve banks are not obligated to grant master accounts to every eligible institution.
  • •Custodia has sought a master account since 2020, but the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City rejected its application in January 2023, citing risks tied to its crypto-focused business model.
  • •In a March dissent, Judge Timothy Tymkovich argued that granting the Fed discretion over master account approvals effectively allows it to override state banking decisions.
  • •The appeal received outside support from the Blockchain Association, Senator Cynthia Lummis, and former Senator Patrick Toomey.
  • •Kraken Financial obtained a restricted, one-year account from the same Kansas City Fed in March, and Custodia may still file a new application or pursue limited payment access under a separate proposal.
Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank's Appeal for Direct Fed Payment Access

The United States Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal from crypto-focused Custodia Bank, effectively ending the Wyoming-chartered institution's latest legal effort to secure direct access to the Federal Reserve's payment system (docket 26-62).

Founded by Caitlin Long, Custodia has sought a Federal Reserve master account since 2020. Such an account would allow the bank to send and receive payments directly through the central bank rather than routing transactions through third-party financial institutions. With Monday's decision, an earlier ruling affirming the Fed's authority to reject applications from eligible banks will remain in effect.

The case highlights the challenges crypto-facing banks continue to encounter in gaining direct access to the US payment system. Even where state-chartered banks meet the qualifications for master accounts, the Federal Reserve is not required to approve every application — the very question at the center of Custodia's legal challenge.

In a dissent issued in March, US Circuit Judge Timothy Tymkovich criticized the appeals court's decision to give Federal Reserve banks discretion over master account approvals.

“Without a master account, a bank cannot operate in the modern banking system,” Tymkovich wrote, arguing that the ruling effectively hands the Fed the power to override state banking decisions.

A timeline of events

Custodia first sued the Federal Reserve in 2022 after roughly two years of waiting for a decision on the master account application it filed in 2020. The Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City ultimately rejected the request in January 2023, citing concerns about risks linked to the bank's crypto-focused business model.

In October 2025, a federal appeals court ruled against Custodia, finding that Federal Reserve banks are not obligated to grant master accounts to every eligible institution. The court declined to reconsider its decision in March, prompting the bank to escalate the dispute to the Supreme Court.

The appeal drew outside support as well. The Blockchain Association argued that the Fed's ability to reject applications could weaken the authority of state banking regulators. Senator Cynthia Lummis and former Senator Patrick Toomey also filed a brief with the Supreme Court in August supporting Custodia's petition.

Broader context

Monday's decision comes as other crypto-focused banks seek access to the Fed's payment system. In March, Kraken Financial, the banking arm of crypto exchange Kraken, received approval for a restricted account from the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City — the same regional Fed bank that rejected Custodia's application.

Notably, Kraken's account was approved for an initial one-year period and allows it to send and receive payments through the Fed's Fedwire system. However, the account carries restrictions and does not offer all the services of a full master account.

Despite the Supreme Court setback, Custodia may still be able to apply for another master account, or pursue limited access to the Fed's payment system under a separate proposal.