Supreme Court Ends Custodia Bank’s Fight for a Fed Master Account, Leaving the Fed Free to Deny Crypto Banks
Key Takeaways
- •The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, allowing the Tenth Circuit's judgment to stand without ruling on the underlying statutory dispute.
- •The Tenth Circuit's 2-1 decision held that regional Federal Reserve Banks have discretion to deny master accounts even to legally eligible applicants, interpreting the Monetary Control Act's availability mandate as a pricing rule rather than an account right.
- •The Kansas City Fed rejected Custodia's master account application in January 2023, citing its unprecedented business model narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities, despite having confirmed the bank's legal eligibility in January 2021.
- •Without a master account, Custodia must clear payments through a correspondent institution, a significant constraint for a bank barred from lending and required to hold customer deposits fully in liquid assets.
- •Custodia's legal battle ended more than six years after its October 2020 application, leaving crypto-focused banks and novel charters with little judicial recourse if a Reserve Bank turns them away.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to review the Federal Reserve’s refusal to grant Custodia Bank a master account, ending chief executive Caitlin Long’s years-long fight for direct access to the central bank’s payment rails.
The case, Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, No. 26-62, is listed under “certiorari denied” on the Court’s Monday order list. The denial leaves in place a Tenth Circuit ruling that regional Federal Reserve Banks have discretion to reject even legally eligible applicants, and it closes the last courtroom path Custodia had to force the Fed’s hand. A denial of certiorari is not a ruling on the merits — the Court expressed no view on the underlying statutory dispute and simply let the appeals court’s judgment stand.
A master account is a bank’s account at a Federal Reserve Bank and the entry point to Fedwire and other payment services. Without one, a state-chartered bank must rely on a correspondent institution to move money. For a bank built like Custodia — barred from lending and required to hold customer deposits fully in liquid assets — direct settlement at the Fed is central to the service it set out to provide, since payments otherwise must clear through a correspondent institution.
Eligible, then turned away
Custodia is a Wyoming special purpose depository institution, a charter that bars it from making loans and requires dollar deposits to be fully reserved in liquid assets. After receiving that charter, the bank applied for a master account at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City in October 2020. In January 2021, the Kansas City Fed confirmed Custodia was legally eligible and told it there were “no showstoppers.” In August 2021, Custodia also applied for Federal Reserve membership.
While those requests sat pending, the Board of Governors in August 2022 published guidelines for evaluating master-account applications. The rules placed firms that are neither federally insured nor supervised by a federal banking agency into “Tier 3,” the group that “generally receive[s] the strictest level of review.” Custodia fell into that bucket.
On January 27, 2023, the Kansas City Fed denied the master account, citing an “unprecedented” business model “narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities” and concluding the risks were “highly likely” to be “inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices.” The same day, the Board denied Custodia’s membership application, saying approval “would be inconsistent with the financial, managerial, and corporate powers factors.”
The last appeal fails
Custodia had already sued the Fed and the Kansas City Fed in June 2022 over the delay. On March 29, 2024, U.S. District Judge Scott W. Skavdahl in Wyoming ruled that the Federal Reserve Act gives Reserve Banks discretion to grant or deny master accounts, dismissed Custodia’s Administrative Procedure Act claim for lack of a final agency action, and granted the Kansas City Fed summary judgment.
The Tenth Circuit affirmed on October 31, 2025, in a 2-1 decision Bitcoin Magazine covered at the time. Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, held that Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act, which says a Reserve Bank “may receive” deposits, is discretionary, and that the Monetary Control Act of 1980’s instruction that Fed services “shall be available” to nonmember banks is a pricing rule, not a right to an account.
Tymkovich dissented. “We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall,” he wrote. The 1980 law, he said, “mandates access to the Fed’s payment services for all nonmember depository institutions.” On March 13, 2026, the full Tenth Circuit denied rehearing, with Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voting to grant it. Being denied a master account, Tymkovich wrote in that later dissent, is “akin to a death sentence.”
Custodia’s July petition, filed by Kannon Shanmugam, asked whether the Monetary Control Act “gives presidents of regional Federal Reserve Banks discretionary authority to deny master accounts” to legally eligible nonmember banks. The Board and the Kansas City Fed opposed review. The Court distributed the case for its Nov. 13 conference and turned it down Monday. In turning the case away, the Court left unanswered the question that divided the Tenth Circuit’s panel: whether the Monetary Control Act’s instruction that Fed services “shall be available” to nonmember banks gives eligible institutions an enforceable right to an account.
The practical effect is that a state charter, even one that makes a bank legally eligible, does not guarantee a door into the Fed’s payment system. Custodia’s own fight ends more than six years after its October 2020 application, with the bank still lacking the account it sought. Crypto-focused banks and other novel charters now have little judicial recourse, at least in the Tenth Circuit, if a Reserve Bank turns them away. Critics have long described that pattern of exclusion, and of banks cutting off crypto firms, as Operation Choke Point 2.0.
Neither Custodia nor Long had commented on the Supreme Court’s denial as of 10:07 a.m. ET Monday.
This article first appeared on Bitcoin Magazine and is written by Micah Zimmerman.