NewsCryptoS&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Weakest Stability Rating as Higher-Risk Assets Reach 28% of Circulation

S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Weakest Stability Rating as Higher-Risk Assets Reach 28% of Circulation

Author: Hokanews·

Key Takeaways

  • •S&P Global Ratings maintained USDT's stability assessment at 5 (weak), the lowest level on its five-point scale, citing reserve quality, potential undercollateralization, and transparency concerns.
  • •Higher-risk assets backing USDT, including gold, Bitcoin, equities, and loans, reached 28% of circulating supply as of September 30, up from 24% a year earlier.
  • •S&P cited limited disclosure of audited financial statements, reserve segregation, and custodian information, making it harder for external observers to verify Tether's claimed backing.
  • •The rise in higher-risk assets does not by itself establish undercollateralization, and the assessment is not a statement that USDT has lost its peg or failed redemption obligations.
  • •Tether rejected the rating, arguing that S&P's evaluation framework, rather than the quality of its reserves, is the source of the problem.
S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Weakest Stability Rating as Higher-Risk Assets Reach 28% of Circulation

S&P Global Ratings has maintained its lowest stablecoin stability assessment on Tether's USDT, assigning the world's largest stablecoin a score of 5 (weak) on its five-point scale after exposure to higher-risk assets in the token's reserves rose to 28% of circulating supply. The assessment cites concerns over reserve quality, the possibility of undercollateralization, and limited transparency in Tether's financial disclosures. Ratings of this kind are intended to gauge how well a stablecoin is positioned to maintain its peg, weighing reserve quality, custody arrangements and disclosure rather than market performance.

According to details reported by Wu Blockchain (X post), S&P kept the rating on its five-point assessment scale, where 5 denotes the weakest level and 1 the strongest. The evaluation indicates that the composition of the assets backing USDT remains a concern, particularly as a growing share of the circulating supply corresponds to assets that S&P classifies as higher risk.

Higher-Risk Assets Reach 28% of Circulating USDT

S&P Global Ratings reported that higher-risk assets held in connection with USDT reserves were equivalent to 28% of the stablecoin's circulation as of September 30. A year earlier, the figure stood at 24%, an increase of four percentage points over the twelve-month period.

The assets identified in the assessment include gold, Bitcoin, equities and loans. Their combined weight has drawn attention to the composition of Tether's reserves and to the potential risks of relying on assets whose value or liquidity may be less predictable than that of traditional cash and cash-equivalent holdings.

The rise from 24% to 28% does not, by itself, establish that USDT is undercollateralized. S&P nevertheless identified the growing exposure to higher-risk assets as a factor raising concerns that the stablecoin's reserves could prove insufficient under certain circumstances.

USDT is the largest stablecoin in the world and plays a significant role in cryptocurrency markets, where it is widely used as a trading and settlement medium. At that scale, the quality of the assets standing behind the token matters not only to holders but to the broader market infrastructure that transacts in it. Its stability assessment is therefore closely tied to questions over the quality, availability, and transparency of the assets backing its circulating supply.

S&P Flags Transparency and Reserve Management Concerns

Beyond the composition of its reserves, S&P also pointed to limitations in Tether's financial disclosures. The agency specifically cited limited disclosure of audited financial statements, the segregation of reserves, and information about custodians.

These factors are relevant to assessing whether a stablecoin's reserves are independently verifiable, appropriately separated, and securely held. Limited disclosure in these areas can make it more difficult for external observers to evaluate the underlying assets and the arrangements supporting a stablecoin's claimed backing.

S&P's decision to maintain the 5 (weak) assessment reflects broader concerns about both reserve-related risks and the information available to evaluate Tether's financial position. The agency's rating is a stability assessment rather than a statement that USDT has already lost its peg or failed to meet redemption obligations.

Tether Rejects S&P's Assessment

Tether disputed the rating, arguing that the problem lies with S&P's evaluation framework rather than the quality of its reserves. The disagreement highlights the difference between the rating agency's approach to evaluating stablecoin stability and Tether's position on the adequacy of its backing assets. Where S&P emphasized higher-risk asset exposure, disclosure limitations, and potential undercollateralization, Tether rejected the conclusions drawn from that framework.

The key figures in the assessment are the 28% exposure to higher-risk assets as of September 30, compared with 24% a year earlier, and S&P Global Ratings' continued 5 (weak) score for USDT, the lowest level on its five-point stability scale. Future updates to the score would rest on the same two areas at the center of the current disagreement: the mix of reserve assets and the extent of Tether's disclosures.

Source: Hokanews