NewsStocksSony Defeats £2 Billion UK Claim Over PlayStation Store Prices

Sony Defeats £2 Billion UK Claim Over PlayStation Store Prices

Author: Coinotag·

Key Takeaways

  • •The Competition Appeal Tribunal in London dismissed a collective claim worth approximately £2 billion ($2.64 billion) against Sony over PlayStation Store pricing, with the ruling published on Tuesday.
  • •The action was brought by consumer advocate Alex Neill in August 2022 on behalf of an estimated 12.2 million UK PlayStation users who bought digital games or add-ons since August 2016.
  • •The claim alleged that Sony abused its dominant position by imposing a 30% commission on digital games and in-game purchases, the cost of which was passed on to consumers through higher prices.
  • •Sony denied the allegations, maintaining that its 30% commission aligns with standard industry practice and that the majority of games and add-ons are sold at discounted prices.
  • •Following the dismissal, the estimated 12.2 million class members will receive no compensation, while similar claims over other digital storefronts' commission structures remain before the tribunal under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 regime.
Sony Defeats £2 Billion UK Claim Over PlayStation Store Prices

London's Competition Appeal Tribunal has dismissed a collective claim worth approximately £2 billion ($2.64 billion) against Sony over PlayStation Store pricing, in a ruling published on Tuesday. The decision ends the action, which was brought by consumer advocate Alex Neill on behalf of an estimated 12.2 million PlayStation users in the United Kingdom.

Background of the Claim

Neill, a long-standing consumer rights campaigner, filed the case with the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) in London in August 2022. The claim alleged that Sony Interactive Entertainment abused its dominant position in the UK market for digital game and add-on distribution by imposing a 30% commission on digital games and in-game purchases made through the PlayStation Store. According to the claim, the cost of that commission was passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices.

The action sought damages on behalf of UK residents who had purchased digital games or add-ons through the store since August 2016. In July 2023, the tribunal certified the case to proceed as an opt-out collective claim, a mechanism that binds all eligible class members to the outcome unless they choose to opt out.

Sony's Defence

Sony denied the allegations throughout the proceedings. The company maintained that its 30% commission is in line with standard industry practice for digital storefronts — a rate that has long been the prevailing fee across major digital games and app marketplaces — and that the majority of games and add-ons are sold at discounted prices, meaning customers are not systematically overcharged.

The Ruling

With Tuesday's ruling, the CAT dismissed the claim, bringing the multi-year legal battle to a close. The dismissal means the estimated 12.2 million class members will not receive compensation under this action, and it concludes one of the largest consumer claims yet brought over digital storefront pricing in the UK. The case was one of a series of high-profile opt-out collective claims brought before the tribunal under the regime introduced by the Consumer Rights Act 2015, which allows consumers to pursue damages for alleged breaches of competition law through a single representative action, and comparable claims concerning the commission structures of other major digital storefronts remain before the tribunal.

This content was first published on COINOTAG.