NewsStocksSkims' $148 Advent Calendar Flop Fuels 'Stunt' Theories, but Marketers Say Store Credit May Not Win Back Angry Customers

Skims' $148 Advent Calendar Flop Fuels 'Stunt' Theories, but Marketers Say Store Credit May Not Win Back Angry Customers

Author: Fortune Crypto·

Key Takeaways

  • •Skims responded to the backlash by contacting every calendar buyer and offering a choice between a full cash refund, which requires returning the product, or store credit that lets customers keep it.
  • •Social-listening data from Starlight Analytics showed negative posts about Skims outnumbered positive ones roughly eight to one between November 2 and November 11, with negativity rising to 76% of mentions on November 11.
  • •Some marketing professionals argued the credit remedy resembles deliberate rage-bait, since research shows shoppers often overspend store credit, while other experts rejected the stunt theory, saying customers who feel cheated do not spend like gift-card holders.
  • •Skims raised $225 million last year at a $5 billion valuation, and analysts said the greater danger is long-term erosion of customer trust rather than the direct cost of refunding a single product.
  • •Roughly 43% of Americans hold leftover gift cards, vouchers, or store credit averaging $244 unspent, suggesting some of Skims' credit-based compensation may never be redeemed.
Skims' $148 Advent Calendar Flop Fuels 'Stunt' Theories, but Marketers Say Store Credit May Not Win Back Angry Customers

Kim Kardashian's shapewear brand Skims is scrambling to contain a wave of customer backlash after its $148 12-day advent calendar became the target of ridicule across social media this week. The box's contents—keychains, bobby pins, scrunchies, and hair ties—offered none of the bodysuits or loungewear that made the company popular.

Advent calendars—countdown boxes of small daily gifts—have become a holiday retail staple, with beauty and lifestyle brands typically using them to showcase miniatures of their signature products.

“We might be on track for the worst advent calendar I've ever opened,” content creator Kayla Ryan said in a TikTok video this week, referring to the 12-day set that customers have been unboxing and criticizing for the past several days. “I could get these at Dollar Tree,” she continued, pulling three unpacked hair ties from the day three slot.

Countless videos like Ryan's have flooded social media in recent days, prompting the company to move quickly to contain the fallout. In response to the online outrage, Skims “personally contacted every customer who purchased the calendar and offered them a choice of a full refund or a SKIMS credit to put towards other products,” a spokesperson told other outlets. Skims did not respond to multiple requests for comment from Fortune.

There is a catch, according to the email buyers received: a cash refund means sending the calendar back, while shoppers who opt for store credit get to keep it. That detail fueled theories that Skims had deliberately rage-baited its customers.

“Skims knew what they were doing with that advent calendar. I'd bet money it was intentional,” Jessica Tillery, a senior vice president of brand communications for Allison Worldwide, wrote in a LinkedIn post this week. “Every dollar spent over that $148 credit is new revenue for them,” she added. “Every person who comes back to shop with that credit is a repeat purchaser.”

Data does show that gift-card overspending happens. Nearly 60% of shoppers say they would go past a card's balance when using it, spending $73 more on average, according to Blackhawk Network's 2026 research. A 2025 study by Northwestern Kellogg School of Management lecturer Ata Jami also found that shoppers are more likely to spend money they get back from returns, and more inclined to splurge with it, since it doesn't sting the way spending regular cash does.

Why some execs think the marketing stunt theory falls apart

But other marketers and consumer researchers who spoke with Fortune don't buy the stunt theory. Customers who feel ripped off, they argue, don't spend like someone holding a birthday gift card—and new social-listening data shows the negativity sticking around even as the online chatter dies down. For a company that raised $225 million last year at a $5 billion valuation and is heading into the heart of the holiday shopping season, the steeper price may be shoppers' trust in the brand.

“I don't buy the stunt theory,” Chris Ribeiro, founder of consumer insights firm Starlight Analytics and a marketing professor at Rutgers Business School, told Fortune. “Any time you alienate your core customer and make them feel stupid, that's bad marketing in my opinion.”

Ribeiro added that the credit shouldn't be confused with a windfall: “This store credit is the customer's own $148, following a poor experience.”

Starlight's tracking of U.S. social posts about Skims and the calendar found negative posts beat positive ones by about eight to one between Nov. 2 and Nov. 11. And as the total number of posts fell off, negativity grew to dominate what was left, making up 13% of mentions on Nov. 6 and 76% on Nov. 11—a figure drawn from a partial day of data.

Others believe the problem started long before the unboxing videos went live. “No brand wakes up hoping its holiday launch gets called overpriced junk,” Nataly Kelly, chief marketing officer of consumer insights platform Zappi, told Fortune. “This is a product that never got checked against what shoppers think $148 should buy.”

Zappi's research shows just one in 10 consumers sticks solely to name brands, suggesting brand loyalty alone won't carry a weak product. “A logo can't carry a box of hair ties anymore,” Kelly said.

Ben Metcalfe, founder of BlackFire Marketing, told Fortune that offering store credit is “smarter than just a refund” because it gets shoppers back in the door. Plenty of that money goes untouched, though: roughly 43% of Americans hold leftover gift cards, vouchers, or store credit, with an average of $244 unspent, according to a 2024 Bankrate survey.

Metcalfe expects Skims to weather the cost of a single calendar, but the bigger risk is what customers remember long term. “Negative attention can boost awareness, but awareness isn't loyalty,” he said. “Brands can survive a single viral mistake, but they struggle when their customers start to see a pattern.”

From here, the clearest indicators are measurable ones: the split between buyers who send the calendar back for a cash refund and those who keep it on credit, and whether negativity's share of Skims mentions recedes from the partial-day 76% reading Starlight logged on Nov. 11. Both figures speak directly to the question Metcalfe raised about what customers remember once the viral moment passes.

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com.