NewsStocksPSE's Uniform 10% Dynamic Threshold Plan May Trigger More Trading Freezes in Less Liquid Stocks

PSE's Uniform 10% Dynamic Threshold Plan May Trigger More Trading Freezes in Less Liquid Stocks

Author: Bworldonline·

Key Takeaways

  • •The PSE proposed replacing its current three-tier dynamic threshold system with a uniform 10% limit applied between successive last traded prices, as detailed in a Nov. 12 consultation paper.
  • •Securities currently carrying 20% thresholds would see the allowed price gap between successive trades halved, while the most actively traded group retains its existing 10% limit.
  • •Less liquid stocks could experience more frequent temporary trading freezes when significant news or large orders breach the tighter threshold, potentially delaying price discovery and trade execution rather than eliminating volatility.
  • •Trading executives Toby Allan C. Arce and Jesus Mariano P. Ocampo supported the standardization for simplifying rules and improving clarity, with Arce urging monitoring to ensure the tighter limit does not cause excessive interruptions or hamper efficient price adjustment.
  • •The proposed threshold would not apply to block sales, negotiated trades, or cross transactions, and the PSE is accepting public comments until Nov. 19.
PSE's Uniform 10% Dynamic Threshold Plan May Trigger More Trading Freezes in Less Liquid Stocks

The Philippine Stock Exchange's (PSE) proposal to adopt a uniform 10% dynamic threshold could lead to more frequent temporary trading freezes in less actively traded stocks, potentially delaying price adjustments and trade execution, according to a trading executive.

Globalinks Securities and Stocks, Inc. Head of Sales Trading Toby Allan C. Arce said the plan would simplify trading rules and reinforce safeguards against abrupt price movements and erroneous orders, but could also change how less liquid securities respond to significant news or large orders.

"Less liquid securities may experience more frequent temporary trading freezes when significant news or large orders trigger sharp price adjustments," he said in a Viber message on Tuesday. "This could delay price discovery and trade execution rather than necessarily eliminate volatility."

Under the proposal, the PSE would replace its current three-tier dynamic threshold with a single 10% limit applied between successive last traded price updates, regardless of how frequently a security trades. The change would tighten thresholds for less frequently traded securities, which currently carry limits of 15% or 20%, while retaining the existing 10% threshold for the most actively traded group. For securities currently in the 20% tier, that would halve the allowed price gap between successive trades.

Under the proposed rules, trading in a security would be temporarily frozen when an order would breach its dynamic threshold during continuous trading. Orders cannot be posted, modified, or canceled while the security is frozen, and the exchange would accept or reject the breaching order in accordance with its implementing guidelines. For investors in thinly traded names, the practical effect is being sidelined at the very moments — significant news or large orders — that can set off a freeze.

Mr. Arce said the PSE should monitor whether the tighter threshold would result in excessive interruptions or hamper the ability of prices to adjust efficiently to market developments.

"Overall, I believe the proposal is reasonable, provided its implementation strikes an appropriate balance between maintaining orderly trading and allowing prices to adjust efficiently to market developments," he said.

He added that a uniform threshold could give investors greater clarity and predictability while reducing their exposure to abrupt price movements caused by erroneous orders or temporary market dislocations.

Investment & Capital Corp. of the Philippines President and Chief Operating Officer Jesus Mariano P. Ocampo likewise supported standardizing the threshold.

"In all practical terms — moving the threshold down to 10% is probably not an issue," he said in a Viber message. "Better to keep the threshold uniform regardless of trading activity."

Under existing rules, securities traded 20 times or fewer over the preceding six months carry a 20% dynamic threshold. Those traded more than 20 times but no more than 500 times have a 15% threshold, while those traded more than 500 times have a 10% threshold. The dynamic threshold governs allowable price changes between successive trades, rather than a security's total price movement during a trading day.

"It should be easier for market participants and the PSE also as there is only one threshold to look at instead of the existing three and conditions under which the limits apply," Mr. Ocampo said.

In a consultation paper dated Nov. 12, the PSE said standardization would simplify execution for the exchange and market participants. It would also eliminate semiannual reviews of threshold classifications and reclassifications between review periods.

The proposed threshold would not apply to block sales, negotiated trades, and cross transactions. The PSE said negotiated trades must be priced within 5% above or below the reference price, while cross transactions must fall within the best bid and best offer prices.

The exchange also cited regional practices in proposing the change, including the Singapore Exchange's uniform 10% dynamic limit. While some Southeast Asian exchanges no longer implement dynamic thresholds, the PSE said it proposed retaining the safeguard as a "speed bump" against erroneous orders and sudden intraday price movements.

Mr. Arce said the proposal should be viewed as a reform of the trading framework rather than a solution to the Philippine stock market's broader liquidity challenges.

"Ultimately, deeper market participation, stronger investor confidence and more attractive investment opportunities will have a much greater influence on trading activity," he said. "The objective should be to strengthen investor protection without unnecessarily constraining legitimate trading or efficient price discovery."

The PSE is accepting comments on the proposed amendments until Nov. 19. For market participants, that deadline is the near-term checkpoint, while the exchange's implementing guidelines for accepting or rejecting breaching orders will help determine how often the 10% limit interrupts trading in practice.

— Alexandria Grace C. Magno, BusinessWorld

Source: BusinessWorld