NewsMacroPhilippines Missed Chance to Shape South China Sea Code of Conduct, Security Analyst Says

Philippines Missed Chance to Shape South China Sea Code of Conduct, Security Analyst Says

Author: BworldonlineĀ·

Key Takeaways

  • •The ASEAN Summit concluded with negotiations on the South China Sea Code of Conduct still unfinished as the Philippines' one-year chairmanship ends and Singapore prepares to take over.
  • •Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa P. Lazaro said the Code of Conduct will not be signed by yearend, with the next round of talks to occur under Singapore's chairmanship in 2027.
  • •The CoC had reached 80% completion, according to the foreign affairs secretary.
  • •Analyst Chester B. Cabalza said the Philippines missed its window to push its priorities on the Code while leading ASEAN, though he argued the stalled finalization is not a failure of regional diplomacy.
  • •First pledged in 2002 under a nonbinding declaration, the Code of Conduct has been negotiated for more than two decades to manage disputes in waters that carry trillions of dollars in annual trade.
Philippines Missed Chance to Shape South China Sea Code of Conduct, Security Analyst Says

The Philippines forfeited a "golden opportunity" to advance its priorities in the long-running negotiations over the proposed Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)-China Code of Conduct (CoC) in the South China Sea while it led the regional bloc, a maritime security analyst said.

The ASEAN Summit concluded this week with the Code of Conduct negotiations still unfinished, ahead of Singapore's assumption of the regional chairmanship next year. The bloc's top post rotates annually among its member states, giving each chair a one-year window to set the group's agenda and priorities.

"Despite the lapse, finalization of the CoC is not a failure of regional diplomacy," said Chester B. Cabalza, founder and president of International Development and Security Cooperation, in remarks relayed via Facebook Messenger.

According to Mr. Cabalza, Singapore's agenda as incoming ASEAN chairman offers no certainty of progress on maritime security in the disputed waterway. "Singapore may or may not prioritize this next year as ASEAN host, but it is not a guarantee that maritime security will be resolved," he said.

He argued that Singapore could instead build on the Philippines' initiatives on climate justice and environmental protection in the high seas, which he described as more attainable areas of regional cooperation. "What Singapore will carry over as the next chairman is how the Philippines put in place climate justice and environmental protection in the high seas," Mr. Cabalza said. "These are low-hanging fruits that redound to ASEAN's needs."

With its chairmanship drawing to a close, the Philippines no longer holds the same opportunity to influence the direction of the CoC negotiations, having missed its window to push its priorities while leading the bloc, he added.

The Code of Conduct in the South China Sea will not be signed by yearend, Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa P. Lazaro said on Sunday. Speaking at a press briefing, Ms. Lazaro said the next round of talks on the sea code would take place when Singapore assumes the chairmanship of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations in 2027. On Saturday, she said the CoC had reached 80% completion.

First pledged in 2002 under the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, a nonbinding accord signed by China and ASEAN's members at the time, the CoC has been under negotiation for more than two decades and is intended to manage disputes in the strategically critical waters, which serve as a corridor for trillions of dollars in annual trade. The proposed agreement seeks to establish rules governing activities in the South China Sea, where overlapping maritime claims have fueled tensions between China and several Southeast Asian countries.

Mr. Cabalza cautioned against treating the code as the definitive answer to the region's maritime disputes. "The CoC is not the be-all and end-all, but it should be a model for maritime security in one of the most contested waterways in the world," he said. The agreement, he added, should function as a framework for maritime security in the region rather than simply an endpoint in ASEAN-China diplomatic negotiations.

— Pexcel John Bacon

Source: BusinessWorld