NewsCryptoNic Carter Says Most Bitcoin Treasury Firms Offer Little Beyond ETFs

Nic Carter Says Most Bitcoin Treasury Firms Offer Little Beyond ETFs

Author: Tron Weekly·

Key Takeaways

  • •Castle Island Ventures partner Nic Carter said in an October 27, 2026 interview that most Bitcoin treasury companies offer minimal benefit compared with spot Bitcoin ETFs for investors seeking exposure.
  • •The digital asset treasury model, popularized by Strategy, raises funds through stock issuances and borrowings to buy Bitcoin, and Carter argued the overwhelming majority of such firms lack distinctive offerings, though a minority have interesting models.
  • •Stacks co-founder Muneeb Ali revealed that Bullish and other institutions subscribed to Stacks' third Bitcoin bond, a 1,000 BTC-capacity product enabling institutions to earn yield in Bitcoin on their balance sheets, with monthly capacity additions and an STX token-holding requirement for access.
  • •Bitcoin Treasury Corporation bought and cancelled 99,500 common shares in October at an average cost of $3.91 per share, and its Bitcoin Per Share rose 1.42% year-to-date to 0.00006435 BTC even as total holdings declined.
  • •As of October 31, Bitcoin Treasury Corporation held 732.47 BTC against 11,383,313 diluted shares, and revenue from its Bitcoin lending operations and Price Risk Management Program is expected to fund future buybacks.
Nic Carter Says Most Bitcoin Treasury Firms Offer Little Beyond ETFs

Castle Island Ventures partner Nic Carter has criticized the business models of most Bitcoin treasury companies, arguing that they deliver limited benefits beyond the Bitcoin exposure investors can already obtain through exchange-traded funds (ETFs). His remarks underscore mounting pressure on digital asset treasury (DAT) firms to develop genuinely distinct strategies and deliver additional shareholder value, particularly as spot ETFs now give investors a direct alternative.

ETFs Set a High Bar for Treasury Companies

Carter voiced his opinion in an interview conducted by Natalie Brunell on October 27, 2026. According to him, investors interested in obtaining exposure to Bitcoin via the securities route can achieve this simply by investing in a spot Bitcoin ETF. These products provide direct exposure to Bitcoin without requiring investors to buy into a firm that holds Bitcoin in its treasury. In practical terms, that makes a passive fund holding Bitcoin the benchmark against which any actively run treasury stock now has to justify itself.

JUST IN: 🚨 Bitcoin treasury firms offer little value beyond standard ETFs, says crypto expert Nic Carter. He argues investors seeking efficient exposure should stick to spot ETFs instead of DATs. $BTC #Bitcoin #Crypto
— inside predict (@popmemecoin) November 15, 2026

Firms that hold digital assets in their treasuries are commonly known as DATs. The model, popularized by Strategy (formerly MicroStrategy), involves acquiring funds via stock issuances, borrowings, and other financing methods, then using the proceeds to invest in Bitcoin. The sector has expanded quickly in recent years, and Carter's assessment suggests many listed firms now offer closely similar propositions. Shares of these companies make it possible for investors to indirectly own cryptocurrencies through the stock exchange.

Carter, however, believes there is very little innovation on the Bitcoin treasury side. While admitting that some firms have come up with interesting models, he argues that the overwhelming majority have nothing special to offer in contrast to other investment instruments.

Stacks Bitcoin Bond Attracts Institutional Participation

Some companies holding Bitcoin have been seeking ways of earning more money through their holdings. In an interview featured on The Wolf Of All Streets, Stacks co-founder Muneeb Ali revealed that Bullish and others had subscribed to the company's third Bitcoin bond, which has a capacity of 1,000 BTC.

According to Ali, the product makes it possible for institutions to earn yield in the form of Bitcoin directly on their balance sheets. He also confirmed that Stacks adds more capacity each month, adding that the third Bitcoin bond is the largest the company has offered so far. The arrangement illustrates the efforts being made by companies to generate income beyond capital gains.

There is a condition attached: participating institutions need to hold some STX tokens in order to use the product. Ali referred to STX as an “access asset” and likened participating in the product to having limited tickets for attending a certain event. Structuring access this way ties demand for the bond to the token itself — an example of the kind of differentiated design that separates the minority of firms Carter acknowledges from the majority he criticizes.

Bitcoin Treasury Corporation Shows a Different Approach

Bitcoin Treasury Corporation is one of the companies pursuing methods of creating value for shareholders apart from just acquiring Bitcoin. As revealed in an announcement dated November 4, 2026, the Canadian firm bought and cancelled 99,500 common shares in October, doing so at an average cost of $3.91 per share.

The company additionally disclosed that its Bitcoin Per Share (BPS) had risen by 1.42% year-to-date to 0.00006435 BTC. These statistics reveal how share buybacks can influence the quantity of Bitcoin backing each diluted share: repurchasing and cancelling stock reduces the share count, so the Bitcoin attributable to each remaining share can climb even when reserves do not grow.

As of October 31, Bitcoin Treasury Corporation was holding 732.47 BTC, while its share dilution was recorded at 11,383,313. The firm indicated that its total Bitcoin holdings had declined during the year notwithstanding the rise in BPS — a dynamic that explains why both reserve and share figures need to be examined together.

It is also worth noting that the company's Bitcoin lending operations and its Bitcoin Price Risk Management Program are considered part of its operating strategy. Revenue generated through these programs is expected to fund future share repurchases. This represents an instance of a treasury company building financial services on top of its Bitcoin reserves — the kind of operational differentiation Carter says most of the sector currently lacks.

Treasury Companies Face Pressure to Prove Value

Carter's critique emerges as investor focus turns increasingly toward comparing corporate approaches to Bitcoin with existing alternative investment vehicles. With ETFs readily available for Bitcoin investments, treasury companies face the task of proving why their stocks should be considered at all.

The sustainability of operations based on crypto reserves is one factor likely to shape the industry's future. New business opportunities, including Bitcoin lending, financial services, and capital management, may emerge, although these would also bring new challenges for investors. That, in turn, raises the bar for transparency around reserves, share counts, and per-share metrics. Figures like Stacks' monthly capacity additions and Bitcoin Treasury Corporation's disclosed buybacks and BPS give investors concrete data points for making those comparisons.

Carter's comments thus reveal a change in the market's approach toward Bitcoin treasury companies. Holding Bitcoin might not suffice to keep investors interested in light of easier alternatives such as ETFs. The companies that succeed in establishing real operations, managing capital effectively, and providing high shareholder value will have the greatest chance of distinguishing themselves in the market.