New Jersey Asks U.S. Supreme Court to Settle Prediction Markets Regulatory Fight
Key Takeaways
- •New Jersey petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn a Third Circuit ruling that federal commodities law preempts its gambling rules for Kalshi's sports event contracts.
- •A circuit split emerged after the Ninth Circuit held that the Commodity Exchange Act likely does not preempt Nevada's regulation of sports-related event contracts.
- •Kalshi argues the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction and says it cannot operate under 50 separate state regulatory systems.
- •Forty-four state attorneys general contend that sports event contracts amount to sports betting and should remain under state oversight.
- •Shares of DraftKings and Flutter Entertainment rose more than 5% after New Jersey filed its petition.

New Jersey has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to resolve a growing legal battle over prediction markets and sports-related event contracts. The state is asking the justices to decide whether federal commodities law prevents states from applying their own gambling rules to these platforms.
The petition comes amid conflicting federal appeals court rulings that have created uncertainty over which level of government should regulate prediction markets. New Jersey argues that states should retain authority over sports betting within their borders, while Kalshi contends that federal law gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) exclusive control.
The stakes extend beyond a single company. Prediction markets such as Kalshi, which is registered with the CFTC as a designated contract market, have expanded rapidly into sports outcomes, elections, and other real-world events, drawing millions of dollars in trading volume. State gambling regulators say that activity looks like sports betting, which since a 2018 Supreme Court decision striking down the federal ban has been licensed and taxed state by state — a framework that could be undermined if federal exchanges can offer sports contracts nationwide without state approval.
New Jersey Challenges Third Circuit Ruling
New Jersey's petition asks the Supreme Court to review an April decision from the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. That court ruled that Kalshi's event contracts fall under the Commodity Exchange Act and that federal law preempts New Jersey's gambling rules. The state's filing is available here.
Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said prediction market firms should not be able to avoid state sports-betting laws simply by operating on a CFTC-registered exchange. New Jersey's petition argues that Congress did not remove state authority over sports wagering when it passed the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010.
The legal dispute widened after the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reached a different conclusion last week. That court said the Commodity Exchange Act likely does not preempt Nevada's rules covering sports-related event contracts.
The Ninth Circuit also rejected requests from Kalshi and Crypto.com for relief against the Nevada Gaming Control Board. Its ruling conflicts with the Third Circuit decision, creating a split between federal appeals courts over how sports contracts should be classified and regulated. A circuit split is one of the main factors that typically prompts the Supreme Court to take up a case, which is why conflicting rulings from lower courts have heightened attention on the issue.
Supreme Court Review Remains Uncertain
Kalshi said it disagrees with New Jersey's filing and continues to view itself as a nationwide financial exchange. Company spokeswoman Dani Lever said the platform cannot operate under 50 separate regulatory systems and argued that the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction.
A Supreme Court review is not guaranteed. The justices receive many petitions each term and may choose to wait for additional lower courts to rule. Bank of America said the court could delay action until next year because other federal cases remain pending.
The dispute has also drawn support from many state officials. Forty-four state attorneys general say sports event contracts amount to sports betting and should remain under state oversight.
The CFTC itself has moved to tighten oversight of event contracts, proposing rules that would restrict certain sports-related listings, so the outcome of the litigation could shape not only state-federal boundaries but also how the federal regulator itself treats these markets going forward.
Shares of DraftKings and Flutter Entertainment, FanDuel's parent company, rose more than 5% in Tuesday trading after New Jersey filed its petition.