Megyn Kelly mocked after doubling down on debunked James Talarico mental health claim
Key Takeaways
- •The Lindner Center of Hope first cited HIPAA privacy rules, then issued a second statement on Sunday evening clarifying that James Talarico had never been a patient at the Ohio facility.
- •The 45-second audio clip circulated by commentator Nick Sortor was authentic but edited to exclude the employee's statement that Talarico was never at the facility, even though the full recording contained that denial.
- •The Bulwark obtained the complete six-minute call, which was made by Amacher rather than Sortor, and it showed Amacher used a series of lies to try to obtain private information while the employee repeatedly denied anyone named James Talarico was in her system.
- •Megyn Kelly publicly asked the Lindner Center on X to clarify whether Talarico had visited in the previous nine days, even after facility had denied he was ever a patient.
- •Talarico reposted the facility's denial and stated that he had never been to Ohio, while several journalists and commentators ridiculed Kelly's continued questioning.

Former Fox News host Megyn Kelly is struggling to accept that the conspiracy theories surrounding Texas State Representative James Talarico were false, and journalists are not letting her doubling down go unanswered.
After a week saturated with conspiracy theories, a right-wing personality posted an audio recording that he claimed came from a woman working at a mental health facility in Ohio and confirmed that Talarico had been a patient there. The facility, the Lindner Center of Hope, released a statement on Sunday afternoon telling journalists that it would never reveal any patient's name because doing so would violate HIPAA, the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, which protects the privacy of patients' health information.
That initial statement addressed the facility's privacy obligations rather than the claim itself. By Sunday evening, the center sent out a second statement making it clear that Talarico had never been a patient there. Talarico, for his part, reposted the statement, saying that he had never even been to Ohio.
Kelly pressed the facility for clarification.
"Could you pls clarify @LindnerCtrHope: 1. Has James Talarico been to your facility at all at any point in the last 9 days? 2. Was the facility operator who said he had been there mistaken? Will you allow her to speak publicly?" she asked on X.
The recording circulated by political commentator Nick Sortor was authentic, but it did not contain all of the information.
The Bulwark obtained the full six-minute recording, in which the woman on the phone makes it clear that Talarico was never at the facility. Sortor left that portion out of his audio edit, meaning he knew Talarico was not at the facility but broadcast the claim anyway.
"Sortor hadn't actually made the call. That was Amacher, who had also cut his teeth filming the Portland ICE protests. Amacher had posted call logs that indicated his actual conversation with (allegedly) the person at Lindner lasted roughly six minutes. So, we asked him for the full recording (not the 45-second clip Sortor had posted). And, thankfully, he sent it along."
"It turns out, that the 45-second portion came at the very end of the actual call. What came before was a series of lies Amacher told to trick the apparent Lindner employee into handing over private information. It also included the employee's repeated denials that anyone named 'James Talarico' was in her system at all," the report said.
The mockery followed swiftly. Semafor editor-in-chief Ben Smith noted, "What a crazy information environment."
"No wonder she got fired from NBC. Totally conspiracy-pilled," commented political analyst and strategist Neera Tanden.
"What stage of grief is this?" asked ZenithPolls founding partner Adam Carlson.
"You've really lost the plot buddy," former Republican Sarah Longwell shot back at Kelly.
Huffington Post reporter SV Dáte commented to Kelly, "Trump acts like a complete lunatic every single day, if suddenly we're that concerned with mental health."
NewsNation's Chris Cuomo got in on the mockery too, writing, "Next target."
Patrick Pfingsten, who writes for The Illinoize and hosts in the afternoon on WMAY News, noted, "'Never' seems as if it would cover the last 9 days."