Lawyers Say Journalist Subpoenaed in Leak Probe Was Targeted for His Kushner Reporting
Key Takeaways
- •The Justice Department subpoenaed freelance journalist Matthew Cole in February to testify about two years' worth of his contacts and conversations as part of a leak investigation into a 2025 article about a failed 2019 Navy SEALs operation in North Korea.
- •Cole's attorneys argued at a Tuesday hearing in Newport News, Virginia, that the subpoena is retaliation for his reporting on Jared Kushner and are seeking to quash it on First Amendment grounds.
- •The government is separately pressing LinkedIn to turn over records about sources Cole contacted through the platform, opening a parallel legal front that targets third-party data rather than the reporter's own notes.
- •Cole's Kushner exposé, 'Princes and Thieves,' debuted at No. 3 on the New York Times nonfiction bestseller list just days before federal prosecutors disclosed details of the request to him.
- •The dispute unfolds amid a broader second-term campaign against the press in which judges have consistently rejected administration efforts to obtain journalists' sources, and upcoming rulings will help define the limits of the investigation's reach.

Attorneys for a freelance journalist subpoenaed by the federal government argued in court on Tuesday that their client is being targeted for his reporting on Jared Kushner, the son-in-law of President Donald Trump — not for any leak under investigation.
The Department of Justice is demanding that journalist Matthew Cole hand over information about sources he contacted through LinkedIn, saying it wants to stem military leaks. Because the demand targets records held by a third-party platform rather than a reporter's notes or personal accounts, it raises distinct questions about how far a grand jury can reach into a journalist's source network. Cole's lawyers contend the subpoena is, in reality, an act of retaliation.
Politico senior political affairs correspondent Josh Gerstein flagged the defense in a post on X: "Just in. After 2 hours 40 minutes, [the] hearing in Newport News, VA on [a] grand jury subpoena to NYT freelancer Matthew Cole about story on failed special operation in N. Korea is over. Looks like Cole atty may have argued that Cole's being targeted due to reporting on Kushner."
According to the New York Times, the Trump administration is trying to force LinkedIn to turn over data about reporters as part of a leak investigation into a 2025 article describing a failed top-secret mission in North Korea — a botched 2019 operation by Navy SEALs to which Cole contributed. Last week, federal prosecutors disclosed details of the request to Cole. The setup puts the dispute on two tracks at once — the reporter's compelled testimony on one side, the platform's records on the other — each of which the courts will have to resolve on its own.
"The court filing confirms that the Trump administration has sought on two parallel fronts to identify the sources for the article as part of one overarching investigation," the Times reported. "The administration subpoenaed Mr. Cole in February to testify about two years' worth of information about his contacts and conversations. Lawyers for Mr. Cole have been trying to quash the subpoena as an impermissible intrusion on the First Amendment."
Cole's attorneys have suggested in earlier proceedings that the White House may have another motivation for pursuing the journalist. Mere days before the DOJ made its disclosures to Cole, his exposé on Kushner — Princes and Thieves — debuted at No. 3 on the New York Times nonfiction bestseller list. At a hearing in June, they argued that the subpoena was "tainted by retaliatory animus," noting that Cole had been working on the book for some time.
The clash comes amid a broader second-term campaign against the press that has delivered uneven results for Trump. His administration has repeatedly sought journalists' sources, but judges have consistently rejected those efforts. The president has also used lawsuits — or the threat of them — to intimidate media outlets, and his officials have threatened to pull the licenses of broadcasters that draw the administration's ire. In September, Trump moved to ban several media outlets from the White House, only to be slapped down in court.
Against that backdrop, the Cole case offers a concrete test of where those limits lie. The immediate watch items are procedural: a ruling on Cole's motion to quash after Tuesday's arguments, and how the court handles the parallel demand on LinkedIn. Either will help define whether this investigation can keep pressing into a journalist's source network — and whether the retaliation claim gets a fuller airing.