Mankun Blockchain Legal Says Bitcoin's Four-Year Cycle Has Ended
Key Takeaways
- •Mankun Blockchain Legal Services stated in commentary published on November 16, 2026, that Bitcoin's four-year market cycle has ended and that the token-issuance fundraising model behind crypto's earliest fortunes no longer works.
- •The four-year cycle is tied to Bitcoin's halving schedule, which cuts mining rewards in half every 210,000 blocks, with halvings occurring in 2012, 2016, 2020, and April 2024, when the reward fell from 6.25 to 3.125 bitcoin per block.
- •The ICO boom of 2017–2018 saw projects raise billions of dollars by selling newly created tokens to the public ahead of exchange listings, drawing regulatory scrutiny including U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission enforcement actions against unregistered offerings.
- •Because blockchain law firms sit at the intersection of token projects, investors, and regulators, their interpretation of fundraising norms can inform how new ventures structure capital raises and how established players manage compliance around token holdings.
- •The debate's outcome may become visible in whether Bitcoin's behavior after the April 2024 halving tracks or breaks from prior halving-linked swings, and in whether new projects adopt funding structures that avoid token issuance as legal interpretations evolve.

Mankun Blockchain Legal Services, a law firm specializing in blockchain-related legal matters, says the four-year cycle that has long framed Bitcoin's market history has ended, and that the fundraising model which built crypto's first fortunes no longer works.
The firm set out its position in commentary published on Monday, November 16, 2026. Its argument targets the approach that dominated earlier eras of the industry: raising money by issuing tokens, cashing out through exchange listings, and waiting for the next wave of buyers to arrive. In the firm's view, that model has run its course.
The assessment carries weight beyond its market implications. Firms focused on blockchain law sit at the intersection of token projects, investors, and regulators, and their reading of fundraising norms can inform how new ventures structure capital raises and how established players manage compliance around token holdings.
The four-year cycle takes its name from Bitcoin's halving schedule. The Bitcoin protocol automatically cuts the reward for mining new blocks in half every 210,000 blocks, an event that has historically occurred roughly once every four years, with halvings taking place in 2012, 2016, 2020 and most recently April 2024, when the mining reward fell from 6.25 to 3.125 bitcoin per block. Market observers have frequently linked these halvings to alternating stretches of rally and downturn, although the reliability of the pattern as a forecasting tool remains a matter of debate among analysts.
Token issuance, for its part, rose to prominence during the 2017–2018 initial coin offering boom, when projects raised billions of dollars by selling newly created tokens to the public, typically followed by listings on major exchanges. That boom drew scrutiny from regulators in multiple jurisdictions, with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission among those pursuing enforcement actions against unregistered token offerings, and the issuance-and-listing playbook has since remained a central feature of the industry's fundraising landscape despite the added legal constraints.
How the debate resolves is likely to become visible in observable developments: whether Bitcoin's behavior after the April 2024 halving tracks or breaks from the timing of prior halving-linked swings, and whether new projects turn to funding structures that sidestep token issuance as legal interpretations of the model evolve. The firm's comments also add a legal-industry voice to an argument that has so far been carried mainly by market analysts, and responses from other participants in both fields will shape whether the view gains traction.
The firm's full commentary was first published by COINOTAG on November 16, 2026, and is available at: https://en.coinotag.com/mankun-says-bitcoin-four-year-cycle-has-ended