NewsMacroMAGA Women Are Trapped in a Paradox That Leaves Them 'Doomed to Fail,' New Analysis Finds

MAGA Women Are Trapped in a Paradox That Leaves Them 'Doomed to Fail,' New Analysis Finds

Author: AlternetĀ·

Key Takeaways

  • •Representative Lauren Boebert lost her midterm reelection bid to Eileen Laubacher, a Democrat and retired Naval officer, in a district that had been considered safely Republican.
  • •According to the analysis, Boebert relocated to a more favorable Colorado district in 2024 following personal controversies, including her 2023 divorce and an ejection from a 'Beetlejuice' screening, but the move did not preserve her seat in the 2026 election.
  • •The MS NOW analysis links Boebert's defeat to a broader pattern, citing Kristi Noem's firing amid denied affair rumors, Nancy Mace's failed gubernatorial bid and upcoming departure from Congress, Karoline Leavitt leaving her podium in August, and Katie Zacharia's brief tenure as White House press secretary.
  • •Author Amanda Marcotte argues that figures like Boebert gained fame and power by conforming to extreme beauty standards and projecting a contradictory feminine image rather than establishing a new model for conservative women.
  • •The analysis concludes that prominent women in Trump's movement were pushed out of power over the past year either by voters or by male GOP leaders seeking convenient scapegoats.
MAGA Women Are Trapped in a Paradox That Leaves Them 'Doomed to Fail,' New Analysis Finds

Rep. Lauren Boebert's failed reelection bid in the midterms capped off a "grim year for MAGA women," according to a new analysis published by MS NOW, which argues that prominent women in President Donald Trump's movement are receiving little in return for the paradox in which they are trapped.

Writing for the outlet on Saturday morning, prolific commentator and journalist Amanda Marcotte broke down how Boebert attempted to sell male conservatives a "contradictory" vision of femininity.

"She titillated the right and annoyed the left with her over-the-top performance of a MAGA man's contradictory fantasy of a woman who is both sexually liberated and a demure wife and mother," Marcotte explained. "Boebert was the forerunner to a type that has become ubiquitous in the Trump era: Republican women who gain fame and power by submitting to extreme beauty standards, while still insisting that they are good and pious ladies. Observers dubbed their combination of heavy makeup and rumored plastic surgery 'Mar-a-Lago face.'"

Marcotte argued that Boebert's reelection loss to Eileen Laubacher, a Democrat and retired Naval officer, in a supposedly safe red district showed why her particular "version of MAGA womanhood was always doomed to fail: The facade did not last long."

"It quickly became evident that hers was a turbulent marriage, and she ended it in 2023," she wrote. "Later that year, she was ejected from a showing of the musical 'Beetlejuice,' and camera footage showed her and her date apparently groping each other in front of other theatergoers. Facing a possible loss in her more swingy Colorado district, she relocated to a district nearby, winning a safe Republican seat in 2024. In the 2026 blue wave, though, even that wasn't enough to save her seat."

According to Marcotte, Boebert's defeat capped off a year in which women of this type were pushed out of power, "either by voters or by male GOP leaders who needed handy scapegoats."

Among those she cited was Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, who "proclaimed the health of her 34-year marriage to Bryon Noem, until rumors of an affair with her aide Corey Lewandowski helped lead Trump to fire her" — although both Noem and Lewandowski denied having an affair. Rep. Nancy Mace will leave Congress in January after a failed bid to become her state's governor. Karoline Leavitt "gave up her podium in August." And Katie Zacharia "lasted only a few days this year as White House press secretary, despite being showily Christian and sporting a standard Mar-a-Lago face."

Marcotte concluded that, rather than establishing a new paradigm for conservative women, figures like Boebert "created an impossible and oppressive standard for" them, in which they are "expected to fulfill male fantasies without having even basic reproductive rights, much less freedom of their own."