NewsMacroRetired Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling Says Jared Kushner Echoed Russian Propaganda in Ukraine Peace Talks

Retired Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling Says Jared Kushner Echoed Russian Propaganda in Ukraine Peace Talks

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Retired Lieutenant General Mark Hertling warned that Jared Kushner's account of the Ukraine peace diplomacy, despite sounding reasonable, repeats long-standing Kremlin talking points.
  • •In early November, Kushner described productive discussions in Brussels with Ukrainian, NATO, and European representatives and outlined five objectives emphasizing all parties' security concerns.
  • •Russia has repeatedly demanded that NATO revert to its 1997 posture, which would reverse decades of alliance enlargement and limit forces defending newer member states.
  • •Many newer NATO members joined the alliance because of their historical experiences with the Soviet Union and ongoing concerns about Russia as a neighbor.
  • •Former Ambassador Michael McFaul criticized Trump's 2018 consideration at the Helsinki Summit of handing a British whistleblower and former U.S. diplomat to Putin based on misinformation.
Retired Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling Says Jared Kushner Echoed Russian Propaganda in Ukraine Peace Talks

A retired senior U.S. military officer is warning that Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump’s son-in-law and emissary, is echoing misinformation favorable to Russian President Vladimir Putin as Washington attempts to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine.

Writing for The Bulwark on Tuesday, retired Lieutenant General Mark Hertling argued that Kushner’s account of the diplomacy may sound reasonable at first, but repeats long-standing Kremlin talking points.

“Washington is attempting to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine,” Hertling wrote. “In early November, about the same time as the bomb threats began across the continent, Trump emissary and son-in-law Jared Kushner described productive discussions in Brussels with Ukrainian, NATO, and European representatives. He outlined five objectives, which may at first sound reasonable because of the emphasis on all parties’ security concerns.”

“There was just one problem: Kushner’s comments echoed the recurring Russian claim that Moscow’s security requires changes to Europe’s existing defense arrangements,” he added.

Hertling grounded his critique in Russia’s repeated demands on the alliance. “Russia has repeatedly demanded that NATO return to its 1997 posture, effectively reversing decades of alliance enlargement and limiting the military presence available to defend newer members,” he wrote. “Many of those nations sought NATO membership precisely because of their past experiences with the Soviet Union and their concerns about their future with Russia as a neighbor.”

As the negotiations continue, that collision — Moscow’s demand to return NATO to its 1997 posture against the military presence newer members rely on for their defense — is the thread to watch in how the terms of any settlement take shape.

More broadly, foreign policy analysts have expressed alarm throughout Trump’s two terms over his seemingly unusual receptiveness toward, and sympathy for, Russia’s foreign policy views. In 2018, at the Helsinki Summit, Trump considered handing a British whistleblower and former U.S. diplomat over to Putin based on misinformation. Former Ambassador Michael McFaul, speaking to Salon at the time, expressed consternation at Trump’s behavior.

“I was deeply disappointed,” McFaul said. “The generous interpretation is that Trump didn’t understand what he was talking about. But let’s be clear, what Trump was doing was assigning moral equivalency to a legitimate indictment with lots of evidence against several Russian military intelligence officers for violating American sovereignty in 2016 during the presidential elections with a completely fabricated cockamamie story invented by Putin. To even for a moment give any kind of dignity to what President Putin proposed was not in America’s national interest from my point of view.”

Hertling has also previously voiced a dim view of Hegseth. In October, he denounced those responsible for damaging a globe once owned by President Dwight Eisenhower while it was being moved to Hegseth’s office, as reported by Alternet.

“I can probably bet that the guys who were told to go move it were a couple of lieutenant colonels in Hegseth’s outer office who are doing nothing but posting trash on X all day long and attacking people,” Hertling said. “I bet it’s the same guy. I’m going to see if Kalshi would take me up on that bet.”