NewsMacroNobel Economist Paul Krugman Rebuts Trump's Biden Blame for Record FAA Flight Grounding

Nobel Economist Paul Krugman Rebuts Trump's Biden Blame for Record FAA Flight Grounding

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •The FAA grounded all U.S. departures for nearly five hours on Nov. 13, disrupting about 12,000 flights and driving more than 6,400 cancellations on Saturday plus roughly 1,500 more on Sunday.
  • •President Trump blamed the Biden administration in a Truth Social post and called on Congress to provide additional air traffic control funding.
  • •Paul Krugman argued that Trump and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy are responsible, pointing to Trump's executive order pausing spending under the 2021 law that included $25 billion for the FAA and to Duffy's rapid modernization push made without consulting air traffic workers.
  • •Roughly two months before the outage, the Government Accountability Office warned that the FAA's accelerated modernization effort could prioritize speed over costs and air traffic disruptions, noting the agency lacked a lifecycle cost estimate and master schedule.
  • •Federal officials traced the outage to an L3Harris-installed router in El Dorado, Arkansas, and another device in Amarillo, Texas, though the precise cause remains under investigation and the manufacturer said its device functioned properly.
Nobel Economist Paul Krugman Rebuts Trump's Biden Blame for Record FAA Flight Grounding

President Donald Trump has blamed former President Joe Biden for the air travel disruption that unfolded on Friday, but Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman rejected that account, placing responsibility on Trump and his own Transportation Secretary.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) temporarily grounded all departures nationwide for nearly five hours on Nov. 13. CNBC reported it was the largest grounding of U.S. flights since 9/11. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said the grounding cost 12,000 flights, and FlightAware recorded more than 6,400 cancellations on Saturday alone. Airlines canceled approximately another 1,500 flights on Sunday as the system sputtered back to life.

On Sunday, Trump posted on Truth Social: "The Biden Administration was an FAA disaster. Everything they touched turned bad." He also called on Congress to provide additional funding for air traffic control.

Krugman, who was stranded in Chicago and made it home a day late, disputed that framing. In a Substack post titled "Republican Ideology Ruined Your Weekend", he wrote, "It wasn't weather, it wasn't a terrorist attack, it was simple incompetence."

Krugman's assessment stands in contrast to Trump's claim. In 2021, Biden signed the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, which included $25 billion for the FAA. Shortly after taking office, Trump signed an executive order to pause spending under the law. Krugman writes that Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has been pushing a rapid transformation of the air traffic control system without heeding warnings and without consulting air traffic workers. It is on that sequence of spending decisions that Krugman's rebuttal largely rests.

Some two months before the outage, the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office warned that the FAA's accelerated effort to modernize its air traffic control system, which began in May 2025, "could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions." The watchdog found that the FAA did not have a lifecycle cost estimate or a master schedule.

Krugman also points out that in 2019, while Duffy was a congressman from Wisconsin, he voted against a bill that would have provided funding for the FAA. Following Friday's outage, Krugman writes, Duffy held a press conference in which he blamed Democrats and praised Trump.

Krugman links the failure to a decades-long Republican distaste for government, starting with Ronald Reagan, which he argues resulted in insufficient investment in public services and reliance on antiquated technology. The FAA, for example, does not plan to stop using floppy disks until 2028. Krugman also cites the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which he says eliminated or drove out some 13 percent of the federal workforce in a matter of months without consulting experts.

The precise cause of Friday's outage is still under investigation, but federal officials say they traced it to a router that contractor L3Harris installed at a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas, and another device in Amarillo, Texas. The router's manufacturer said that, based on the information it has, the device functioned as it should.

Krugman said he has no particular reason to disbelieve the official explanation. But he argued the larger problem was predictable, describing an administration focused on moving fast and breaking things as having finally broken air travel. Whether the investigation ultimately sharpens or complicates that account remains to be seen, as does any congressional action on Trump's call for additional air traffic control funding.