NewsCryptoKalshi Seeks Federal Court Protection From New York's $36 Billion Gambling Lawsuit

Kalshi Seeks Federal Court Protection From New York's $36 Billion Gambling Lawsuit

Author: CryptoMeter io·

Key Takeaways

  • •Kalshi warned a federal court that New York's proposed restraining order could shut down its entire prediction-market exchange because the company operates from within the state.
  • •New York Attorney General Letitia James alleges Kalshi runs an unlicensed gambling business through event contracts covering sports, elections, and other events, and the state is seeking at least $36 billion in restitution, profit forfeiture, and penalties.
  • •Kalshi argues its federal registration places it under the exclusive authority of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which invoked emergency authority on August 11 to direct the exchange to keep operating.
  • •A November 10 ruling noted the Second Circuit denied injunctions pending appeal in consolidated Kalshi and Coinbase cases, a procedural setback that did not resolve the underlying appeals or establish liability.
  • •The dispute tests the scope of Kalshi's federal exchange registration against New York's interests in gambling licensing, taxes, and consumer safeguards, with the immediate question being whether the court grants the requested restraining order and injunction.
Kalshi Seeks Federal Court Protection From New York's $36 Billion Gambling Lawsuit

Kalshi has asked a federal court to protect it from New York's proposed trading restrictions, warning that the measures could shut down its prediction-market exchange nationwide. The dispute stems from a July 31 lawsuit seeking at least $36 billion and turns on whether federal derivatives oversight shields event contracts, which let traders take positions on the outcomes of real-world events, from state gambling laws.

New York Attorney General Letitia James alleges that Kalshi operates an unlicensed gambling business through contracts covering sports, elections, and other events. The state is seeking restitution, forfeiture of profits, and financial penalties. Kalshi counters that its federal registration places the exchange under the exclusive authority of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the federal agency that oversees U.S. derivatives markets.

Why the restrictions could reach nationwide

The proposed restraining order targets operations conducted within or from New York, along with transactions involving New York customers. Because Kalshi operates from within the state, the company warned that the language could halt its entire exchange. Its objection therefore extends beyond blocking access for residents of a single state.

Kalshi also told the CFTC that the requested relief could require customer refunds and the surrender of profits from completed trades. According to the regulator's account, the company warned of market disruption and potentially substantial trader losses. These statements reflect Kalshi's own assessment of the risks, rather than losses that have already occurred.

Federal backing faces judicial resistance

On August 11, the CFTC invoked emergency authority and directed Kalshi to continue operating under federal requirements. Kalshi subsequently cited that directive when seeking an injunction pending appeal. Its lawyers argued that federal instructions to keep trading would conflict with a state order forcing the exchange to stop.

Federal backing has not guaranteed courtroom protection, however. A November 10 ruling in a separate prediction-market case noted that a Second Circuit panel had denied injunctions pending appeal in consolidated Kalshi and Coinbase cases. That procedural setback did not itself resolve the underlying appeals or establish Kalshi's ultimate liability. The appearance of Coinbase alongside Kalshi in those consolidated appeals also signals that the legal questions reach beyond a single platform, forming part of a broader set of prediction-market disputes moving through the courts.

For New York, the dispute concerns gambling licenses, taxes, and consumer safeguards, including age restrictions. For Kalshi, it concerns the reach of its federal exchange registration. The immediate procedural question is whether the court grants the requested restraining order and injunction pending appeal. The $36 billion remains a demand subject to legal proceedings and accounting, rather than a court-imposed payment obligation.