NewsMacroHistorian Jon Meacham Warns Trump's 'Incompetence' Is Spooking Americans

Historian Jon Meacham Warns Trump's 'Incompetence' Is Spooking Americans

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Historian Jon Meacham said Americans' anxiety about recent government failures largely reflects incompetence visible in the Trump administration.
  • •Meacham argued Friday's events highlighted why basic government functions matter, citing the FAA's role in overseeing airspace and air traffic control.
  • •He emphasized that the need for competence is not a partisan issue and said this demand manifested itself in the midterm.
  • •Meacham suggested the ongoing turbulence may cater to Trump's 2017-stated desire to run his presidency like a reality show.
  • •Co-host Joe Scarborough invoked George Marshall and Harry Truman to argue that past leaders surrounded themselves with the most capable people, unlike the past 25 years.
Historian Jon Meacham Warns Trump's 'Incompetence' Is Spooking Americans

Pulitzer Prize-winning presidential historian Jon Meacham says the anxiety many Americans feel about recent government failures stems largely from incompetence on full display in President Donald Trump's administration.

Speaking on MS Now's "Morning Joe" on Monday, Meacham said that in times of crisis Americans want the best and the brightest in charge — and are instead getting reality TV stars.

Co-host Joe Scarborough described another 80-year-old president "who seems dangerously disconnected from the realities of what's going on," citing Trump calling affordability a "hoax" and focusing on his grand ballroom project while people cannot afford groceries and planes are being grounded.

Meacham said Friday's events underscored why basic government functions matter, pointing to the Federal Aviation Administration, the agency that oversees the nation's airspace and air traffic control. "I think what Friday reminded us of is that for all the arguments about government being too big and government overreaching, this is the kind of thing we want the government to be able to do, right?" he said. "There are certain basic functions that we have trusted the public sector to do historically, customarily. And when you get to the FAA, that's right up there, right? It's traffic lights, it's, you know, utilities. It's basic safety, food safety, vaccines."

He added that no one on an airplane cares about poll numbers. "You expect and need a basic level of competence," he said, noting that presidents throughout history have overlooked that fundamental concern of Americans.

Scarborough invoked General George Marshall — the World War II Army chief of staff who later became Truman's secretary of state and the architect of the Marshall Plan — who famously told President Harry Truman he had not voted for him. "And Truman didn't care. He kept the best and brightest around him. You look back over the past 25 years, that just hasn't been the case. It's been one disaster after another," Scarborough said, wondering whether Americans would ever reach a point where competence, experience and rationality mattered more than entertainment.

Meacham described a "flashback to those early covid days on Friday, where there was this sense, you know what I mean? You wanted — and maybe it's a natural human impulse, right? I wanted the people who are supposed to be in charge of our affairs to be smarter than we are. I wanted them to know more. I wanted them to be better at their jobs than I would be. And I can't say as the afternoon went on that I was filled with confidence, to say the least."

He stressed that the issue is not partisan, saying the desperate need for competence "sure as hell manifested itself in the midterm." "This is not to say that the Democrats, if they were in charge, would somehow magically be better at dealing with the FAA. I'm not saying that," Meacham said. "But you want people — it's just a basic human impulse, right? We want the public sector to do certain basic things well. And pointing fingers back at a former president or whatever, it doesn't do any good, right?"

Such turbulence, he suggested, may cater to Trump's impulse to keep the conversation controversial and entertaining. Meacham recalled Trump saying in 2017 that he wanted his presidency to be like a reality show in which he "vanquishes my opponents."

"Okay, he thinks it's a reality show, but it's our reality," Meacham said.

The interview video is available on MS Now's "Morning Joe" via YouTube: watch the segment. The original report appeared on Alternet: Historian Jon Meacham warns Trump's 'incompetence' is spooking Americans.