NewsMacroHouse Republicans Brace for Leadership Fight as Minority Status Looms

House Republicans Brace for Leadership Fight as Minority Status Looms

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Rep. Jim Jordan is widely expected to run for House minority leader if Republicans lose their majority, positioning him against Speaker Mike Johnson and Majority Leader Steve Scalise.
  • •Winning the minority leader post requires only a simple majority on a secret ballot, a far lower bar than the 218 votes Jordan failed to secure in his three 2023 Speaker bids.
  • •Jordan's opponents are using his alleged relationship with former Speaker Kevin McCarthy to sink his candidacy, with Republicans still furious over McCarthy's pre-election comments that Republicans would lose the election.
  • •Anonymous GOP critics claim McCarthy is coaching Jordan partly out of his rivalry with Steve Scalise and a desire to regain relevancy and lobbying access.
  • •Republicans are divided over Jordan's candidacy, with some saying he is no longer the Tea Party firebrand of 2010 while others wary of MAGA influence are likely to back Scalise.
House Republicans Brace for Leadership Fight as Minority Status Looms

House Republicans are already turning on one another as they confront the prospect of a new minority status, with an internal leadership fight taking shape even before the midterm results are settled.

Countless polls are predicting the GOP tumbling into minority status, but the party must still hammer out who will lead it in a diminished position. According to Sources Say News, members are already squaring off around Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), who is "widely expected to run" for the top job if Republicans lose their majority. Jordan has coveted the leadership spot before, but his ambition would likely pit him against the current, embattled Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) and Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-La.).

The post carries real weight: the minority leader is the party's top figure in the chamber, its chief spokesman and strategist, and the person tasked with steering the conference's response to the majority's agenda — which is why contested races for the job tend to expose a caucus's deepest divides. In recent cycles, House conferences have settled their leadership posts in the weeks after Election Day, leaving a compressed window for rivals to line up votes before the next Congress convenes.

The contest for minority leader can be just as bloody, because a victory requires only a simple majority on a secret ballot — a much lower bar, Sources Say reporter Juliegrace Brufke explains, than the 218 votes Jordan failed to secure three times in 2023, when the prize was the Speaker's gavel awarded by a vote of the full House.

Jordan's enemies, however, are looking to use his alleged relationship with former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy to sink his candidacy.

"Kevin is rooting for us to fail every day. And it shows. I mean, people hate that. They're not just ambivalent," one lawmaker told Sources Say News. "Is Newt Gingrich out there as a former speaker, saying anything other than, this is how the Republicans can win?"

Republicans remain furious that McCarthy, out of Congress for nearly three years, appeared on Bloomberg TV days before Election Day and slammed the GOP's many mistakes in the months leading up to November.

"It's not that the Democrats are going to win this election. Republicans are going to lose it," McCarthy told Bloomberg.

"If I was Jim Jordan and I wanted to lead the Republican conference, I wouldn't pick up the Kevin McCarthy playbook," former Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), who led the effort to oust McCarthy in 2023, told Sources Say News.

Republican critics speaking anonymously also say McCarthy is driven to coach Jordan because of his heated rivalry with Scalise, but they claim the former leader is also scraping for relevancy and an easier path to lobby people at the top.

"I feel like it's interesting the USS McCarthy is looking to float again. It's like so typical," another GOP lawmaker told Sources Say News.

Some GOP members told Brufke that Jordan is no longer the "Tea Party bomb-thrower of 2010."

"For people like me, who have not seen the Jim Jordan of 2010, the Tea Party Jim Jordan ... it's a very, very different Jordan," one lawmaker told Sources Say News.

There are plenty of others, however, who are leery of more MAGA trouble and where it has gotten the party today, Brufke reports.

"There are enough members, I think, still left who kind of remember the Jim Jordan of old, and so they're probably going to be more in the Scalise camp. But Jim's been very active all around the country and I think he's probably calling a lot of members," another lawmaker told Sources Say News.

For now, the fight remains informal. The midterm outcome will determine whether the job even comes open, and a formal declaration from Jordan — or an organized counter-movement behind Johnson or Scalise — would turn the current jockeying into a defined race.