NewsStocksHome Depot Tops Q3 Estimates as Spending Improves, but Weak Traffic and Margin Pressure Cloud the Picture

Home Depot Tops Q3 Estimates as Spending Improves, but Weak Traffic and Margin Pressure Cloud the Picture

Author: ForexLive·

Key Takeaways

  • •Home Depot posted third-quarter adjusted earnings of $3.86 per share and revenue of $43.4 billion, both exceeding analyst expectations.
  • •Comparable sales increased 2.2%, but customer transactions fell 0.5%, indicating growth was driven by a higher average ticket of $93.09 rather than more frequent visits.
  • •Shares declined 1.9% in premarket trading after the company lowered its operating margin outlook, which executives attributed entirely to a product mix shift toward lower-margin categories.
  • •Full-year guidance implies adjusted EPS of roughly $14.98, slightly below the $15.05 analysts expected, even as the total sales growth forecast was raised to the top of the prior range.
  • •Elevated mortgage costs have suppressed housing turnover, and management said the market is softer than expected at the start of the year, though the company is taking market share.
Home Depot Tops Q3 Estimates as Spending Improves, but Weak Traffic and Margin Pressure Cloud the Picture

Home Depot reported better-than-expected third-quarter earnings and sales on Tuesday, though shares slipped 1.9% in premarket trading as the company contends with margin pressure. It is the first of the major US retailers to report results this week, and as the largest home improvement retailer in the United States, its quarterly numbers are typically read as a gauge of household repair-and-remodel demand.

The home improvement giant posted adjusted earnings of $3.86 per share, ahead of the $3.84 expected, while revenue of $43.4 billion topped the $42.8 billion consensus.

The more revealing figures sit deeper in the report, offering clues about the health of the US consumer.

Comparable sales rose 2.2% in the quarter, matching a 2.2% increase in the United States. That marks an improvement from the 0.2% growth reported a year earlier and points to some stabilization in home improvement spending.

The composition of that growth, however, is telling:

  • Comparable sales: +2.2%
  • Comparable customer transactions: -0.5%
  • Comparable average ticket: +3.0%
  • Average ticket: $93.09 versus $90.39 a year ago

In other words, customers are spending more when they visit Home Depot but are visiting and buying less often. The pattern resembles inflation more than a resurgent consumer, though there is some sequential improvement: transactions fell 1.6% in the same quarter last year, so the pace of decline has moderated considerably. Even so, the recovery in spending is being driven by larger tickets rather than more frequent purchases.

The company does not break down how much of the increase in average ticket reflects inflation, larger projects, or customers opting for more expensive products, which makes it difficult to draw conclusions about real consumption.

Another complication is Home Depot's growing professional contractor business, including its acquisitions of SRS Distribution and GMS. That segment is increasingly important to total revenues but does not necessarily reflect the spending decisions of ordinary households.

Home Depot has also been fighting a difficult housing market and is particularly exposed to interest rates. Elevated mortgage costs have kept homeowners locked into existing properties and depressed housing turnover, a major lever for renovation and improvement spending.

On guidance, Home Depot now expects full-year comparable sales growth of 1.4% and adjusted earnings growth of approximately 2%. The earnings forecast implies adjusted EPS of roughly $14.98, slightly below the $15.05 analysts had expected. The company also lowered its operating margin outlook to the bottom of its previous range, even as it moved its total sales growth forecast to the top of the prior range — a disappointing combination.

Revenue rose 4.9% in the quarter, but operating income increased just 2.4%, suggesting that stronger sales are not translating into much additional profitability. That raises the question of whether retailers start pulling the price-hike lever, adding to consumer inflation.

For the US economic outlook, the report can be characterized as mildly encouraging but far from a signal that the consumer is roaring. Today's US October advance retail sales report was also solid. The slowdown in transaction declines is a positive sign and argues against a sharp deterioration in household spending. At the same time, the continued decline in traffic suggests consumers remain selective, particularly when it comes to expensive discretionary home improvement projects.

For now, the message is that the US consumer is holding up, but there is still considerable reluctance to spend. With other major US retailers reporting later this week, the upcoming results will show whether that caution is fading or becoming more entrenched.

Update — notes from the earnings call:

  • Executives said the market is softer than they expected at the start of the year, but the company is taking market share.
  • They said the margin decline was strictly due to a different product mix, meaning the company is selling more in low-margin categories.