GOP Caught in a 'Trap of Its Own Making' Over Anti-Muslim Bigotry, Conservative Pollster Says
Key Takeaways
- •Focus group pollster Sarah Longwell found that the GOP's midterm strategy of stoking fears about transgender people and immigrants failed to mobilize voters effectively.
- •Anti-Muslim sentiment has become entrenched among a portion of the Republican base, appearing in focus groups about Abdul El-Sayed's Michigan Senate run, Vivek Ramaswamy's Ohio gubernatorial campaign, and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
- •Longwell traced the rise in anti-Muslim attitudes to rhetoric from Republican leaders such as Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and right-wing media figures, with similar concerns voiced by respondents in Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania.
- •Following the election, more repeat Trump voters expressed dismay about the perceived impact of Muslim voters on the results.
- •Longwell concluded the GOP faces a choice between feeding anti-Muslim sentiment and alienating voters who prioritize the cost of living, or abandoning the theme and ignoring a growing base concern, making the party's rebuilding effort more difficult.

The Republican Party's attempt to salvage the midterm elections by ginning up hysteria about minorities and marginalized groups fell horribly flat — and, according to one top conservative pollster, it has also left the party caught in a "trap of its own making" that could further jeopardize its ability to rebuild.
Sarah Longwell is the publisher of The Bulwark, a center-right, anti-Trump publication, and an accomplished focus group pollster noted for her extensive study of how everyday voters conceive of the Trump era. Focus groups — moderated small-group discussions used across politics to probe how voters react to candidates and messaging — are the backbone of her work, giving her an early read on shifts inside the Republican coalition. In her latest piece, published Sunday, she detailed how the GOP's effort to mobilize its base with fears about transgender people and immigrants failed miserably — but also left one portion of its base locked in on anti-Muslim bigotry that could leave the party imperiled going forward.
"But there were some voters with whom all the fearmongering about Muslims specifically really sank in," Longwell explained. "Some of this has already popped up in focus groups this year about Abdul El-Sayed and even Vivek Ramaswamy. Zohran Mamdani is occasionally also in the mix, natch. Islamophobia is now a major part of the Republican Triangle of Doom — the voters have heard it from the politicians (like Greg Abbott) and right-wing media figures, so now they're going to demand to hear more and more of it. It's going to make it incredibly difficult for the GOP to rebuild: They can either play into the bigotry and alienate people who would rather hear about things like the cost of living, or they can abandon the bigotry and thereby ignore one of their base's growing concerns."
The names she runs through show how far the issue has traveled: El-Sayed is running for Senate in Michigan, Ramaswamy for governor in Ohio, and Mamdani — a Muslim — is mayor of New York City, with all three figures the subject of Longwell's focus groups this year.
Longwell explained that the drift toward anti-Muslim sentiment among right-wing voters began to creep into her focus group sessions earlier in the year, especially in Texas, where Gov. Greg Abbott and other party leaders have leaned hard into Islamophobia in recent years. Now, in the aftermath of the election, she noted that more "multi-time Trump voters" were expressing dismay about the impact of Muslim voters on the results.
One 75-year-old Texas resident called it "a little heartbreaking" that "people that maybe don't have America's best interest are able to vote and move in and begin to change our laws."
"I've heard a little bit about some of the elementary schools, books they're putting in front of little elementary kids," the respondent said. "They call it a religion, but it's the Muslim politics [that] are put in front of our school kids, and the sharia law, and the aspects of sharia."
Conservative respondents from across the country — including in Georgia, North Carolina and Pennsylvania, at least — voiced similar concerns about Muslims in the United States, which Longwell attributed to inflammatory rhetoric from elected leaders.
Moving forward, she concluded, this shift among Republican voters could make it extremely difficult for the party to shed the bigoted image crafted by Donald Trump and the MAGA movement. How that tension plays out — whether candidates keep feeding the base's demand or pivot to pocketbook themes like the cost of living that many voters say they would rather hear about — is the fork Longwell identifies, and her ongoing focus groups offer a running gauge of where base voters stand.
"This is one of the essential difficulties for Republicans who might want to calibrate away from Trump's brazenly racist GOP after getting annihilated in the midterms: Republican base voters won't let them," she wrote.
A clip of Longwell's analysis was shared by The Bulwark on X.
This article is based on reporting originally published by Alternet.