NewsMacroHarry Enten: Fetterman's Disapproval Among Pennsylvania Democrats Is 'Off the Page'

Harry Enten: Fetterman's Disapproval Among Pennsylvania Democrats Is 'Off the Page'

Author: Alternet·

Key Takeaways

  • •Fetterman's net popularity among Pennsylvania Democrats has plunged 112 points in two years, from plus 56 to minus 56.
  • •The senator has shifted to the right since his 2022 victory, frequently breaking with his party and backing President Trump on matters involving U.S. support for Israel.
  • •Enten compared Fetterman's party approval to senators who lost reelection primaries, noting even Lisa Murkowski was only 15 points underwater in 2010 and later won reelection as a write-in candidate.
  • •Based on historical patterns, Enten said Fetterman is almost certain to lose a 2028 Democratic primary if he enters it.
  • •Key indicators to watch are whether Fetterman ultimately runs in the 2028 primary and whether his standing among Pennsylvania Democrats improves.
Harry Enten: Fetterman's Disapproval Among Pennsylvania Democrats Is 'Off the Page'

Senator John Fetterman is widely expected to face a difficult road to reelection, but according to CNN's top polling analyst Harry Enten, that pessimism actually "undersells" how much trouble the Pennsylvania Democrat is in, with his disapproval numbers running "off the page."

Fetterman won his Senate seat in 2022 as a progressive candidate, but has shifted unmistakably to the right during his tenure, frequently breaking with the rest of his party on certain issues and backing President Donald Trump, particularly on matters involving U.S. support for Israel. Those factors have combined to produce historically bleak reelection prospects should he choose to run again as a Democrat in 2028. Because Senate primaries are decided by each party's own voters, his net standing among Pennsylvania Democrats serves as a direct gauge of his viability in that contest.

Appearing in a Monday morning segment on the senator, Enten argued that even the doomsaying surrounding Fetterman has not fully captured the true scope of how much voters now despise him, pointing to one particularly striking slide that showed just how dramatically his popularity has collapsed in Pennsylvania. Net popularity — approval minus disapproval — is one of the most basic gauges of an incumbent's standing with a given group of voters.

"Sometimes a slide says it all, and you literally get the inverse on it," Enten said. "Look at this, [among] Pennsylvania Dems: John Fetterman is not popular. You know, you go back two years ago, [his net popularity] was plus 56 points. It's literally the inverse. Now it's literally the inverse; it's negative 56 points. That is a change of... 112 points in the negative direction... In just two years time, Pennsylvania Democrats despise, they hate, hate, hate John Fetterman."

Enten went on to explain that host John Berman was considerably "underselling" the situation when he described Fetterman as facing a "challenging" reelection bid in 2028. He presented a chart comparing the party approval ratings of senators who went on to lose a reelection primary, with figures ranging from former Sen. Bob Smith, who was 15 points above water with voters, down to Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who was 15 points underwater when she lost a reelection primary bid in 2010, though she was later successfully reelected as a write-in candidate — a reminder that a primary defeat does not by itself end a Senate career.

"When it comes to senators who would run for reelection and then lost the primary, simply put, there is no historical analogy that quite fits the moment right now of just how unpopular John Fetterman is," Enten explained. "If he runs in a Democratic primary, unless, I don't know, we're literally moved to planet Krypton, he is almost certainly going to lose that primary based upon what we see, historically speaking. Normally, if you're running in a primary as a senator, if you're at about, let's say, zero points, as many approve as disapprove, you would be in trouble. And he's down at negative 56 points among Pennsylvania Democrats. He's really in a deep load of you-know-what." The markers to watch from here are whether Fetterman ultimately enters a 2028 Democratic primary and whether his net standing among Pennsylvania Democrats moves in the meantime.